Pie Five Pizza Menu – Stillwater, OK

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Stillwater, OK

Pie Five Pizza is personal craft pizza with unlimited toppings for one price in only 5 minutes! Options available for most dietary restrictions, including Gluten free crust, a lower carb Cauliflower crust, vegan cheese and for those just wanting an everyday pizza there’s plenty of fresh veggies and meats to choose from to create your own craft pizza.

Sleek counter-serve chain serving design-your-own pizza baked in 5 minutes, plus salads. Based on 309 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $

Pie Five Pizza 74075

Address:
611 N Perkins Rd Ste A Ste A, Stillwater, OK 74075

Phone: (405) 372-2177

Website: https://www.piefivepizza.com/

Menu

Large Pizzas
Build Your 14″ Pie
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust. Choose up to 2 sauce: Tuscan Marinara Sauce, Spicy Marinara Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Ranch Sauce, Olive Oil. Would you prefer different cheese for whole pie?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese (Whole Pie), Substitute Parmesan Cheese (Whole Pie), Substitute Ricotta Cheese (Whole Pie), Substitute Vegan Cheese (Whole Pie) : $3. Would you prefer different cheese for left half?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese (Left Half), Substitute Parmesan Cheese (Left Half), Substitute Ricotta Cheese (Left Half), Substitute Vegan Cheese (Left Half) : $3. Would you prefer different cheese for right half?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese (Right Half), Substitute Parmesan Cheese (Right Half), Substitute Ricotta Cheese (Right Half), Substitute Vegan Cheese (Right Half) : $3. Choose a meat on the whole pie: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni (Whole Pie), Grilled Chicken (Whole Pie), Natural Beef (Whole Pie), Italian Sausage (Whole Pie), Bacon (Whole Pie). Choose a meat on the left half: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni (Left Half), Grilled Chicken (Left Half), Natural Beef (Left Half), Italian Sausage (Left Half), Bacon (Left Half). Choose a meat on the right half: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni (Right Half), Grilled Chicken (Right Half), Natural Beef (Right Half), Italian Sausage (Right Half), Bacon (Right Half). Would you like whole toppings?: Red Onions (Whole Pie), Mushrooms (Whole Pie), Green Olives (Whole Pie), Black Olives (Whole Pie), Kalamata Olives (Whole Pie). Would you like toppings on the left half?: Red Onions (Left Half), Mushrooms (Left Half), Green Olives (Left Half), Black Olives (Left Half), Kalamata Olives (Left Half). Would you like toppings on the right half?: Red Onions (Right Half), Mushrooms (Right Half), Green Olives (Right Half), Black Olives (Right Half), Kalamata Olives (Right Half). Would you like to add condiments?: Add Magic Dust, Add Crushed Red Pepper.		 $14.99
5 Star 14″ Pizza
Tuscan marinara, mozzarella, cheddar, Italian sausage, pepperoni, beef, green olives, red and green peppers, black olives, and red onions. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $3. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add condiments?: Add Magic Dust, Add Crushed Red Pepper.		 $14.99
11″ Pizzas
Build Your 11″ Pie
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose up to 2 sauce: Tuscan Marinara Sauce, Spicy Marinara Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Ranch Sauce, Olive Oil. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $7.59
5 Star 11″ Pizza
Tuscan marinara, mozzarella, cheddar, Italian sausage, pepperoni, beef, green olives, red and green peppers, black olives, and red onions. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $7.59
11″ Pizzas with Dessert and Drink
Build Your 11″ Pizza With Dessert And Drink
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose up to 2 sauce: Tuscan Marinara Sauce, Spicy Marinara Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Ranch Sauce, Olive Oil. Choose a dessert: Chocolate Chip Brownie Slice, Ultimate Brownie Slice, Cinnamon Stix : $1. Choose a drink: Bottled Water, Bottled Coke, Bottled Honest Peach Tea, Bottled Sprite : $0.30. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $10.99
5 Star 11″ Pizza With Dessert And Drink
Tuscan marinara, mozzarella, cheddar, Italian sausage, pepperoni, beef, green olives, red and green peppers, black olives, and red onions. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose a dessert: Chocolate Chip Brownie Slice, Ultimate Brownie Slice, Cinnamon Stix : $1. Choose a drink: Bottled Water, Bottled Coke, Bottled Honest Peach Tea, Bottled Sprite : $0.30. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $10.99
11″ Pizzas with Side Salad and Drink
Build Your 11″ Pizza With Side Salad And Drink
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose up to 2 sauce: Tuscan Marinara Sauce, Spicy Marinara Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Ranch Sauce, Olive Oil. Choose a side salad: Caesar Salad, Garden Salad, Classic Italian Salad. Choose a salad dressing: Ranch Dressing, Caesar Dressing, Fat-free Italian Dressing, House Vinaigrette, Greek Vinaigrette. Choose a drink: Bottled Water, Bottled Coke, Bottled Honest Peach Tea, Bottled Sprite : $0.30. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $11.99
5 Star 11″ Pizza With Side Salad And Drink
Tuscan marinara, mozzarella, cheddar, Italian sausage, pepperoni, beef, green olives, red and green peppers, black olives, and red onions. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose a side salad: Caesar Salad, Garden Salad, Classic Italian Salad. Choose a salad dressing: Ranch Dressing, Caesar Dressing, Fat-free Italian Dressing, House Vinaigrette, Greek Vinaigrette. Choose a drink: Bottled Water, Bottled Coke, Bottled Honest Peach Tea, Bottled Sprite : $0.30. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $11.99
11″ Pizzas with Breadsticks and Drink
Build Your 11″ Pizza With Breadsticks And Drink
Be creative! Design your own personal pizza by picking a crust, sauce, cheese, and any toppings you want. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose up to 2 sauce: Tuscan Marinara Sauce, Spicy Marinara Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Ranch Sauce, Olive Oil. Choose a breadstix: Garlic Butter Breadsticks, Cheesy Breadsticks : $1, Bacon Cheesy Breadsticks : $1.50. Choose a sauce: Garlic Butter Sauce, Marinara Sauce, Ranch Sauce. Choose a drink: Bottled Water, Bottled Coke, Bottled Honest Peach Tea, Bottled Sprite : $0.30. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $12.99
5 Star 11″ Pizza With Breadsticks And Drink
Tuscan marinara, mozzarella, cheddar, Italian sausage, pepperoni, beef, green olives, red and green peppers, black olives, and red onions. Choose a crust: Crispy Thin Crust, Classic Pan Crust, Traditional Italian Crust, Gluten-free Crust : $2, Cauliflower Crust : $2.50. Choose a breadstix: Garlic Butter Breadsticks, Cheesy Breadsticks : $1, Bacon Cheesy Breadsticks : $1.50. Choose a sauce: Garlic Butter Sauce, Marinara Sauce, Ranch Sauce. Choose a drink: Bottled Water, Bottled Coke, Bottled Honest Peach Tea, Bottled Sprite : $0.30. Would you prefer different cheese?: Substitute Cheddar Cheese, Substitute Parmesan Cheese, Substitute Ricotta Cheese, Substitute Mozzarella Cheese, Substitute Vegan Cheese : $2. Choose a meats: Naturally Smoked Pepperoni, Grilled Chicken, All Natural Beef, Italian Sausage, Bacon. Choose a toppings: Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Olives, Black Olives, Kalamata Olives. Would you like to add a fresh finish?: Add Basil Pesto Rizzle, Add Sun-dried Tomato Puree, Add Chopped Cilantro, Add Feta, Add Fresh Basil.		 $12.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Amanda Harrist
Something has happened recently– new owner or manager?– and the quality is going downhill quickly. They are often out of crusts and other ingredients; it’s dirty; the staff isn’t friendly like it used to be. They start putting chairs up on tables before 8 o’clock even though they don’t close until 9 and it give the story a creepy feel. I have made two online orders only to arrive and no one had noticed that the orders had come in; when I complained about this (in a reasonable voice) I was treated super rudely. Too bad, it used to be one of the best one places in town,

… more

Dustin Murphy
Always enjoy the place and the pizza is fairly priced for what you order. Think of this place as a subway for pizza, which honestly, makes it quite the fun visit every once in a while. Except there’s a catch: Don’t expect to get a lot of toppings sprinkled on without asking.

… more

Peter Richtsmeier
Good pizza! We like the focus on personal pizzas, the selection of toppings, and the option to get a salad with your meal. Occasionally, the toppings and lettuce are not the freshest, but there’re always enough options to be able to pick something else. The interior is simple but pleasant, and there is patio seating for nice days.

… more

Matt Cross
Excellent handmade pizza! Must try!!

… more

RawrsALot
It’s okay. The gluten free is pretty bland and extra cheese is $2 more. So a tiny pizza is really expensive. I do like the subway style veggie bar. There’s enough people who have food allergies for them to carry better crust though. And at a cheaper price.

… more

James Hudson
Fast service. Nice atmosphere. Custom-made, personal-size pizza just the way you like it best. They also have a gluten-free crust option (for only $2 more) for people like me who are sensitive to or allergic to gluten.

… more

Tina Clingings
I really enjoyed it, I liked that you can choose all the toppings like building a burrito, sub-sandwich etc. Even got a free small Pizza for my husbands birthday. Would’ve given 5☆, but we ordered 2 of the SAME pizza’s and they were clearly 2 different pizzas. I’ll go again for sure

… more

Ignacio Carranza
The place was literally empty and service was substandard. I ordered a personal pizza and the cheese was hardly melted. When the manager pulled it off the oven, he didn’t even offer to run it again just to make it more appealing. He just cut it and boxed it up. It looked no better than a frozen pizza from the supermarket.

… more

Angel M
Called in two large pizzas tonight for pick-up: both specialty pizzas. When my husband picked them up, they were personal pan pizzas; neither the size nor crust that were ordered. One pizza was undercooked with raw onions on it and the other had unappetizingly large slices of tomato (1/4 of the tomato) as well as pineapple pieces. Our past experiences have all been delicious, but this entire visit was extremely disappointing. Will not be returning or recommending this business.

… more

Abigail Davis
I love Pie Five and my fiancé and I love to eat here, but tonight we did not have the usual great experience we normally have. I preordered my food on the app and when I arrived the order was incorrect. My pizza literally did not even have cheese on it, and I ordered a cheese pizza. The staff member asked if I wanted it to be corrected and I obviously said yes. After this banter, I watched the employee go to the back of the store and grab the dough for my pizza with his bare hands, then put gloves on to continue to make the pizza. I didn’t say anything because I figured the heat from the oven would kill bacteria from his hands. After the pizza was made, a different staff member shoved the pizza crust into the box, again with bare hands, and did not offer to add any of the extra seasonings we love. I normally have a great experience at Pie Five, but my experience tonight was very disappointing.

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Little Caesars Pizza Menu – Stillwater, OK
  2. Arby’s Menu – Stillwater, OK
  3. Cafe 88 Menu – Stillwater, OK
  4. Subway Menu – Stillwater, OK

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch