Based on 107 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1915 W Crawford Ave, Connellsville, PA 15425
Phone: (724) 628-1660
Website: https://linktr.ee/pappyspizza
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9:40 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:40 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:40 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:40 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:40 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:40 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Reviews
Ryan Turin
Women owned and operated! They not only delivered great pizza and wings; they delivered awesome service too. The food was soooo good and the atmosphere is so nostalgic to a classic pizza shop!
… more
Donald Rattay
Would have been 3 stars, but they don’t have current prices listed online. Paid about 20 bucks more than I thought I was paying. Got pizza thick crust (is a topping charge) pepparoni average at best. Also, I got 3 dozen breaded wings again average at best. I happen to be down that way, or I would have never ordered from there. It’s take out or delivery. I will not get it again. It’s not worth the trip.
… more
Kimberly Davies
I ordered a white pizza and a grilled chicken salad. Both were fantastic!!
… more
Sabrina Yealey
I grew up eating and loving Pappys Pizza!! I’ve ordered a few times in recent months and was very disappointed. It wasn’t terrible but definitely isn’t like it was when I was younger! The recent pizzas I’ve received either had too much sauce or the dough was chewy and seemed to be not fully cooked. This may have been due to new cooks or very busy business but I will not order again unfortunately.
… more
Ronald Enos
I had an Italian Hogie. I got the large. Plenty of meat and 3 kinds of cheese. I could only eat half of it. It was heated slowly in a large oven. Delicious. Nice people there and they deliver. I have not tried the pizza, but plan to soon.
… more
Bill Baughman
Top notch, home town pizza shop for many years. We’ve been regular customers for many years.
… more
Karah Mia Opal
My only regret is not getting wings. Very timely delivery, delicious pizza, priced well. I highly recommend above other pizza shops in our area.
… more
Richard Massafra
First they deliver. I was at the Dunbar Festival and they delivered to my booth. Second they made a thick pizza.
… more
Lilly Tremmel
Pizza was cold when it was delivered, the wings are super duper small. hot Pepper cheese balls were banging and so was my hoagie! Called about the pizza and they said I could bring back the pizza and get my money back but it was 15 minutes before close and I didn’t have time so the lady told me I could pick up a fresh one the next day which made me satisfied. Overall it’s good food, just don’t order during a football game
… more
steven newcomer
If I could give zero stars I would. I order frequently and tip very well but they refused to even try to accommodate my Celiac Disease and make me A bbq chicken pizza as “they use too much chicken on the pizza” I have ordered a three meat gluten free no problem in the past multiple times, and I asked if they could just please put the chicken on the side or use less chicken and they refused” I offered to pay extra for them to put LESS chicken on the pizza! I don’t see the big deal about putting a little less chicken on a pizza so I’m able to try it, and it’s not like I have the option to eat the non gluten free. Thanks for nor even trying to work with me Pappy’s.
… more
… View more