Counter-service place offering hot & cold subs on house-baked bread, plus pizza, calzones & salads. Based on 206 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1014 Main St, Buhl, ID 83316
Phone: (208) 543-5210
Website: http://www.papakelseyspizza.com/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
6 AM–8:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 6 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ben M
I always get the Italian Combo Sandwich when I go to Papa Kelsey’s. I always get the 16” whole size. I normally split it when another person. It might not fill you both up completely, but it’s enough to get you both to your next meal. If you were to try to eat the whole sandwich yourself, you probably wouldn’t have to eat again for the rest of the day. The sandwich is delicious and full of meat and if you split it, it’s inexpensive. I’ve been getting these subs here for a long time and the quality has always been the same. Their oven baked sandwiches are some of the best around. The sandwich will come with a small bag of lays potato chips. The inside of the restaurant looks sharp and has a nice modern look to it. I’ll recommend Papa Kelsey’s any day.
… more
Jennifer C
Always yummy. We love their sandwiches and pizza. The large sandwich is big enough to feed 2 adults. They cut it into 4 squares. The employees are also very nice.
… more
randall apgood
This is a great place to eat. We love the steak and everything sandwich. We always get great service. It is very clean every time we go there. Best place in Buhl.
… more
Ms Morgan
I love the pizza and the Italian Sub. I recommend you give them a try. Yummiest
… more
Heidi Fischer
I really enjoyed their subs and the pizza was good too
… more
SarahM Weintraub
First time here! The dining area was very clean and the staff were friendly. We had 8 of us and the food was done very timely.
… more
matthew pierson
Sandwiches are huge! I had a meatball sub, it was great. Enough for 2 meals. The employees were very nice as well.
… more
Mike S
Pizza is awful. Idk what and where the pic on their site is from but this is cookie-cutter cheap far worse than Pizza Hut material grade F garbage. The only positive was that I got a medium instead of a large so I “only” wasted $11.50 instead of like $16. The nerve of these prices for this quality! Unreal.
… more
Tammy Foster
Papa Kelseys never disappoints. We have gone to 4. Always very good.
… more
Misti Netz
Papa Kelsey’s has good sandwiches but you barely get meat on the triple meat without adding more. Just adding jalapeños to it, its a $15 sandwich. I ordered 2 sandwiches and some spicy fries for my son. It’s $37 and some change, plus the extra 3% for debit card use. Ridiculous! I could go to subway and get my husband and I sandwiches for $22. Sad thing is it is better than Subway. Quick food isn’t worth it in a pinch anymore.
… more
… View more