For Papa Johns Pizza in Pickerington, OH, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza – the more you put into it, the more you get out of it. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, our original fresh dough, or even the box itself, we invest in our ingredients to ensure that we always give you the finest quality pizza. For you, it’s not just Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. It’s a family gathering, memorable birthday, work celebration or simply a great meal. It’s our goal to make sure you always have the best ingredients for every occasion. Call us at (614) 864-7272 for delivery or stop by Hill Rd North for carryout to order your favorite, pizza, breadsticks, or wings today!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. Based on 154 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1201 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
Phone: (614) 864-7272
Hours
| Wednesday | 9:30 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 9:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 9:30 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 9:30 AM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 9:30 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 9:30 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 9:30 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
DragonClawGaming YT
So at first we were having issues with the Papa Johns app because it said that our order was already picked up. My Dad was anxious so we went ahead and called Papa Johns and a man with a really nice and not angry or mad or miserable sounding voice came on the phone and talked to us nicely that there was a issue currently going on with the app. He then told us right after to drive safe. You know how many times you get that now a days? I’ll tell you what it’s once in a BLUE MOON. Just hearing that me and my Dad were already felt good driving there. When I got there to go pick up my order the guy who was on the phone, his name was Chrismorre, already had my order ready to go and double checked to make sure everything was in there he then said you have a nice night and take care. This guy was unbelievably nice and we need more people like him out on this earth, especially with how miserable working the food industry can be nowadays. Not only that but everyone at this store was focused and doing their part. I noticed that there was new employees since the last time we have been there and it looks like it’s doing way better, the store was very clean and our pizza was very hot and ready. Me and my family enjoyed it very much. If you plan on ordering pizza tonight or for your family this would be the best option, not only that but they are open late. Good luck to Chrismorrre and everyone who works at that store god bless them .
… more
KC Sunshine
I’m so angry right now. Not only did they NOT deliver my pizza but the “manager” hung up on when I asked their name. I waited outside during my delivery window. But I called and they said they are running behind. Watching the delivery tracker it suddenly uodates to delivered and I looked outside right away and NO pizza. The store would not resolve it and stole my money and the 20% tip. Bad experience with no resolution.
… more
Angela Ealy
There was a deal, “perfect pairings.” You get two items for 6.99 each. I ordered hot wings and brownies. The hot wings were perfect! Opened the brownie box and it was the chocolate chip cookie. I’m probably the only person on earth that hates chocolate chip cookies. I spoke with someone about what I received and she repeated a couple times that she had refunded the brownie. There was no refund receipt or even a heads up. Now I’m just wondering if that refund did me any favors because the wings without the deal are $11. I appreciate that she tried to give me something, I would have rather had a rain check.
… more
steve f
The checkout person is clueless about customer service. Her standard response when she can’t find the order is, “it is not ready”. So, customers stand around waiting while the pizza is sitting on shelf getting cold. If is truly not ready, the customer has to ask several times (between other customers who have come in the door). I pay online for the order, so I don’t have to wait. This is not an isolated experience. You have a problem. Clue: nose ring
… more
Jasmin Huynh
This is their new garlic parm pizza and this is what it looked like… I added pepperoni and mushrooms. Where are the pepperonis at? Literally see slices without pepperoni on them. Just beware when you order a pizza from here that they’ll skimp out on your toppings that you paid for lmao.
… more
P4ncakeBoy
We had 4 pizza’s delivered ON TIME, SO FRESH, STILL HOT, BEST SERVICE, yesterday. We were so impressed. The delivery guy so so nice. Hands down best service I’ve gotten from a pizza place. I can’t wait to order again. Thanks guys!
… more
Joel Hill
Terrible burnt pizza that the store refused to replace! We have bought Pizza from this location for 10 years. Literally 5 to 6 times a month. The pizza was picked up at the store. Once home we realized burnt and inedible. The pizza was returned for another to be made. The manager refused to make another Pizza. This individual lacks all management skills and communication. Zero skills to satisfy customers. He was rude and argumentive. He absolutely refused to make another Pizza to replace the piece of Charcoal received and charged for. I’m still shocked over such a poor outcome and lack of customer satisfaction.
… more
Tony Guzman
The pizza I ordered was good but not over the top. The customer service and speed were excellent. Recommended
… more
Antique Shopper
Good location, nice employees, great tasting pizza!
… more
Roger Shively
This is more for the corporate office than this individual store but i bought my last papa John’s pizza today. I found out your website no longer allows me to opt out of tipping for delivery, and forces a minimum of 15%. I don’t mind tipping, especially when it’s busy nights, but it’s a slow Wednesday afternoon so get over yourself.
… more
… View more