Papa Gallo Mexican Restaurant Menu – Fayetteville, NY

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : Fayetteville, NY

Vibrant space for Mexican fare, margaritas & happy hour, plus a weekday kids-eat-free special. Based on 580 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Papa Gallo Mexican Restaurant 13066

Address:
205 W Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066

Phone: (315) 632-4789

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 4–8:30 PM
Wednesday 4–8:30 PM
Thursday 4–8:30 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed

Menu

Online Take Out
Chips & Salsa
house fried corn tortilla chips, chipotle spicy salsa & pico de gallo
$7.00
Chips, Salsa & Queso
house fried corn tortilla chips, chipotle spicy salsa, pico de gallo & poblano cerveza queso
$13.00
Chips & Queso
cheese, roasted poblano peppers, beer
$7.00
Large Guacamole
house guacamole comes with house fried corn tortilla chips
$9.00
Tres Botana
house fried corn tortilla chips, chipotle spicy salsa, pico de gallo, large guacamole & poblano cerveza queso
$20.00
Nachos
topped with choice of: ground beef, pulled chicken, adobo pork, or smoked shredded beef, refried beans, house queso, jalapenos, pico de gallo, guacamole & seasoned sour cream
$18.00
Jerk Shrimp Appetizer
four grilled jerk marinated shrimp, jerk dipping sauce
$14.00
Bowl Poblano Chowder
roasted poblano peppers, corn, potato & cheddar cheese
$8.00
Bowl Of Chicken Tortilla Soup
a broth of chicken, tomatoes & carrots topped with crisp tortilla strips, fresh avocado & cilantro
$8.00
Gallo Chicken Salad
mixed greens, red onions, candied pecans, orange supremes & goat cheese, grilled sliced 6oz chicken breast
$18.00
Jerk Chicken Salad
a bed of romaine lettuce, with black beans, pico de gallo, corn & avocado, grilled sliced 6oz chicken breast
$18.00
Gallo Salad
mixed greens, red onions, candied pecans, orange supremes & goat cheese
$9.00
Jerk Salad
a bed of romaine lettuce, with black beans, pico de gallo, corn & avocado
$9.00
Taco Salad
chopped romaine, crisp flour tortilla bowl, with Spanish rice, pinto beans, pico de gallo, guacamole, seasoned sour cream, cheese blend & choice of: ground beef, adobo pork, pulled chicken, smoked
$16.00
Jerk Shrimp Salad
Five jerk marinated grilled shrimp, romaine lettuce, black beans, corn, pico de gallo, avacado, jerk vinaigrette
$23.00
Gallo Steak Salad
mixed greens, red onions, candied pecans, orange supremes & goat cheese, grilled sliced 8oz flank steak
$21.00
Jerk Steak Salad
a bed of romaine lettuce, with black beans, pico de gallo, corn & avocado, grilled sliced 8oz flank steak
$21.00
Tico Burrito
shredded smoked sirloin or ground beef, rojo sauce
$17.00
Diablo Burrito
HOT!! adobo pork, habanero salsa, topped with jalapeños, rojo sauce
$17.00
“Verde Burrito
pulled chicken, pico de gallo, verde sauce
$17.00
Cowboy Burritos
adobo pork, borracho beans, morita sauce, chipotle aioli, fried onions
$17.00
Pescado Burrito
crisp mahi, pickled onions, verde sauce & chipotle aioli
$18.00
Camaron Burrito
sautéed baby shrimp, black beans, chayote squash, red onion, baby tomato, quest fresco, morita & tomatillo cream
$18.00
Veggie Burrito
marinated and sautéed criminology mushrooms, zucchini & cherry tomatoes, Chihuahua cheese, choice of sauce
$15.00
Pollo Verde Dinner
pulled chicken in a verde sauce, black bean-corn salsa, mixed cheese blend. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of refried, black or borracho beans
$17.00
Al Pastor Taco Dinner
braised adobo pork with onion & grilled pineapple, Chihuahua cheese. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of refried, black or borracho beans
$17.00
Ground Beef Taco Dinner
house seasoned ground beef, seasoned shredded cabbage & mixed cheese blend. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of refried, black or borracho beans
$15.50
Barbacoa Taco Dinner
smoked pulled beef, seasoned shredded cabbage & Chihuahua cheese. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of refried, black or borracho beans
$17.00
Carne Asada Taco Dinner
sauteed smoked sirloin steak with pico de gallo, sliced avocado & queso fresco. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of refried, black or borracho beans
$18.00
Pescado Taco Dinner
crispy fried mahi, chipotle aioli, seasoned shredded cabbage, pickled red onion, mixed cheese blend. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of refried, black or borracho beans
$18.00
Vegetable Taco Dinner
sauteed mushrooms, zucchini, cherry tomatoes & onions, queso fresco cheese. Three soft tacos come with pico de gallo, sour cream, Spanish rice, & your choice of beans
$16.00
Jerk Shrimp Tacos
Jerk seasoned sauteed baby shrimp, house slaw, queso fresco, fresh cilantro, pico de gallo, jerk vinaigrette, 3 per order, Spanish rice & choice of beans
$18.00
Chicken Quesadilla
flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo & chicken. Served with Spanish rice, choice of beans & sour cream
$17.00
Ground Beef Quesadilla
flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo & ground beef. Served with Spanish rice, choice of beans & sour cream
$17.00
Shredded Beef Quesadilla
flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo & shredded smoked beef. Served with Spanish rice, choice of beans & sour cream
$17.00
Adobo Pork Quesadilla
flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo & shredded smoked beef. Served with Spanish rice, choice of beans & sour cream
$17.00
Vegetable Quesadilla
flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo & vegetables. Served with Spanish rice, choice of beans & sour cream
$17.00
Bean Quesadilla
flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo & beans. Served with Spanish rice, choice of beans & sour cream
$16.00
Chicken Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese & chicken. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$17.00
Ground Beef Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese & ground beef. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$17.00
Shredded Beef Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese & shredded beef. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$17.00
Adobo Pork Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese & adobo pork. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$17.00
Vegetable Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese & vegetable medley. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$17.00
Cheese Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$16.00
Mixed Enchiladas
three corn tortillas filled with cheese & choice of fillings & sauce. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans & sauce
$17.00
Bean & Cheese Enchiladas
Corn tortillas with mixed cheese & beans, choice of sauce. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans
$16.00
Chicken Fajitas
Chicken breast served on a sizzling platter with peppers & onions, flour tortillas, sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole & cheese blend. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans
$18.00
Shrimp Fajitas
Shrimp served on a sizzling platter with peppers & onions, flour tortillas, sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole & cheese blend. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans
$20.00
Steak Fajitas
Seasoned smoked steak served on a sizzling platter with peppers & onions, flour tortillas, sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole & cheese blend. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans
$22.00
Steak & Shrimp Fajitas
Steak and shrimp served on a sizzling platter with peppers & onions, flour tortillas, sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole & cheese blend. Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans
$25.00
Kids Taco’s
Two tacos, choice of meat, side of fries
$8.00
Kids Cheese Quesadilla
Just cheese & fries
$8.00
Kids Quesadilla
Flour tortillas with cheese and choice of meat, side of fries
$8.00
Kids Chicken Tenders
Three fried chicken fingers with a side of fries
$8.00
Kids Taco’s
Two tacos, choice of meat, side of fries
$8.00
Kids Cheese Quesadilla
Just cheese & fries
$8.00
Kids Quesadilla
Flour tortillas with cheese and choice of meat, side of fries
$8.00
Kids Chicken Fingers
Three fried chicken fingers with a side of fries
$8.00
Side Rice
a side dish of our Spanish Rice
$3.00
Side Beans
Vegetarian Refried Beans
Vegetarian Black Beans
Borracho Beans with Bacon & Beer
$3.00
Side Of Chips $2.00
Side Of Fries $3.50
Side Large Queso No Chips
cheese, roasted poblano peppers, beer
$6.00
Side Of Soft Flour Tortillas X 4 $1.50
Side Of Soft Corn Tortillas X 4 $1.50
Food Truck
Adult Entree $12.96
Kid Entree $5.56

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Cora Jo
Horrible food! Food was cold and had no flavor. Waitress messed up and entered the wrong order and the manager yelled at us?! The waitress did apologize but after she had messed up our order twice, I was done accepting apologizes. The food is overpriced and this is not authentic Mexican food. Save yourself the money and go to a local mom and pop restaurant.

… more

Daniel Stinson
Great place for dinner. We try to go here every other month because we both love the food. The queso is amazing. My only complaint is after ordering our apps, we have hardly any time to enjoy them because our main course has already come out! The food is delicious and anything can be substituted if you don’t like something.

… more

Andrew Gaydo
I used to really like this place. I went back there tonight and I’m really sad to see what happened. The wait staff was disengaged. The place was half full and it still took over 20 minutes to even have a drink order taken. It took almost an hour and a half from when we were seated until we received a kid’s meal and 3 simple entrees.

… more

Kyle Wood
Amazing staff, quick turnaround time from ordering to receiving our food, which was delicious and huge portions as well! Our server was friendly and attentive which was a breath of fresh air after a long day of traveling with all the aggressive drivers (which seems to be EVERYONE lately!)

… more

Jennifer Tedesco
Wonderful Vibe the minute I walked in the door! Food was delicious served in a timely fashion! Kitchen staff extremely friendly! Bartender so cheerful and very knowledgeable! Definitely will be visiting again soon!

… more

Jay Dossett
Food was phenomenal our waitress was very lackadaisical and didn’t really tend to us much or any of her other tables. Though I feel if we had different server it would have been easy 5 ⭐ as every other waitress was on top of the game. A

… more

Brad Rogers
Huge portions. The margaritas are typical restaurant margaritas. High on sugar. But they do tend to be fairly tasty. Service is great!

… more

Wilson Cortes
I always love going here from time to time. It was a beautiful day, so we sat outside. Our waitress was awesome, and the food was good. I would recommend going if you haven’t been.

… more

William Mitrus
Great place. Owner cares about the place. Staff seem happy for the most part. Have not had a bad experience here and have been coming for roughly 2 years.

… more

Caitlin Spencer
Very good, fresh mexican food. Have Been Here multiple times and have never left disappointed. Prices are very reasonable, food is cooked perfectly, and the staff is always friendly and you never have to wait more than a minute for help.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions