Papa Johns Pizza Menu – Evansville, IN

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Evansville, IN

For Papa Johns Pizza in Evansville, IN, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza – the more you put into it, the more you get out of it. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, our original fresh dough, or even the box itself, we invest in our ingredients to ensure that we always give you the finest quality pizza. For you, it’s not just Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. It’s a family gathering, memorable birthday, work celebration or simply a great meal. It’s our goal to make sure you always have the best ingredients for every occasion. Call us at (812) 423-7272 for delivery or stop by W Lloyd Expy for carryout to order your favorite, pizza, breadsticks, or wings today!

Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. Based on 153 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $

✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Papa Johns Pizza 47712

Address:
4814 W Lloyd Expy, Evansville, IN 47712

Phone: (812) 423-7272

Website:

Hours

Sunday 10 AM–11 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–11 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–11 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–11 PM
Thursday 10 AM–11 PM
Friday 10 AM–12 AM
Saturday 10 AM–12 AM

Menu

Listed and Service By Buckeye Foodhub
Contact Information
Please call 1 (800) 701-7214 or email [email protected] if you have any questions regarding your orders or Service.
$0.00
Papa’s Starters
Knots
8 knots.
$8.75
Cheesesticks $9.49
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
Tuscan Six Cheese
$14.99
Specialty Pizza
Small Pepperoni Pizza
6 slices.
$13.99
Medium Pepperoni Pizza
8 slices.
$16.99
Large Pepperoni Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extras-Large Pepperoni Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$21.99
Small Sausage Pizza
6 slices.
$13.99
Medium Sausage Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$16.99
Large Sausage Pizza
8 slices.
$19.99
Extras-Large Sausage Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$21.99
Small Cheese Pizza
6 slices.
$13.99
Medium Cheese Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Large Cheese Pizza
8 slices.
$18.99
Extras-Large Cheese Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$21.99
Local Flavors Pizza
Small Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
6 slices. Served with BBQ sauce.
$15.99
Medium Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
8 slices. Original crust. Served with BBQ sauce.
$19.99
Large Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
8 slices. Served with BBQ sauce.
$21.99
Extra-Large Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
10 slices. Original crust. Served with BBQ sauce.
$24.99
Small Foligno Favorite Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium Foligno Favorite Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$19.99
Large Foligno Favorite Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extra-Large Foligno Favorite Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Specials
Papadias
Flatbread-style sandwich made from original fresh dough filled with our real meats, veggies, and cheese.
$10.50
Jalapeno Popper Rolls
Made with Philadelphia cream cheese on our original fresh dough and rolled up with jalapenos for a side that really pops.
$10.50
Large Two Topping
Large Two Topping Pizza.
$23.99
Pick A Sides
Breadsticks, Garlic Parm Breadsticks, Garlic Knots, 10″ Cheesesticks, 6 piece Wings, 10 piece Chicken Poppers, Brownie, Cookie or Cinnamon Pull-aparts.
$11.50
Any Large Pizza
Create your own, Up to 5-Toppings or Any Specialty Pizza.
$19.99
Medium Five Topping & Specialty Pizza
Create your own, Up to 5-Toppings or Any Specialty Pizza.
$17.99
Party Pack $42.99
Any Large Meatless Pizza
No Meat? No Problem. Extra Cheesy Alfredo, Six Cheese, Garden Fresh, or Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo? There’s no wrong answer here.
$18.50
Extra Large Five Topping & Specialty Pizza
Create your own, Up to 5-Toppings or Any Specialty Pizza.
$21.99
Pizza Party
Five Large up to Five Toppings or Specialty Pizzas.
$84.99
4 For $8 Variety Pepsi Pack
Find the perfect pairing for that pizza.
$12.99
Garlic Parmesan Crust Pizza
Fresh, never-frozen original dough baked to a golden brown with garlic sauce and Parmesan-Romano cheese around the crust
$18.50
Handcrafted Meatless Specialties Pizza
Small Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$17.99
Large Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extra-Large Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
6 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Medium Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$17.99
Large Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extra-Large Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Garden Fresh Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium Garden Fresh Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$18.99
Large Garden Fresh Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extra-Large Garden Fresh Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
6 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Medium Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$18.99
Large Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extra-Large Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Handcrafted Specialties Pizza
Small The Works Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium The Works Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$17.99
Large The Works Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extras-Large The Works Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small The Meats Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium The Meats Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$18.99
Large The Meats Pizza
8 slices.
$22.49
Extras-Large The Meats Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Meatball Pepperoni Pizza
6 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Medium Meatball Pepperoni Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$17.99
Large Meatball Pepperoni Pizza
8 slices.
$22.99
Extras-Large Meatball Pepperoni Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Super Hawaiian Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium Super Hawaiian Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$18.99
Large Super Hawaiian Pizza
8 slices.
$22.99
Extras-Large Super Hawaiian Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
6 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Medium Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$17.99
Large Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
8 slices.
$21.99
Extras-Large Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
6 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Medium Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$19.35
Large Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
8 slices.
$22.99
Extras-Large Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
6 slices.
$15.99
Medium Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$18.99
Large Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
8 slices.
$22.99
Extras-Large Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Small Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
6 slices. Ranch sauce.
$15.99
Medium Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
8 slices. Original crust & ranch sauce.
$18.99
Large Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
8 slices & ranch sauce.
$22.99
Extras-Large Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
10 slices. Original crust & ranch sauce.
$24.99
Small Pepperoni, Sausage & Six Cheese Pizza
6 slices. Original crust.
$15.99
Medium Pepperoni, Sausage & Six Cheese Pizza
8 slices. Original crust.
$18.99
Large Pepperoni, Sausage & Six Cheese Pizza
8 slices.
$22.99
Extras-Large Pepperoni, Sausage & Six Cheese Pizza
10 slices. Original crust.
$24.99
Gluten-Free Crust with Ancient Grains
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust $15.99
New Garlic Parmesan Crust Pizzas
Create Your Own With Garlic Parmesan Crust $16.99
Extra Cheesy Alfredo With Garlic Parmesan Crust
Alfredo sauce.
$19.99
Pepperoni With Garlic Parmesan Crust $16.99
Sausage With Garlic Parmesan Crust $19.99
Cheese With Garlic Parmesan Crust $19.99
The Works With Garlic Parmesan Crust $23.99
The Meats With Garlic Parmesan Crust $24.99
Garden Fresh With Garlic Parmesan Crust $25.99
Create Your Own Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza (Small)
6 slices.
$13.99
Create Your Own Pizza (Medium)
8 slices. Original crust.
$16.99
Create Your Own Pizza (Large)
8 slices.
$21.99
Create Your Own Pizza (Extra-Large)
10 slices. Original crust.
$23.99
Papa’s Wings
Unsauced Roasted Wings (6) $10.99
Unsauced Roasted Wings (8) $12.99
Unsauced Roasted Wings (16)
Choice of two dipping sauce.
$21.99
Unsauced Roasted Wings (24)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$34.99
Unsauced Roasted Wings (32)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$41.99
Unsauced Roasted Wings (50)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$62.99
Buffalo Wings (6) $9.99
Buffalo Wings (8) $11.99
Buffalo Wings (16)
Choice of two sauce.
$21.99
Buffalo Wings (24)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$32.99
Buffalo Wings (32)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$41.99
Buffalo Wings (50)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$61.99
BBQ Wings (6) $9.99
BBQ Wings (8) $11.99
BBQ Wings (16)
Choice of two sauce.
$21.99
BBQ Wings (24)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$31.99
BBQ Wings (32)
Choice of four dipping sauce.https://www.buckeyefoodhub.com/admin/menu/menus#
$38.99
BBQ Wings (50)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$61.99
Honey Chipotle Wings (6) $9.99
Honey Chipotle Wings (8) $11.99
Garlic Parmesan Wings (6) $9.99
Garlic Parmesan Wings (8) $11.99
Garlic Parmesan Wings (16)
Choice of two sauce.
$20.99
Garlic Parmesan Wings (24)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$30.99
Garlic Parmesan Wings (32)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$39.99
Garlic Parmesan Wings (50)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$59.99
Papa’s Poppers
Chicken Poppers (30)
Choice of two dipping sauce.
$21.99
Chicken Poppers (45)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$32.99
Chicken Poppers (60)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$43.99
Honey Chipotle Chicken Poppers (10) $8.99
Honey Chipotle Chicken Poppers (15) $10.99
Honey Chipotle Chicken Poppers (30)
Choice of two dipping sauce.
$17.99
Honey Chipotle Chicken Poppers (45)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$22.99
Honey Chipotle Chicken Poppers (60)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$29.99
Buffalo Chicken Poppers (10) $8.99
Buffalo Chicken Poppers (15) $10.99
Buffalo Chicken Poppers (30)
Choice of two dipping sauce.
$18.99
Buffalo Chicken Poppers (45)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$22.99
Buffalo Chicken Poppers (60)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$28.99
BBQ Chicken Poppers (10) $11.99
BBQ Chicken Poppers (15) $14.50
BBQ Chicken Poppers (30)
Choice of two dipping sauce.
$17.99
BBQ Chicken Poppers (45)
Choice of three dipping sauce.
$29.49
BBQ Chicken Poppers (60)
Choice of four dipping sauce.
$33.99
Chicken Poppers (10) $10.49
Chicken Poppers (15) $11.99
Papadias
Italian Papadias
Alfredo sauce.
$9.49
Philly Cheesesteak
Ranch sauce.
$10.25
Meatball Pepperoni Papadia $12.49
Create Your Own Papadia $11.50
Extras
Special Garlic Sauce $2.99
Spicy Garlic Sauce $2.99
Pizza Sauce $2.99
Ranch Sauce $2.99
Blue Cheese Sauce $2.99
Buffalo Sauce $2.99
BBQ Sauce $2.99
Honey Mustard Sauce $2.99
Cheese Sauce $2.99
Honey Chipotle Sauce $2.99
Special Seasonings $2.99
Crushed Red Pepper $2.99
Parmesan Cheese $2.99
Pepperoncinis $2.99
Jalapeno Peppers $2.99
Banana Peppers $2.99
Desserts
Cinnamon Pull Aparts $11.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie
8 slices.
$11.99
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
9 squares.
$11.99
Beverages
Pepsi $2.99
Mountain Dew $2.99
Diet Pepsi $3.99
Aquafina (20 Oz.) $3.99
Sierra Mist $3.99
Dr. Pepper $3.99

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Brian Dunn
Got a couple pizza’s, cheese bread, and a chocolate chip dessert for some family for supper and it was great. Their spicy Italian sausage meat topping is great, I should’ve ordered both pizza’s with the spicy Italian sausage because I almost eat one by myself but I left a couple pieces so my grandma and uncle had some besides the pepperoni pizza. Definitely recommend the spicy Italian on your pizza. Very friendly staff, and clean atmosphere. Great job pizza was great and great customer service. I ordered everything from the app to pickup within an hour and a half, and when I get there it was coming out of the oven, no waiting around very fast order pickup .

… more

Dominique Carlos
No no no. Do not order wings or chicken in sauce of any kind unless you have a bottle of your own to add to it. I wants SAUCY wings. It’s like a squirt I would give my 2 yr old so he can’t make a mess. I paid 25$ for SAUCY chicken and now I can’t even enjoy the messiness of the sauce cause there is none!! I called the store but was a dead end talking to the guy who answered and sounded like she didn’t want to me there.

… more

D LaBaw
Called in my order and when I arrived it was ready. I added garlic knots and the young man promptly fixed them and I was out the door. Pizza was very good and exactly what I ordered and the garlic knots were so good!!

… more

Jennifer Tucker
Food was great they are low staffed though and after being told the pizza would be ready in about 20 minutes we sat in the Park lot another 30 minutes waiting for it to go into the oven

… more

Nick Ambrose
This place can’t follow simple directions. Light sauce doesn’t mean add as much sauce so its flowing over the crust… the quality of this store sub par at absolute best.

… more

Frances Knuth
Always fresh and prepared to perfection. Staff friendly and courteous. Love this Papa John’s.

… more

Alicia Renee Selner
Flavor was good but toppings were scarce. That was unexpected for a Pappa John’s and the price we paid.

… more

Eric “Murphdogg76” Murphy
I ordered 12 pizzas on Saturday afternoon for my jobsite and Papa Johns came through like a champ! Thank you

… more

Samantha Eberhart
Our order was hot and ready when we got there. No mistakes and the employee was very friendly and efficient.

… more

Wes Williams
I know this location never puts much sauce if any on pizza so I ordered extra sauce. What do you know it still cheese bread

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions