Based on 811 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
871 Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901
Phone: (631) 369-7758
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 7 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dorothy Rodger
Really nice brunch! A good, classic, family owned and operated diner. Delicious Greek salad piled with feta and topped with chicken souvlaki. My family enjoyed their eggs and pancakes. The chocolate chip pancakes are melt in your mouth good. Food came out very fast. Service was great!
… more
Sam GB
We ordered a meal and we let the server know that the meal did not taste fresh and tasted very sour like it was spoiled. she said it was made all fresh that day since they are closing the next day for a few weeks. I also noticed the other meal I ordered was not what it was supposed to be and everything just tasted super off and spoiled. They reassured me that everything is made fresh.
… more
Steven Tringali
This was our first time at the Peconic Bay Diner. We had an awesome time. The food there was amazing!
… more
Justin Conway
Rip off!
… more
Russell Skadl
Been there twice now in the past two months. Attentive accurate service. Excellent wait staff! Food quality met expectations for what you should expect from a Long Island Diner. Even our picky eater was satisfied with their order. Food was served promptly. The soups are very good. Prices reasonable. The Diner was at medium capacity, but even so we were able to enjoy a nice quiet meal. Not loud or crowded like other places. Good location for anyone with sensory issues. Bathrooms were clean. Overall positive experience.
… more
Bob
Probably the worst diner experience I’ve ever had. I knew eggs came in large and extra lodge, but I didn’t know eggs came in extra small! The home fries weren’t even cooked. It was like eating a raw potato that was browned on the outside. I felt rushed out of the diner. I was there for 10 minutes eating before the waitress come over and slept the bill on my table. That’s when I told her about the home fries and she didn’t even seem to care even though she did get me another portion. That one wasn’t much better. So I decided to leave without finishing. My recommendation would be to find a diner, any other diner, even if it means driving an hour, then eat here! The hour drive in any direction has to be worth it compared to what this place sells as breakfast.
… more
Glenn
Heading out east….now to find a diner! Good call…Peconic Bay diner. Socially distant aware, friendly service. Good coffee! (And hot too!) plenty of refills! Even a chance to sit and read the Sunday paper! Stop by!!
… more
Gwen Pidgeon
Hometown long island, the quintessential diner experience. From genuinely HAPPY, friendly servers (my beautiful server Diane was actually humming a happy tune!) to extra speedy food prep, this place delivers! Food was delicious, short stack of pancakes was great, fluffy and full of chocolate chips, the eggs over easy were well prepared, arrived with a big portion of home fries and nice toast with butter.
… more
Dea-Rey Caliguri
What a great place. Loved it
… more
Lorrie Mitchell
Food was good. Jennifer, our server was great. She brought things to the table that you didn’t have to ask for. She is a professional.
… more
… View more