Based on 157 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
Address:
554 N New St, Bethlehem, PA 18018
Phone: (484) 357-8727
Website: http://paranormalpizzaco.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Heather Boswick
Wow! last time we went to Bethlehem, vegan finds were hard to find… now this place is new and amazingggggg. Drool worthy. Must visit!! We got the garlic knot vegan pizza and was blown away. Love the funky decor and vibe here. Seems family owned which is amazing and should be supported. My friend who isn’t even vegan said it was in his top 10 best pizzas. Love their combos and flavors. Please come here- vegan or not. The pizza is DIVINE ✨
… more
B Nobles
Vegan magic! Ordered the special with their homemade bacon crumbles and homemade chicken (both amazing texture/flavor). The dough was very traditional , NY style or even very common to all the pizzerias around here and a perfect balance of crispy/thin and chewy/thick. Their cheese is great, unlike other vegan offerings in the LV. I love that everything is from scratch and not store bought! Will definitely order again AND non-vegans will love it because the flavor is paramount
… more
Robin Miller
Delicious pizza and wings! The texture of the wings was incredible, nice and crispy with a few crunchy bits. The Alien Bounty Hunter was phenomenal! The garlic knots were a dream of dough and garlic while the piled high veggies were scrumptious.
… more
mags
Best vegan pizza I’ve ever had in my life as well as the best customer service I have ever had a pizzeria. Lauren, who as working the front counter is super sweet and helpful. Not only to us but to everyone who came in. I remember there was a Nick and a Zach working as well. Trying to remember everyone who is working‘s name as I promise to mention everybody in the review. Regardless I seriously recommend this pizza place to anyone who is looking for a vegan spot with fun and friendly staff and Cool atmosphere. My best friend and I met up for the weekend and we were looking for something that was up our alley and lucky for us we felt so lucky to have found this place. We will definitely be coming back!
… more
Vivian Timor
I’m sorry to ruin the 5.0 review but as a vegan pizza coinessuer I have to be honest. The seitan, I will say, was a solid 8.5/10. The wings in particular were wonderful, but I found the pepperoni bland. The texture is there but not the flavor. What ruined this pizza for me was honestly the cheese. The texture/flavor isn’t there and I feel I could have made something of similar quality in my own kitchen. The crust was good, especially with garlic knots but overall the entire meal did give my friend and myself stomachaches. The sauce was fine, average.
… more
Libby Guman
I am the only vegan in my family. A lot of times, the food I order when I go out is not something that my family members want to try. I visited Paranormal Pizza and fell in love! I could, given enough time and empty stomach space, finish one pie without any help. It’s that good! When I brought some leftovers home from this place, someone found them in the fridge and got to them before I did. They had no idea it was vegan, and were shocked to find out that something that was vegan could taste that awesome! Now that I put my family onto this place, I have to share every pie I order, which means I usually order two! One for me, and one for them The staff here is lovely. Super welcoming and friendly! I can tell they really put a lot of love into the food they make for the community! I love the fun flavor combinations for the pizzas and I’m eager to try the wings next time I stop in. Even if you are not vegan, Paranormal Pizza is a definite must-have if you are in the area!
… more
Pierra Clemons
Absolute deliciousness! 100% Vegan and that almond ricotta is to die for! We got gluten free crust and the texture of the crust is just *chef’s kiss* It was like a white pizza, can’t remember the name but it was sooo good, ofc. Everyone working there is also super nice and they even remembered my hubby when we came back for a second visit. Love this spot.
… more
SarahHart10481
First time ordering from this place. I walked in and placed an order to go. I was so excited to find out about an ALL VEGAN pizza place! Everything is 100% vegan! I ordered the Mulder Pizza, and garlic knots. It was so good! Definitely will go back! Thanks for bringing a vegan business to the area!
… more
Kayla Kulla
I love to see an entirely vegan pizza place! Great pizza and lots of options. BEST seitan wings I’ve ever found. Will definitely be back.
… more
Dominic Frascella
Years of searching for the perfect vegan pie have finally come to a close. Not a single negative thought comes to mind.
… more
… View more