Papa Johns Pizza Menu – New York, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : New York, NY

For Papa Johns Pizza in New York City, NY, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza – the more you put into it, the more you get out of it. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, our original fresh dough, or even the box itself, we invest in our ingredients to ensure that we always give you the finest quality pizza. For you, it’s not just Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. It’s a family gathering, memorable birthday, work celebration or simply a great meal. It’s our goal to make sure you always have the best ingredients for every occasion. Call us at (212) 979-7272 for delivery or stop by Grand St for carryout to order your favorite, pizza, breadsticks, or wings today!

Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. Based on 300 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Papa Johns Pizza 10002

Address:
343 Grand St, New York, NY 10002

Phone: (212) 979-7272

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–1 AM
Wednesday 11 AM–1 AM
Thursday 11 AM–1 AM
Friday 11 AM–2 AM
Saturday 11 AM–2 AM
Sunday 11 AM–1 AM
Monday 11 AM–1 AM

Menu

Wings
Papa Wings [6] $9.15
Parmesan Crusted Papadias
960 cal.
$9.15
Create Your Own Parmesan Crusted Papadia
960 cal.
$9.15
Papa Wings [8] $12.55
Papa Wings (16) $23.95
Papa Wings (24) $36.50
Papa Wings (32) $49.05
Papa Wings (40) $60.45
Papa Wings (50) $76.40
Featured Selection
Epic Stuffed Crust Create Your Own Pizza
14″ epic stuffed crust pizza. 270 cal.
$24.50
Deluxe Cheese Crispy Parm Pizza
Crispy parm crust, normal cheese, normal bake, regular sauce, normal cut, alfredo sauce. 260 cal.
$22.25
Create Your Own Crispy Parm Pizza | 14″
Crispy parm crust, 200 cal.
$22.25
Hot Lemon Pepper Chicken Poppers
Normal bake.
$11.40
Hot Lemon Pepper Chicken Poppers (30)
Normal bake.
$33.05
Hot Lemon Pepper Chicken Poppers (45)
Normal bake.
$37.65
Hot Lemon Pepper Chicken Poppers (60)
Normal bake.
$65.00
Hot Lemon Pepper Wings $9.15
Hot Lemon Pepper Wings (16) $14.85
Hot Lemon Pepper Wings (24) $27.40
Hot Lemon Pepper Wings (32) $39.90
Hot Lemon Pepper Wings (50) $67.30
Desserts
Oreo Cookie Papa Bites (8)
Cream cheese icing dipping sauce. 80 cal.
$7.40
Chocolate Chip Cookie | 8″
190 cal.
$7.40
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie | 8″
240 cal.
$7.40
Cinnamon Pull Aparts
1960 cal.
$1.75
Lunch
Cheesesticks $10.25
Chicken Poppers
Normal bake.
$11.40
Parmesan Crusted Papadia $9.15
Pepsi
20 oz. Pepsi. 250 cal.
$2.90
Create Your Own Crispy Parm Crust, 200 Cal $14.55
Papadia $16.00
Papa Picks
Pepperoni Pizza | 10″
210 cal.
$14.55
Gluten-Free Pepperoni Pizza | 10″
160 cal.
$17.40
Pepperoni Pizza | 12″
230 cal.
$17.70
Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
250 cal.
$21.10
Original Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
320 cal.
$21.10
Original Pepperoni Pizza | 16″
330 cal.
$24.80
NY Style Pepperoni Pizza | 16″
360 cal.
$24.80
Cheese Pizza | 10″
180 cal.
$14.55
Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza | 10″
150 cal.
$17.40
Original Cheese Pizza | 12″
190 cal.
$17.70
Thin Cheese Pizza | 14″
200 cal.
$21.10
Original Cheese Pizza | 14″
270 cal.
$21.10
Original Cheese Pizza | 16″
280 cal.
$24.80
NY Style Cheese Pizza | 16″
310 cal.
$24.80
Epic Stuffed Crust Create Your Own Pizza | 14″
Epic stuffed crust. 270 cal.
$24.50
Epic Pepperoni-Stuffed Crust Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
Epic pepperoni-stuffed crust. 320 cal.
$25.65
Create Your Own Crispy Parm Pizza | 14″
Crispy parm crust. 200 cal.
$22.25
Original Sausage Pizza | 10″
220 cal.
$14.55
Gluten-Free Sausage Pizza | 10″
170 cal.
$17.40
Original Sausage Pizza | 12″
240 cal.
$17.70
Original Sausage Pizza | 14″
260 cal.
$21.10
Original Sausage Pizza | 16″
340 cal.
$24.80
NY Style Sausage Pizza | 16″
400 cal.
$24.80
Deluxe Cheese Crispy Parm Pizza
Crispy parm crust, normal cheese, normal bake, normal bake, normal cut, Alfredo sauce. 260 cal.
$22.25
Papa Bowls
Chicken Alfredo Papa Bowl
Alfredo sauce. 570 cal.
$9.70
Create Your Own Papa Bowl
Alfredo sauce.
$9.70
Italian Meats Trio Papa Bowl
Alfredo sauce. 880 cal.
$9.70
Garden Veggie Papa Bowl
Original sauce. 380 cal.
$9.70
Pizza | 10″
Original Create Your Own Pizza | 10″
180 cal.
$14.55
Original BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 10″
230 cal.
$16.55
Original Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 10″
210 cal.
$16.55
Original Meats Pizza | 10″
250 cal.
$16.55
Original Super Hawaiian Pizza | 10″
230 cal.
$16.55
Original Garden Fresh Pizza | 10″
190 cal.
$16.55
Original Works Pizza | 10″
230 cal.
$16.55
Original Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza | 10″
240 cal.
$16.55
Original Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 10″
230 cal.
$16.55
Original Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza | 10″
260 cal.
$16.55
Original Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 10″
240 cal.
$16.55
Original Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | 10″
220 cal.
$16.55
Original Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 10″
220 cal.
$16.55
Original Zesty Italian Trio Pizza | 10″
240 cal.
$16.55
Original Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | 10″
190 cal.
$16.55
Original Meatball Pepperoni Pizza | 10″
230 cal.
$16.55
Pizza | 12″
Original Create Your Own Pizza | 12″
190 cal.
$17.70
Original Meats Pizza | 12″
260 cal.
$19.40
Original Super Hawaiian Pizza | 12″
230 cal.
$19.40
Original Garden Fresh Pizza | 12″
200 cal.
$19.40
Original Works Pizza | 12″
230 cal.
$19.40
Original Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza | 12″
250 cal.
$19.40
Original BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 12″
250 cal.
$19.40
Original Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 12″
250 cal.
$19.40
Original Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza | 12″
280 cal.
$19.40
Original Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 12″
250 cal.
$19.40
Original Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | 12″
230 cal.
$19.40
Original Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 12″
230 cal.
$19.40
Original Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 12″
230 cal.
$19.40
Original Zesty Italian Trio Pizza | 12″
260 cal.
$19.40
Original Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | 12″
200 cal.
$19.40
Original Meatball Pepperoni Pizza | 12″
240 cal.
$19.40
Thin Pizza | 14″
Thin Create Your Own Pizza | 14″
200 cal.
$21.10
Thin Meats Pizza | 14″
300 cal.
$22.25
Thin Super Hawaiian Pizza | 14″
260 cal.
$22.25
Thin Garden Fresh Pizza | 14″
210 cal.
$22.25
Thin Works Pizza | 14″
270 cal.
$22.25
Thin Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
290 cal.
$22.25
Thin BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 14″
280 cal.
$22.25
Thin Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 14″
280 cal.
$22.25
Thin Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza | 14″
320 cal.
$22.25
Thin Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 14″
290 cal.
$22.25
Thin Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | 14″
250 cal.
$22.25
Thin Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 14″
250 cal.
$22.25
Thin Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 14″
260 cal.
$22.25
Thin Zesty Italian Trio Pizza | 14″
300 cal.
$22.25
Thin Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | 14″
210 cal.
$22.25
Thin Meatball Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
280 cal.
$22.25
Pizza | 14″
Original Create Your Own Pizza | 14″
270 cal.
$21.10
Original Meats Pizza | 14″
380 cal.
$22.25
Original Super Hawaiian Pizza | 14″
340 cal.
$22.25
Original Garden Fresh Pizza | 14″
280 cal.
$22.25
Original Works Pizza | 14″
340 cal.
$22.25
Original Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
360 cal.
$22.25
Original BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 14″
350 cal.
$22.25
Original Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 14″
360 cal.
$22.25
Original Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza | 14″
390 cal.
$22.25
Original Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 14″
360 cal.
$22.25
Original Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | 14″
320 cal.
$22.25
Original Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 14″
320 cal.
$22.25
Original Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 14″
330 cal.
$22.25
Original Zesty Italian Trio Pizza | 14″
370 cal.
$22.25
Original Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | 14″
290 cal.
$22.25
Original Meatball Pepperoni Pizza | 14″
360 cal.
$22.25
Pizza | 16″
Original Create Your Own Pizza | 16″
280 cal.
$24.80
Original Meats Pizza | 16″
410 cal.
$25.65
Original Super Hawaiian Pizza | 16″
360 cal.
$25.65
Original Garden Fresh Pizza | 16″
300 cal.
$25.65
Original Works Pizza | 16″
360 cal.
$25.65
Original Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
Original BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
Original Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
Original Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese Pizza | 16″
410 cal.
$25.65
Original Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 16″
380 cal.
$25.65
Original Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | 16″
330 cal.
$25.65
Original Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 16″
330 cal.
$25.65
Original Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 16″
350 cal.
$25.65
Original Zesty Italian Trio Pizza | 16″
390 cal.
$25.65
Original Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | 16″
300 cal.
$25.65
Original Meatball Pepperoni Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Pizza | 16″
NY Style Create Your Own Pizza | 16″
310 cal.
$24.80
NY Style Meats Pizza | 16″
440 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Super Hawaiian Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Garden Fresh Pizza | 16″
310 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Works Pizza | 16″
390 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza | 16″
400 cal.
$25.65
NY Style BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 16″
430 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Pepperoni, Sausage, & Six Cheese | 16″
480 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 16″
410 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza | 16″
360 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 16″
370 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 16″
360 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Zesty Italian Trio Pizza | 16″
420 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza | 16″
310 cal.
$25.65
NY Style Meatball Pepperoni Pizza | 16″
450 cal.
$25.65
Gluten-Free Pizza | 10″
Gluten-Free Meats Pizza | 10″
200 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free Super Hawaiian Pizza | 10″
170 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free Garden Fresh Pizza | 10″
140 cal.
$16.55
Gluten Free Works Pizza | 10″
170 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza | 10″
200 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza | 10″
170 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free Philly Cheesesteak Pizza | 10″
180 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza | 10″
180 cal.
$16.55
Gluten-Free Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza | 10″
160 cal.
$16.55
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust | 10″
150 cal.
$17.40
Papadias
Papadias
830 cal.
$8.00
Create Your Own Papadia $8.00
Create Your Own Parmesan Crusted Papadia $9.15
Parmesan Crusted Papadias
960 cal.
$9.15
Extras
Dipping Sauce
150 cal.
$0.60
Add-On $1.15
Seasoning Packet $1.15
Sides
Cheesesticks
90 cal.
$10.25
Papa Bites
110 cal.
$7.40
Garlic Knots (8)
10 ” garlic knots. 110 cal.
$6.85
Breadsticks $8.00
Drinks
Soft Drink | 20 Oz $2.90
Soft Drink | 2L $4.05
Tea $2.90
Aquafina Water
20 oz.
$2.90

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jonathan Lee
During my years, I would go to this place because I used to have family that lived nearby so I would go and get takeout for dinner. Since I had different types of pizza there, they were really good because it tasted nice and fresh right out of the oven. You even get a free jalapeno if you are into eating spicy stuff. Sometimes, they even had some good deals for a pizza and I would highly recommend you get it because it is really good. These are the goods on why Papa John’s is worth going to. However at Papa John’s, if you have a sensitive stomache like I did, I would highly stay away from the buffalo chicken pizza because when I ate a buffalo chicken pizza, I had food poising and had to rush to the bathroom four times because they chicken was too raw and not cooked well enough and it was the most painful thing that I had ever experienced. If you order buffalo chicken pizza but have a sensitive stomache, try to asking the staff to have the chicken removed from the pizza because the chicken may contain raw meat which can cause you to have food poising. Additionally, when you walk into this place, sometimes it takes very long until someone comes up to the register to take your order which can be annoying and frustrating that they see you but continue to mind their business. So if you are looking for some choices of pizzas to eat, you can create your own toppings and select the size you want. My recommendation is to choose pepperoni and whatever topping you want to choose. These are all the experiences that I had when I went to Papa John’s to get takeout and eat their fresh pizza. It was worth it since the food I got was nice and fresh. Since my family moved, and none of my family live nearby anymore, I cannot come back since I live far but would like to thank them for creating a welcome atmosphere when I came to place my order. If you are hungary and want to eat pizza, this is a good place to go and get your pizza since the pizza taste nice and fresh. Thank you staff.

… more

Shubham Bhatia
I have been very thrilled and have been very satisfied by the service provided by Mahbub. He has been very helpful and supportive while making the order. You should always ask for him. He is generous and makes sure to help you to make the best order as per your convenience.

… more

L. Fong
Friendly staff. Quick service. Affordable prices. Good selection od pizzas. Made fresh & to order. No tables or chairs to sit down to eat. Long wait time for orders to be made because food is fresh.

… more

Matt Daniel
Decent pizza at a good price. I did carry out and it was ready by the time I walked there. Always use the discounts online for them. Two topping large pizza is about $19. Delivery is $2.99. The place itself looks clean and the staff nice enough. Hope this helps!

… more

Anthony Aurelia
Great location, nice staff and food is as you’d expect.

… more

ann aquino
If I could give it less than one star I would the food is substandard fake cheese and no sauce on the pizza I ordered a double cheese pizza there was barely enough cheese on there to make it a regular pizza.not worth the price I paid for it

… more

Mickster
Pizza was good but service is terrible. The gentleman behind the counter didn’t seem to understand what I was saying. I ordered 4 individual slices to go and he decided to pile the pizza on top of each other. He was going to put it in a paper bag. I had to request a box. He acted like he was doing me a favor.

… more

José Manuel Castillo
There is no seats to eat, only take out. But the Tuscan six cheese pizza was good.

… more

Neko Troupe
The wait will be a few minutes as the workers get the pizzas made and fixed out but when they get to the front desk to take your orders things go on smoothly from there. Occasionally i would ask to switch out a sauce for peppers instead and they do which is very nice.

… more

Tom W. H. IV James
The only problem that they need to work on is the people that handle over the phone orders. They have people that treat people with the care and respect that they would want if it were them making the order. THEN They have those who are so disrespectful that they end up having people canceling orders do to the lack/level of disrespect that is given. THEY KNOW FULL WELL THAT IF THE SHOE WAS ON THE OTHER FOOT THEY THEMSELVES WOULD NOT WANT THE SAME.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions