Based on 444 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3911 Broadway Ave, Evansville, IN 47712
Phone: (812) 423-3339
Website: https://www.parkwaypizza.online/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Melanie J Watkins
Thought we’d give this place a try and we were extremely disappointed, to say the least. Upon entering we looked to our left, behind the counter, were 3 employees sitting around on their phones. One of them said to seat ourselves & someone would be right with us. There were 2 or 3 tables seated and what looked like a baby’s birthday party of about 15-20 ppl. We ordered some beer buckets, onion rings (w/ranch & honey mustard), cheese bread (with cheese dip & pizza sauce)and a pizza to take home. We were confused about the pizza toppings on the specialty pizzas. We ordered the house special and on the menu (sorry, I apologize for not getting pictures of it, as I usually do.) it states all the meats, but when it came to the vegetables it said, “LITE.” I didn’t know if it was an established idea or what?? Our server Penny was very nice and said if we got the 16″ we would get our cheese bread free. Before deciding, we asked her why it says, “LITE”. She stated that it’s because there are too many toppings??? It was so weird. We decided to go with the “16 to get our cheese bread free. Our onion rings came out first with a topped foam container of ketchup. The onion rings were good, but when she brought our ranch and honey mustard they were both AWFUL! Zero flavor! Next was our cheese bread with another topped foam container of pizza sauce and one with cheese sauce. It was just bread with a cheese like substance that was NOT good. The pizza sauce was sub-par and lacked salt. The cheese sauce looked like cheese, but didn’t taste like it. No cheese flavor!!!! I happened to notice in the back corner that their stuff comes from cans! Later, we had the pizza and it was one of the worst pizzas we’ve ever had!!! Our youngest ended up getting Domino’s and it was incredible compared to Parkway. $69 for horrible food! Great service, but the food was awful. I wouldn’t waste your money.
… more
Tyler Dixon
I tried this place for the first time today. Went pretty basic with an extra pepperoni. It was alright. Thin crust, but not quite as crackery as Spankey’s. I think I prefer Spankey’s sauce to this place. I will certainly give it another try. Delivery was ok, no issues. I like how they have some coupons for free stuff with minimum orders. Pizza is getting too expensive these days… Sheesh.
… more
Stephanie Spurlock
A bit of confusion with order but called & they quickly fixed the problem. Pizza was great tasting. Didn’t care for the cheese bread it was a bit plain no flavor. Didn’t eat in we got delivery will order again in near future.
… more
Honey White
Everytime we call to place an order we are put on hold for over 5 minutes. Then if you call back they answer with an attitude. We have ordered quite often from there. The food is good but service is awful.
… more
Lori Culbertson
Really yummy pizza! They have Gluten Free! So good! Awesome customer service and ice cream was delicious! You should definitely go!
… more
Peter Hawley
Real local Evansville feel. Good food and service. A little expensive, but that’s everywhere.
… more
Justin Guy (JustSomeHawk)
I cannot express how much I enjoyed this place. I am pretty stingy with 5-star reviews, but this one does it!
… more
Iambydefault
Great pizza, great service. Will definitely be back.
… more
Erik Varden
Excellent pizza! Nice place to share a great meal with friends and family. Won’t be disappointed. Stays busy which speaks well.
… more
Valerie Cobb
Went with my husband and niece and nephew. We truly enjoyed it. Hands down the best pizza and wings around!!! Prices are great. 11-12-22 there was 4 of us and this time pizza wasn’t as good as normal. It had a different taste and portions of the pizza didn’t have as many toppings for a meatlovers. Also, my husband got half of a stromboli and he could tell that it wasn’t going to taste good and it wasn’t. Total waste of money. There were 2 large groups of people with kids and they were running around the restaurant and around the salad bar. They hovered over the salad bar throwing hats across the bar. They were unsupervised by parents/family. The workers never asked the families to control their kids. They were so disruptive. I guess that says how their home life is….who runs things. My husband wanted peppers but knew they had been playing around the bar. So not cool or professional. The cook came out there got items from the bar to make something for a customer….all I can say is glad it wasn’t ours!!!
… more
… View more