Italian chain & delivery standby known for its pizzas with unusual toppings such as taco sauce. Based on 65 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
144 Merchant Row C, Milton, WI 53563
Phone: (608) 868-4999
Website: https://www.facebook.com/PRPMilton/menu
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 4–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 4–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Reviews
GodLoves MyMotherMary
I rode from Milwaukee to this Paul Revere’s Pizza in Milton. This is the only Paul Revere’s Pizza left in Wisconsin. Back in The 1990’s, there used to be a Paul Revere’s Pizza in Lancaster, Wisconsin where I grew up. That one closed in The Late 1990’s. I have only been to this location in Milton twice. I have had positive experiences both Times. I Love their Terminator Pizza. I am Happy to see that Paul Revere’s Pizza still offers it after all these Years. Most restaurants change out their menus over the Years. The Terminator Pizza is awesome. I am trying their version of The Taco Pizza and The BLT Pizza too. The employees there are very friendly and polite. The community is a nice little community. I bought 3 pizzas to take back with me to Milwaukee. Thank You all for the kind service
… more
Jamie S
Changing my review! This place went above and beyond today. At first I couldn’t get through (phone issues) but I really wanted to try their pizza. I sent a FB message and they got back to me quickly and was able to call me and get my order placed. Not only 5 stars for customer service but 5 stars for the yummy pizza. I order thin crust and it came so perfectly crunchy. Thank you!!
… more
Donna Kessler
Great food, and service! Would definitely order again.
… more
Darlene Demerath
I ordered 2 of the $24 specials along with 2 liter of coke Saturday September 26, 2020. 1) First of all I was told 1 1/4 hour delivery time. Ordered at 5:53 PM. 5:57 PM I called back after being disconnected. Completed order with going to pay cash at delivery. I called back at 6:05 pm to add a charge card and a $10 tip. Could not attach phone call status. I called back at 7:34 pm as no pizza was delivered yet. My husband drove into pick up pizza, etc. We had 3 small children to feed and several adults.
… more
Andrew Belmont
Very good pizza and breadsticks!
… more
Isaac Thompson
Super fast and probably the best pizza I’ve had in Wisconsin. Not expensive, and the bread sticks are to die for. Keep up the good work guys! Maybe add online ordering to Milton location?
… more
Robert Miller
Just tried to order a pizza at 7:45 on a Friday night and was told that 3.9 mi. was too far to deliver, even though they’ve done it many times before. Being inconsistent and screwing up people’s supper plans, is a terrible business model. If you had let me know sooner, I would have just called Casey’s and saved us the trouble. Now I know to just call Casey’s, which is further away, but reliable.
… more
jordan M
never fails to be very good at reasonable prices I was able to feed my family of 5 and a few more and still have left overs for the week!
… more
Andrew D
I have been enjoying Paul Revere’s for years now, originally in Edgerton but now Milton. And I would take the extra time to drive here for food without a thought. I only wish they could deliver to Edgerton, but not a deal breaker. As everyone says “breadsticks are to die for” they aren’t kidding. My favorite is any thin crust pizza or a “Wedgie”! Keep up the great food and service!
… more
Ron Tracy
Absolute nostalgia trip! The sticks and cheese bread were just as I remembered. I may have looked like a psychopath shoveling it into my face, while parked just outside a cemetery… but with all that cheese and oil, I really didn’t care. Excelsior!
… more
… View more