Penn Street Pizza is owned by Alan Miles. Alan owned and operated Fox’s Pizza for over 37 years at the same location at 500 West Penn Street . In February 2017 Alan left the Fox’s franchise and opened Penn Street Pizza ! Alan is no longer associated or affiliated with Fox’s Pizza in any way ! Alan is Butler’s longest running owner/operator in the pizza business. Alan has been serving the Butler area for 39 years since he began in August of 1980 .
Penn Street Pizza offers only the best with fresh local produce and fresh ingredients. Our meats and cheeses are hand sliced daily ! The secret to the best Hoagies , Stromboli and Pizza is the oven ! We use the best ovens. Blodgett brick deck gas ovens cook slow unlike conveyor ovens !
Come try
Laid-back chain serving specialty pizzas in varied shapes & sizes, plus sandwiches, salads & sides. Based on 193 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
500 W Penn St, Butler, PA 16001
Phone: (724) 285-7200
Website: http://pennstreetpizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday |
3 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday |
4–11 PM |
| Monday |
3–11 PM |
| Tuesday |
3–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Julie Holt
Ordered 2 mediums and waffle fries and i would have been better off going into my freezer and making a Tombstone. The crust was obviously a frozen shell with toppings thrown on. You know how when you put freezer burnt waffle fries in the oven the edges get burnt but the middle isn’t even cooked. Thats what they were. And the wait was and hour and a half. For frozen garbage. Never again.
… more
Tammy Hartle
Got take out. Saw good reviews so decided to try it. Got pepperoni pizza and a steak and cheese wedge. We enjoyed both. I will be back.
… more
Lucas LeFevre
The best pizza we ever had in Butler!! The pizza was so delicious and with so many flavor could choose that we even visited the pizza shop twice in the same day! Guy who awnsered the phone was so kind and his voice was hot(kinda got me wet).Delivery boy was kinda cute, just wish i asked for those digits.
… more
kailee loschen
amazing! very clean, delicious food, kind employees and owner! best local pizza shop!
… more
Nathan Thompson
This place is AWESOME, despite the bad reviews. Yes it can take 45 mins for a carryout order, but come on, they have two single brick ovens! Brick oven pizza is so much better then all the other chain pizzas. Pizza is pizza, nothing to go writing home about. The wedges although, are fantastic and the best wedge I’ve had around! Best part of the place is the service. Perhaps some of the best service around town, can really tell pride is put into their work. I have been coming here for many years and will continue to do so, unless something drastically changes!
… more
Jordan Wagner
I genuinely think they gave me just a frozen pizza, and it took an hour to receive it.
… more
Storm W
Been eating Alan’s pizza since I was like 2.. I never get tired of it. Best Salads and wedges around.
… more
dey k
Amazing stromboli!
… more
Curtis Mahood
Alan and his staff are great to deal with and their salads and wedgies are amazing!
… more
Jeffry Hysong
UPDATE: I tried this place again a few years after my initial review and I haven’t had any problems with their service for some time now. Their Turkey Bacon Cheddar Wedgie is probably the best food to be found in Butler. All of my recent experiences with them were positive and tasty.
… more
… View more
