Get the pizza and subs you love right in the comfort of your home. Our takeout food is available for pickup so you can save time and stay safe. Your family will be ecstatic when you come through the front door with a pizza box.
Ordering subs to-go is easy, too. Check our Specials page to see which subs are discounted on each day. With our wide variety of sandwich ingredients and our low prices, you can make sure everyone in the family gets exactly what they want.
Call today or order online!
Counter-service place offering hot & cold subs on house-baked bread, plus pizza, calzones & salads. Based on 239 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
379 S Idaho St, Wendell, ID 83355
Phone: (208) 536-2505
Website:
Hours
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
7 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
7 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
7 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
7 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
7 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
7 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Locke Seavello
Stopped in for lunch during a road trip from Boise to Salt Lake City. I had a Steak Firehouse and it was absolutely delicious. The portion sizes are huge too. We saw someone get a “kid’s cone” ice cream and it was much bigger than most ice cream places. My only complaint, which is very minor, was that my sub was a little over toasted and the bread was falling apart as a result.
… more
Lisa Swanson
Was not happy with my pizza. The crust was not good. Was dry. The cheese was over cooked. Like rubber. And your workers were on there cell phones more than taken care of your customers if I am going to spend $40 for pizza,I am better off going to simerlys, which is not that good either come on papa,,,do better.
… more
Kimberly Youngblood
Ordered a LG Pepperoni pizza and What I thought was CHEESY BREADx2… tip and all ….NOT WORTH IT!!! $30… IN THE TRASH… CHEESY BREAD IS NOW SERVERED ON A CRUSTY PIZZA CRUST!!! JUST SAD AND HORRIBLE!!… Not sure what happened but horrible food now…
… more
Dolores Alaniz
I have always loved papa Kelsey’s , born and raised in Twin Falls it was one of my favorite places to eat . I was a little disappointed that their bread has changed its thin and has hard crust !!! What happened?
… more
Kytyn Matney
Pretty good pizza. Friendly counter person and very clean restaurant. Pizza has a medium crust with a nice crunchy bottom. The usual kind of sauce and cheese, pepperoni and mushrooms not liberally placed – could have used more to be an average portion of toppings.
… more
Michael R. Bryant
Pizza is different but good. I love the medium thick crust, not deep dish, not thin, but just right. Love the garlic seasoning. Love the thick sliced pepperoni. In my opinion both pies had too much cheese and too much sauce. Prices are high for the toppings you get. Restaurant space is big and open. Entire place needs a deep cleaning. Outside parking is lacking. Building exterior is uninviting. Can’t stand when a local spot is a little too local and the employees sit in the dining room and have their own social hour because of slow business instead of cleaning and checking in on patrons.
… more
Jordan Allen
It’s my all time favorite sandwich. And it has been my favorite sandwich for over 30 years. I just wish there was as much focus on creating a great atmosphere as there is creating an excellent sandwich. (A portable radio for music?) But I’ll be back. And my kids will be back. It’s the best!
… more
Lisa Diestelhorst
Very Good Food. I was in the mood for a sandwich. It Definitely didn’t disappoint.
… more
Jessica A
By war one of the best pizzas in the region. It was worth friving off the freeway for this pizza. Our new must stop by place whenever we’re driving by
… more
George Davis
We went to Wendell to get breakfast. I can’t get enough of their cinnamon rolls.
… more
… View more
