Chic trattoria with an old-country Italian vibe presenting a huge menu of Italian favorites. Based on 620 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
231 Old Country Rd, Carle Place, NY 11514
Phone: (516) 741-4800
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Krystal Brown
Thank you Jose (server) for an awesome experience. The food was amazing: Spaghetti and Meatballs(2). Chicken Parmesan. The Bread Basket and Garlic Bread Delicious . Drinks: Sangria and Passion Fruit Strawberry Lemonade, Yummy! Dessert: Vanilla and Watermelon Gelato. I absolutely enjoyed this meal and I plan on returning and telling others about this gem. Most Importantly I have to emphasize how Jose went out of his way to make this dinner special. I highly recommend you choose this Dining Experience and ask for Jose he really optimized our experience as he went ABOVE and BEYOND.
Christopher Whitley
Super good with a great atmosphere. The host at the front door (could be the owner) was a character! Waiter was great. Food was delicious, warm, and tasty. The bread basket – a variety of breads and slices of cold pizza – were a welcome but unexpected treat. Water was cold, not semi-warm like many places. The wait staff had every part of the meal timed perfectly. So very good – a must visit. Enjoy the dated, old time wall coverings, lighting and overall decor. Seating was very comfortable. I usually do not write this much – there is lots of very good here!
Joseph Gerasci
Unbelievable menu. Everything is absolutely delicious. The staff is super nice. I can’t say one bad thing about our experience. One of the best dinners I’ve had in a while and I’ve been to every high end restaurant on Long Island. Overall great place.
Dianne
Third time here and consistently great. The owner Emilio came to our table ,told us about a lot of dishes and home made pasta, the cream sauce is superb. . He trested us to his Flatbread Margarita pizza, omg Delicious. I had artichoke franchise as appetizers. SO SO GOODI love the atmosphere and decor, as well
Subho S.
The $19 Signature chopped veggie salad looked as though it was thrown into a food processor ! The bread rolls were stone cold. The only saving grace was the Trofie Pasta pesto Rosso but then again not worth $28 ! Overall pretty disappointed with what was showed up at the door. For full disclosure, I want to add that I ordered delivery via Uber Eats but that isn’t any excuse for the restaurant serving garbage !
John Lios
This place is great! Had a warm welcome when we walked in and a great lunch! Chicken Parmigan was delicious and Josè was a great server!
Dolly Hoffman
Love this place! Never disappoints. This place has great food in an unpretentious, lovely environment. The servers are amazing and always willing to assist with substitutions! The food is wonderful Italian comfort food. Never had a bad dish here.
Kathleen Brucato
I made a reservation on Open Table without checking their website.
Arbër Shehu
The food could be better, felt like Italian buffet style food served in a restaurant. The pizzas were a little bit too salty and the rest of the dishes were overfilled with tomato sauce, and the portions were way to big for real Italian. The service was fast and cultured, the place looks clean, the ambient is comfortable and the Italian songs make it even better. However, they need to improve their food quality. And not overuse the pasta sauce on every dish.
Jeanine Garard
I dined last night with 13 of my colleagues. I ordered frutti de mare, as I am a seafood lover! I asked the waiter to make my sauce spicy. It looked fine however I noticed that the clams had an odd taste. I asked one of my colleagues to taste it and she commented that the “funny taste” stayed on her tongue and that maybe something is wrong! I brought this concern to the attention of my waiter who told me that 1) he got the seafood in fresh that morning, 2) that I am going to have to pay for it anyway, 3) that people in the other area of the restaurant had no concerns, and 4) he said that he was not willing to allow me to order anything else since the kitchen is closed.
… View more