A local, authentic pizzeria brought to you by Chef Nicholas St. Clair & his wife Alison St. Clair, of Top 100 Restaurant in America, Antebellum, in addition to Roland Stanley of Cork It in Gainesville. Peyton’s Pie Company – named after his son, Peyton.
Based on 32 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
118 Main St SW Suite E, Gainesville, GA 30501
Phone: (678) 943-2900
Hours
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jeb Napier
In the gainesville area this is one of my favorite pizza pie places. We have tried most of the pies they offer and all have been awesome. 🙂 Has a very good relaxed atmosphere. The pies themselves have nice thin crispy crust and chewy pizza bone. The fresh toppings rock. The Greasy New Yorker is one of my favorites along with the SFC.
… more
Kayla Courson
An amazing spot on the square! The shared spaced is the perfect atmosphere especially right next to Cork It, the best pizza place on the square and in the Gainesville area. Very nice staff and they always have on a smile. Archie is the nicest and was so helpful! I only have great things to say about Peyton’s and their staff. You have to check it out if you’re on the square!!
… more
Connor Legault
My experience at Peyton’s could not have been more wonderful!!! Immediately walking into the building you’re greeted with such a wonderful aroma. I was blown away by the service, and also amazed how quickly my order came out. By far THE BEST pizza I’ve had in Georgia. And might even be the best I’ve had…. GO TRY THIS PLACE
… more
Jesse Lee
Top notch artisanal pizza! Delicious! Great price. Love the venue space as well with wine bar and live music.
… more
Kelly V
Absolutely the best pizza place in Gainesville! And their crème brûlée was the perfect treat to finish out my meal. Outstanding food. Amazing service. Excellent all around. Can’t wait to come back!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… more
Tom Newman
Very good wood fired pizza..We had the margherita pizza and it was better than expected..We were going to eat at Atlas but we were ignored at outside table so we left and happily we did..We will be back! If you have not given Peytons a try,you need to.!
… more
Erika Benitez
Favorite pizza spot, they have a great variety of pizzas with fresh ingredients cooked just a few feet away from you! Not just a pizza place but an experience!
… more
Jillian Galli Allen
Pizza is so good and the staff are wonderful! Favorite pizza in Gainesville; try the hot honey!
… more
Mariana Alarcon
Top tier authentic pizza! Definitely recommend ‘My Honey is Hotter than yours.’ Definitely worth the money! Will definitely be going back!
… more
Stephanie Lewis
So delicious! I wish I got a picture but we ate it too fast! We got regular cheese and the My Hot is Hotter Than Yours and wow, so good.
… more
… View more