Based on 138 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
600 W Sherman Ave, Millville, NJ 08332
Phone: (856) 459-2100
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brandon
Best white broccoli and garlic white pizza around. Great family ran restaurant, cheap prices and great location will be back and keep going back. Great people. Just had a flat tire and one of the workers came to help me change it.
M. W.
We order from Papa Luigis at least once a month. Food is always great. Customer service is always great too. My only complaint is I would like a paper menu. Recommend the wings, bacon burgers, and cheesesteaks! Last time we got pizza it reminded me of pizza from the mall! Soo good!
Danielle Diaz
Worked all day ordered a sandwich drove all the way from millville opened it order was incorrect called them had to turn around told him he apolized said come back he wld fix got their he then stated here put on sandwich said no you told me wld correct not eating a cold sandwich he clearly said he ddnt tell cook the option wasn’t on his register was his fault an cursed me out said he ddnt want a customer like me get out their was poor ppl wld eat it for me to eat it I come thier once a week had wonderful service from a man Ramon an tony always tipped I was hurt disappointed an will never return was rude his fault not mine never had a problem their but the owner was disrespectful I will never go back an tell all my family not to as well an keep spreading my experience thier ….
… more
Uneek 1980
I have been going to Papa Luigis since I was a child. The food is amazing which you will be very pleased once you take your first bite. If you look at the pictures which I happen to post of Papa Luigi it’s very immaculate inside which is a clear description of how they handel there food & customer’s. They aim to please. A great place to bring your family,friends & children.
Jeremy Glass
Food was great, could have had a 5 star but they took forever on the delivery and there fries were soggy
Estephania Loder
The food was good and the place was clean and the people was good
J T
THE BEST pizza we’ve ever had!! And the way they lay the pizza’s out is VERY CUSTOMER FOCUSED!!! VERY reasonably priced family owned and ran business. The authenticity of this place is OFF the charts. THE BEST FOOD ALONG WITH OUTSTANDING CUSTOMER SERVICE ♀️ THANK YOU VERY MUCH❣❣❣
Joyce Appel
I was highly disappointed with the taste of the food.
Sherry Sanderson
Very friendly staff and reasonable pricing for today’s inflation.
Melissa W
Food is usually good from here in the past, but last week when we ordered to go they totally missed 1 chicken tender basket when I had ordered 2. I noticed it after we paid, so the girl was like “do you still want it?” And I said yes it’s for one of my 2 children. So then I had to pay separately for a mistake that the “new” girl made. I wouldn’t have minded paying for it because I did order it, but then it took almost 10min to get that and now my other food is getting cold. The cheesesteak meat was very skimpy which I don’t remember them doing usually, so all in all it wasn’t a good experience this time.
… View more