A staple of in Downtown Indy and now in Fishers! We’re a locally-owned restaurant & bar specializing in pizzas, salads, sandwiches, and offering a full bar to enjoy a drink any day of the week. Come in and enjoy 13 65 TVs, 20 draft lines of microbrews, a private party room, 2 patios, and Golden Tee for playing fun. You’ll want to check-out our bourbon selection too! We’re a cozy neighborhood place where you’ll find the quality ingredients and focus on service makes a difference.
Based on 255 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
10462 Olio Rd, Fishers, IN 46040
Phone: (317) 336-8703
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11:30 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
sankalp bhatnagar
Pearl Street pizzeria in fishers is a fine pizza place. Ample parking in front of the restaurant. They have a nice reception area and 2 benches if you have to wait before seating. Ample dining spaces inside the restaurant and has a modern trendy vibe inside. The servers are very friendly and helpful and they made the experience amazing. I ordered old fashioned and I didn’t read the description before ordering, it has a cinnamon spice in it and I am not a big fan of cinnamon so I let my server know and apologize that I didn’t read the description and she immediately took it off for me and got me one without the cinnamon flavor which was perfect for me. Loved the services. I ordered cheesy breadsticks, spicy chicken and gorgonzola soup, and half-and-half Buffalo chicken and veggie pizza which was cooked to perfection. Ioved the place and experience so definitely recommend trying it out.
… more
Travis Chamberlain
A true treasure for residents and visitors of the Geist area. You will be challenged to find better food, atmosphere and service than Pearl Street. You will appreciate and crave the fresh ingredients and well thought out menu. If you’re going to spend your $$ going out to eat, feel good about it. Shame on me for taking this long to leave a review after coming here for years. My personal favorites, the BBQ chicken pizza and shrimp pesto flatbread.
… more
Eric S
Really great food, small menu with lots of variety. Sandwiches, wraps, pizza, pasta, apps, more. Wonderfully varied beer selection. Wine and liquor also. Staff is welcoming and friendly. Convenient location. Dog friendly outdoor seating. I’ve yet to be disappointed in anything: not food, not service, not price. Give them a try. Join the mug club. I hear it’s worth it if you return – I will at my next visit (6 in two months). I may even bring the pooch.
… more
Krag Roydes
Best Calzone I’ve had in a long time, maybe ever. They use a better quality cheese than most places, and the dough was cooked perfectly. I’ll definitely go back again.
… more
Mike Pierce
Pearl Street Pizza has unique Pizza it’s a gourmet pizza you need to try. One of the best in Indy we love going there you will not be disappointed.
… more
Andrew Schwab
Great atmosphere with a friendly staff, quality food at a very fair price.
… more
Matt T
We attended a pine to posh here and the accommodations were great. The back area was reserved and we had a large open space to work and eat.
… more
Whatchamavlogit
Great pizza and a large craft beer selection. Great atmosphere with a large bar and a patio for outdoor seating as well as a family dining area.
… more
Megan Anderson
What an adorable gem of a pizza place. I’ve lamented the one thing I miss about the years living in Bloomington was the fantastic pizza options and Indy had some good ones but just nothing to compare. Pearl Street was delightful and the closest yet to my beloved IU-Days in terms of pizza options. They were delightful and kind to our 1 year old who still is learning such things as “inside voices” when we are dining out (he was born in a quarantine, he never got to leave the house, haha).
… more
Matt Therault
The quality of food is just as great as the downtown location. However the service is a little lacking. They took way to long checking up on us toward the end of the meal. They also messed up the sauces. However, this place is still great, and I go back time and time again.
… more
… View more