Paisano's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria Menu

Classic Italian & American eats, plus homestyle breakfasts, served in a casual cafe with a lounge. Based on 671 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Paisano's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria 53172

Address:
113 N Chicago Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172

Phone: (414) 856-9020

Website:

Hours

Thursday	11 AM–9 PM
Friday	11 AM–10 PM
Saturday	11 AM–10 PM
Sunday	11 AM–9 PM
Monday	11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday	11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–9 PM

APPETIZERS / FROM OUR GARDEN
Baked Garlic Bread Our famous garlic bread topped with mozzarella cheese.	$6.95
Baked Pizza Bread Topped with our famous sauce & mozzarella cheese.	$7.95
Breaded Eggplant Served with lemon wedge & homemade sauce.	$12.95
Breaded Mushrooms Fried to a golden brown.	$8.95
Chef Salad Fresh crisp lettuce, ham, American cheese, Swiss cheese, turkey, tomatoes, & cucumbers.	$12.95
Chicken Tenders Fresh strips of chicken breast, breaded & fried crispy, served over french fries & with our ranch dressing.	$12.95
Chicken Wings (10) Ask for our flavors, fried until golden brown, served with ranch dressing.	$14.95
Crispy Chicken Salad Hand breaded, boneless chicken breast served on top of greens, garnished with fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, black olives, & mozzarella cheese.	$13.95
Garlic Bread Complement your pizza with the best garlic bread in town.	$4.25
Grilled Chicken Salad Grilled boneless chicken breast served on top of crisp greens, garnished with fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, black olives, & mozzarella cheese.	$13.95
Italian Salad Fresh crisp lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, & pepperoni.	$12.95
Jalapeno Poppers (6) Stuffed with cream cheese & served with homemade sauce.	$7.95
Mediterranean Italian Tomato & Onion Salad Fresh green peppers, tomato wedges, onions, garlic, oregano, salt, & olive oil.	$12.95
Mozzarella Sticks (6) Fried to a golden brown & served with homemade sauce.	$7.95
Onion Rings Breaded & deep fried to a golden brown.	$6.95
Paisano’s Combo Something for everyone: Breaded mushrooms, breaded cauliflower (currently out of item; will substitute a pieces of our new breaded ravioli), onion rings, mozzarella sticks, & jalapeno poppers with our homemade sauce.	$14.95
Side House Salad Fresh crisp lettuce, tomato, & cucumbers.	$4.95
Waffle Fries	$5.95
SANDWICHES, MELT SHOPPE & CLUBS
Charboiled Chicken Breast on a Bun Chicken breast charbroiled to perfection, served with lettuce, tomatoes, & mayonnaise.	$11.95
Chicken Filet on a Bun Hand breaded, skinless chicken breast fried to a golden brown & served with lettuce, tomatoes, & mayonnaise.	$11.95
Chicken Melt 6 oz. chicken breast served on rye bread with Swiss cheese, & fried onions.	$10.95
Chicken Parmigiana on a Bun Boneless, skinless chicken breast hand breaded, topped with mozzarella cheese & our homemade sauce.	$13.95
Club #1 Includes layers of bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, & mayo on toast.	$12.95
Club #2 Includes layers of bacon, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, & mayo on toast.	$12.95
Club #3 Includes layers of bacon, ham, lettuce, tomatoes, & mayo on toast.	$12.95
Club #4 Includes layers of American cheese, turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, & mayo on toast.	$12.95
Club #5 Includes layers of, ham, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, & mayo on toast.	$12.95
Club #6 Includes layers of bacon, ham, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, & mayo on toast.	$12.95
Double Cheeseburger Two 1/3 pounders served with lettuce, & tomatoes. Add Bacon $1.	$12.95
French Dip Thinly sliced roast beef served on a hoagie bun with Au Jus.	$12.25
Grilled Cheese White Texas toast grilled with American cheese.	$8.95
Grilled Ham & Cheese White Texas toast grilled with ham and American cheese.	$10.95
Haddock on Bun Served with lettuce, tomato, & tartar sauce.	$9.95
Ham & Bacon Melt Served on rye bread with Swiss cheese, & fried onions.	$10.95
Hamburger 1/3 pound served with lettuce & tomatoes. Add cheese $0.50; Add Bacon $1.00.	$9.95
Hamburger (1/2 lb.) 1/2 pounder served with lettuce & tomatoes. Add Cheese $0.50. Add Bacon $1.00.	$10.95
Italian Roast Beef Thinly sliced roast beef with mozzarella cheese, & homemade sauce served on a hoagie bun.	$12.95
Italian Sausage Bomber Italian sausage link served on a hoagie bun with mozzarella cheese & our homemade sauce.	$11.95
Meatball Bomber Homemade meatballs, served on a hoagie bun with mozzarella cheese & our homemade sauce.	$11.95
Monte Carlo Egg-dipped Texas bread grilled and topped with swiss and American cheese, deli-sliced turkey and bacon.	$11.95
Monte Cristo With Swiss and American cheese, Deli-sliced Ham. Egg-dipped Texas bread grilled & topped.	$11.95
Mushroom Swiss Burger 1/3 pounder served with lettuce & tomatoes.	$11.95
Patty Melt 1/3 pound burger served on rye bread with Swiss cheese, & fried onions.	$10.95
Philly Burger Bomber Beef patty on a hoagie bun, topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.	$13.95
Philly Cheesesteak Sliced roast beef served on a hoagie bun topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.	$12.95
Philly Chicken Bomber Sliced chicken breast on a hoagie bun, topped with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, onions, & green peppers.	$13.95
Pizza Burger Pizza sausage grilled to perfection, served on a hoagie bun with mozzarella cheese & homemade sauce.	$11.95
Roast Beef & Brown Gravy Served on a hoagie bun.	$12.95
Smothered Steak Sandwich 6 oz. top sirloin, smothered with mushrooms, onions, mozzarella, & American cheese served on a hoagie bun.	$14.95
Steak Melt 6 oz. top sirloin served on rye bread, with Swiss cheese & fried onions.	$13.95
Turkey Melt Turkey served on rye bread with Swiss cheese, & fried onions.	$10.95
Veal Parmigiana on a Bun Topped with mozzarella cheese, & our homemade sauce served on a bun.	$12.95
ITALIAN ENTREES
Baked Cannelloni Seasoned ground beef stuffed into a homemade pasta shell, topped with our homemade sauce & mozzarella cheese.	$14.95
Baked Manicotti Three cheeses blended together & seasoned. Stuffed into a homemade pasta shell, topped with our homemade sauce, & mozzarella cheese.	$13.95
Baked Mostaccioli Mostaccioli topped with mozzarella & homemade sauce.	$13.95
Cheese Tortellini in Alfredo Sauce Cheese pasta rings topped with homemade white sauce.	$15.95
Cheese Tortellini in Red Sauce Cheese pasta rings topped with homemade red sauce.	$14.95
Chicken Parmigiana & Lasagna Combo Hand breaded chicken breast, topped with mozzarella cheese, served with a generous portion of lasagna & our homemade sauce.	$18.95
Chicken Parmigiana with Pasta Boneless, skinless, chicken breast hand breaded, topped with mozzarella cheese & our homemade sauce.	$15.95
Chopped Sicilian Beef Steak with Pasta Chopped beef steak grilled to perfection, seasoned & topped with mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, & homemade sauce.	$15.95
Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta Eggplant fried to a golden brown, topped with mozzarella cheese & homemade sauce.	$15.95
Fettuccini Alfredo Fettuccini tossed in our homemade alfredo sauce. Add shrimp or chicken for an additional fee.	$12.95
Homemade Beef Lasagna Made with ground & seasoned beef & a blend of three cheeses – Romano, ricotta, & mozzarella; & our homemade sauce.	$16.95
Homemade Cheese or Beef Ravioli A blend of three cheeses or beef mixed with spices, wrapped in a homemade pasta pillow, topped with our homemade sauce.	$14.95
Italian Connection Combination of chicken parmigiana, cannelloni, manicotti, meat ravioli, & cheese ravioli topped with our homemade sauce & mozzarella cheese.	$20.95
Italian Sausage Platter with Pasta Italian sausage links topped with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, tomato, mozzarella cheese, & our homemade sauce.	$14.95
Meat Tortellini Pasta rings filled with meat, topped with our homemade sauce.	$14.95
Pasta A choice of mostaccioli, or spaghetti topped with our homemade sauce.	$10.95
Shrimp & Crab Ravioli Stuffed cheese ravioli topped with shrimp, crab meat, & our homemade white sauce.	$17.95
Shrimp Siciliano Fettuccini topped with mushrooms, onions, peppers, tomatoes, & garlic butter.	$18.95
Sicilian Beef with Pasta Thinly sliced beef simmered in our sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, & homemade sauce.	$15.95
Sicilian Chicken Breast with Pasta Boneless, skinless chicken breast seasoned & grilled to perfection. Topped with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomato, mozzarella cheese & homemade sauce.	$15.95
Sicilian Lasagna Our homemade beef lasagna topped with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomato, & mozzarella cheese.	$17.95
Sicilian Pork Chops with Pasta Tow pork chops, charbroiled & topped with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, & tomato.	$15.95
Sicilian Veal with Pasta Seasoned & breaded veal topped with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomato, mozzarella cheese, & homemade sauce.	$15.95
Tour of Italy Combination of lasagna, cannelloni, manicotti, meat & cheese ravioli topped with mozzarella cheese & our homemade sauce.	$20.95
Veal Parmigiana & Lasagna Combo Seasoned & breaded veal topped with mozzarella cheese & served with a slice of lasagna with our homemade sauce.	$18.95
Veal Parmigiana with Pasta Seasoned & breaded veal topped with mozzarella cheese & our homemade sauce.	$14.95
FROM THE WOK / SEA / CHAR BROILER
Alaskan Stir Fry Combination of crab, shrimp, with vegetables sauteed & served over rice. Includes our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$18.95
Baked Lemon Pepper Cod (4pc) Seasoned with lemon pepper, baked to perfection & served with drawn butter. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$15.95
Baked Salmon 8 oz. salmon seasoned & baked to perfection. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$16.95
Beef Stir Fry Cubes of sirloin marinated & sauteed with vegetables, served over rice. Includes our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$16.95
Breaded Sicilian Steak With Italian seasoned bread crumbs, & topped with green peppers. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$25.95
Broiled Baby Cod (4pc) Baby cod broiled & seasoned to perfection. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$15.95
Broiled Sicilian Cod (3pc) Baby cod broiled & topped with mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomato, mozzarella cheese, & topped with our homemade sauce. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$17.95
Charbroiled Prime Rib Twelve to fourteen ounce choice rib, charbroiled to perfection & served with fresh sauteed mushrooms. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$27.95
Chicken Stir Fry Sauteed chicken breast with vegetables & served over rice. Includes our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$16.95
Chopped Beef Steak Fresh ground beef charbroiled to perfection with sauteed onions. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$12.95
Delmonico Steak Ten ounce top sirloin steak charbroiled & topped with mushrooms, onions, & mozzarella cheese. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$25.95
Fantail Shrimp Seven jumbo shrimp lightly breaded & deep fried. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$16.95
Fish Fry – Beer Battered Cod (Friday’s Only) 3 piece, fried until golden brown. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$13.95
Lake Perch Lightly breaded perch filets. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$14.95
New York Strip Twelve to fourteen ounce; Charbroiled to perfection & topped with fresh sauteed mushrooms. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$27.95
Shrimp Stir Fry Shrimp marinated & sauteed with vegetables & served over rice. Includes our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$18.95
Sicilian Steak Ten ounce top sirloin charbroiled to perfection, topped with fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, & tomatoes. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$25.95
Smothered Baby Cod Baby cod smothered with mozzarella & American cheese, mushrooms, broccoli, & onions. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$17.95
Top Sirloin Butt Steak (10 oz.) Perfectly charbroiled & topped with fresh sauteed mushrooms. Includes choice of potato & our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$24.95
Vegetarian Stir Fry Generous portion of vegetables sauteed & served over rice. Includes our famous garlic bread or Italian bread & coleslaw.	$15.95
SIDE ORDERS
American Fries	$4.25
Baked Potato	$3.25
Coleslaw	$2.25
French Fries	$4.25
Italian Sausage	$4.25
Mashed Potatoes	$3.25
Meatballs (2)	$4.25
Mixed Vegetables	$4.95
Pudding	$2.75
Side of Fettuccini Alfredo	$7.95
Side of Pasta (Mostaccioli or Spaghetti)	$6.50
DOWN HOME DINNERS
Baked Italian Chicken Breast Seasoned with Italian bread crumbs & baked to perfection.	$14.95
Breaded Pork Chops Two center cut pork chops hand breaded & fried to a golden brown.	$14.95
Breaded Veal Cutlets Two breaded veal cutlets fried to a golden brown & topped with a brown gravy.	$14.95
Charbroiled Pork Chops Two center cut pork chops charbroiled to perfection.	$14.95
Fried Chicken One half chicken, hand breaded & fried to a golden brown.	$13.95
Liver & Onions Tender beef liver served with fried onions.	$12.95
Old Fashion Mushroom Steak Ground beef patty topped with mushrooms, onions, mozzarella cheese & brown gravy.	$14.95
Roast Beef with Brown Gravy USDA beef sirloin thinly sliced & simmered in brown gravy.	$14.95
Smothered Chicken Breast Chicken breast, smothered with mozzarella & American cheese, mushrooms, onions, & broccoli.	$14.95
BUCKETS / PARTY
Baked Mostaccioli (1/2 Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$55.00
Chicken (12 Pieces)	$21.95
Chicken (16 Pieces)	$24.95
Chicken (24 Pieces)	$30.95
Chicken (8 Pieces)	$18.95
Chicken Alfredo (Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$95.00
Chicken Alfredo (1/2 Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$60.00
Cod (12 Pieces)	$24.95
Cod (16 Pieces)	$28.95
Cod (24 Pieces)	$36.95
Cod (8 Pieces)	$20.95
FS Chicken (12 Pieces)	$25.95
FS Chicken (16 Pieces)	$28.95
FS Chicken (24 Pieces)	$34.95
FS Chicken (8 Pieces)	$22.95
FS Cod (12 Pieces)	$28.95
FS Cod (16 Pieces)	$32.95
FS Cod (24 Pieces)	$40.95
FS Cod (8 Pieces)	$24.95
FS Shrimp (12 Pieces)	$27.95
FS Shrimp (16 Pieces)	$29.95
FS Shrimp (24 Pieces)	$35.95
Garden Salad (1/2 Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$30.00
Meat Lasagna (1/2 Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$60.00
Mostaccioli (1/2 Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$40.00
Party Baked Mostaccioli All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$85.00
Party Dozen Meatballs All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$20.00
Party Dozen Sausage Links All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$22.00
Party Meat Lasagna All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$105.00
Party Mostaccioli All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$75.00
Party Salad All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$50.00
Party Spaghetti All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$75.00
Shrimp (12 Pieces)	$23.95
Shrimp (16 Pieces)	$25.95
Shrimp (24 Pieces)	$31.95
Spaghetti (1/2 Pan) All PARTY items include garlic bread, our homemade sauce, & Parmesan. 24 hour notice required for all party items.	$40.00
MENUFY PIZZA
*PAN STYLE CHZ 12″	$18.95
*PAN STYLE CHZ 14″	$19.95
*PAN STYLE CHZ 16″	$21.95
*THICK STYLE CHZ 12″	$17.95
*THICK STYLE CHZ 14″	$18.95
*THICK STYLE CHZ 16″	$19.95
*THICK STYLE CHZ BF	$35.95
*THIN STYLE CHZ 12″	$15.95
*THIN STYLE CHZ 14″	$16.95
*THIN STYLE CHZ 16″	$17.95
*THIN STYLE CHZ BF	$33.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Mike Lopez

Ok, so if you’re like me, and you don’t like a sweet red sauce, this is the place for you! The tomato sauce has a little peppery bite just how i love it. I asked, and their sauce is homemade family recipe. I even ordered more on the side. Bella, our server was ON POINT. What a hidden gem, and pricing was very surprising post covid. Stop by and try yourself.

… more

Autumn Kumlien

Delicious food. Very large portions. Homemade sauce was amazing! Service from all was the best. They were all very attentive.

… more

Justine Filapek

What a gem. The exterior does not hint at how absolutely lovely the interior is. Beautiful decor, wonderful music – at a perfect volume to enjoy but still converse, and I have to mention their table sizes. Not usually something I comment on, but the tables here are great. So many restaurants have teeny square tables for two that they push together for larger groups. Well these square tables are not small. No crowding, lots of room for menus, food, drinks, elbows, etc.

… more

LINDA MOERING

Baked fish was dry, tasteless…so called garlic bread to so-so…not good. Cream of Mushroom soup waaay too salty but better than mashed potatoes that came w/fish even though ordered baked potato. Would NOT recommend nor never ever return.

… more

Gabe Riel

Ordered take out, personal pizza with anchovies and mushrooms. They added onions for free which was even better- somebody else may have taken issue with that though. Great flavor (anchovies salty but not overwhelming, mushrooms were cooked before putting pie in oven which is often overlooked but important, pizza sauce flavor pretty good), the crust texture was just ok, cheese average. I’m giving three stars because the price of a personal pizza (over $15) makes me unlikely to do it again. Maybe next time I just need to order food with people who are down with fish on the pizza.

… more

WARRIOR ROAD

OMG! We travel all over the world. I had an unbelievable fish and chip in Edinburgh. I had unbelievable “chicken” dish in South Africa. I’ve had unforgettable experiences with food all over. THIS is another one!

… more

Drew Fuller

Maybe one of the best places I have ever had a meal at. Service was exceptional. Food is too good to describe. Simply great in all aspects. Definitely treat yourself to an amazing experience here!

… more

Melissa 77

We order delivery from here, and it’s fast. The food is awesome-the lemon pepper baked cod, so good. Plus alot of other dishes-too many to mention but all delicious. I put 5 stars for service, as I wanted to give them delivery credit. Enjoy!!!

… more

Thomas LinScents

I’ve been coming here for 8 years. This used to be a place I would crave. The wings used to be amazing, but this last time I went, the wings were super dry. Almost like they are leftovers. Besides the friendly servers being nice since day 1, the place seems to be going downhill..

… more

Theresa G

We ordered from Paisano’s for our 45th class reunion party and we were not disappointed. We had 3 different pizza’s, fried chicken, mostaccoli, and garlic bread. All arrived on time and hot! Thank you Fred, Fidane and your team for making our night and feeding about 50 of us great food!! We’ll definitely be back!

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Paisano’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria Menu – South Milwaukee, WI

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions