Panthers Pizza, in Nappanee, IN, is the leading pizza restaurant serving Elkhart, Kosciusko and Marshall counties since 2018. We offer pizza, pasta, calzones, soups, sandwiches, wings, salads, gift cards, lunch specials, catering, and much more. For your next meal, visit Panthers Pizza in Nappanee.
Based on 209 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
105 S Locke St, Nappanee, IN 46550
Phone: (574) 773-0022
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Danielle Hooven
Love their pizza but today I had mine delivered. Ordered 2 pizzas one with just bacon second bacon and mushrooms. I got the 2 topping the second had sausage not bacon. I paid for delivery and was informed that the pizza tipper insists he only put bacon and if I wanted to dispute this to drive my pizza back to them let them be the judge and if they did wrong then I would have to wait to have another one made for me. I already paid 55.74 for 2 pizzas to be delivered and I’ve been up since 4 am for work it’s now 815 pm I’m tired that’s why I had it delivered . Nice customer service and standing behind your product.
Jason Mishler
We frequent here. The pizza is really good, but their downfall is their ability to accurately give a time the pizza will be done. Rule of thumb: add 30 minute to whatever time your given. Otherwise I would give 5 star review.
Spend’n & Eat’n Living Da Life
I love pizza so much, and often just eat at random pizza places just to try their pizza. I stumbled on this pizza shop, this is really great pizza. They’re very busy, and wait times can be longer than usual on busy days, but the quality is there, this pizza shop, I highly recommend. Whenever I’m back in the area, I will stop and dine inside.
Tim
Worst spaghetti and meat balls EVER. 75 minute wait and another 10 mins when i showed up to warm 2 breadsticks. The spaghetti was definitely lacking flavor 3out of 10 no gift card was received. Let me know when I receive it
enders227
Great homemade pizza! Panther bread is awesome as well. Great value on their single slice meals too!
theredneckwoman
I ordered a small pizza with mushrooms on half. They put all the veggies on half as well. Only wanted mushrooms on half.
Joseph Schroeder
My experience with Panthers is hit or miss. When they miss, they miss big. I enjoy the taste of their pizza and the customer service is just fine. But there have been multiple times where we have had to bake individual pieces, after bringing it home, because it was almost like soup in the middle of the pizza. Very unappetizing. They show you the pizza before you take it home but it’s difficult to tell that there’s really doughy crust under the toppings. I’d love to continue supporting a local business but if I’m going to get fully cooked pizza only half of the time, l will have to give them up.
Charles Secord
Went there twice. The first time, waited for almost 2 hours to get the wrong pizza. Got my money back and left. Second time waited for over a hour, finally got the right pizza but only after the cashier struggled to find my order. Definitely won’t give them a third try.
Luke Skwalker
The pizza isn’t boneless.
Anthony Green
Its a nice pizza parlor with very good food. The atmosphere resembles the traditional 80’s/90’s pizza parlor; they even have a video game from that era set to “freeplay” next to the front door. The pizzas themselves are substantial and very tasty. They also serve sandwiches, pastas, wings, and ice cream (either in a cone or pre-packaged pint), but I didn’t order any of these things. They lose a star for this:
… View more