Nestled in the heart of Evansville, Indiana, Penny Lane Coffeehouse stands as a beloved beacon of comfort and community. With its warm ambiance, exceptional coffee, and welcoming atmosphere, this cozy café has become a cherished destination for locals and visitors alike.
Upon entering Penny Lane Coffeehouse, guests are enveloped in a sense of warmth and tranquility. The interior exudes a rustic charm, with exposed brick walls, reclaimed wood accents, and soft lighting that casts a gentle glow throughout the space. Comfortable seating arrangements, including plush couches, wooden tables, and cozy nooks, invite patrons to settle in and stay awhile.
Cheerful, sunlit coffeehouse with a hip vibe, serving up espresso drinks, organic teas & sandwiches. Based on 694 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
600 SE 2nd St, Evansville, IN 47713
Phone: (812) 421-8741
Website: http://www.pennylanecoffeehouse.com/
Hours
| Sunday |
8 AM–5 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
7 AM–6 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
7 AM–6 PM |
| Wednesday |
7 AM–6 PM |
| Thursday |
7 AM–6 PM |
| Friday |
7 AM–6 PM |
| Saturday |
8 AM–5 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Josh B
this place is just a whole total vibe. It’s so cool inside there with local artwork on the wall, items that can be purchased from local people. And then the selections for the food and drink. Man, they’ve got some great looking sandwiches I went with the smoothie today and was not disappointing at all. We tried two different kinds, and both of them were just incredible. I don’t really feel like you’re going to go wrong with anything that you get here. Staff was extremely friendly, and the restaurant itself was clean. If you’re downtown in Evansville, and you want a good place to stop by and give this one a shot.
… more
Andrew Utter
This coffee shop is mid. Iced coffee was warm upon arrival and was also not very “coffee” strong. While working in the shop for awhile, I noticed the air vents were fuzzy which was kinda surprising.
… more
Jaime Haney
I love their smoothies and croissant sandwiches. The staff is awesome and so helpful when I’m there to hang my artwork or just get a bite to eat and relax with friends. They’re one of the few local businesses that support local artists by providing us a great place to display and sell our artwork.
… more
Kimberly Charles
Delicious breakfast sandwiches, smoothies, and coffees. Long line in a small space on weekends. Decent prices, nice outdoor seating.
… more
Alana Roberts
Always a pleasure. Popular walk-to location. Can be hard to find seating, though there’s some outside. Breakfast sandwiches, lunch, coffee, and tea. Water bottles for sale as well as Jones Sodas in the fridge. Free water in cups from a spigot on the counter.
… more
K Housman
What a great place! It’s a chill vibe with great service! My husband and I came in when they were experiencing a broken smoothie machine, and we couldn’t get what we wanted, but they had some nice cold drinks for only $1 that hit the spot for the moment. We will be back!
… more
Khaleesi
Oh my damn!!! I usually drink black coffee, a neighbor & I visited one day & he got the White Rabbit (hot) I took a sip & I was HOOKED!!! My favorites are Large instant karma & White Rabbit. I tried an iced IK & the special coffee Salted Caramel Turtle latte (hot) love their muffins & B & G is pretty good.. their breakfast croissants are delicious!!! I love to support local & go back as often as I can… always look @ the local artists pieces on the wall & jewelry they sell.. nice selection of books & very quaint little coffee shop. Wishing they’ll open a shop in Newburgh (closet to home)
… more
Jess Ehm
The very best neighborhood coffee shop!
… more
Miranda Terry
This was my go to coffee shop for a long time when I lived in Evansville- I have been in Colorado the past few years. I absolutely loved coming here whether it was to pick up my morning breakfast, meet a friend here for lunch, or swing by for a treat after walking along the greenway path.
… more
Jeff Pellman
This is a cute shop in cute neighborhood. Everybody seems to know each other. It’s worth a stop to sit outside and enjoy your favorite coffee and just watch the world go by.
… more
… View more
