Otto’s Restaurant Menu – Elkhart Lake, WI

Type : American restaurant

Location : Elkhart Lake, WI

Otto’s Restaurant is an excellent choice for casual Elkhart Lake dining. Our family-friendly dining area features both indoor and outdoor seating with panoramic views of the courtyard and the pristine waters of Elkhart Lake. Whether you wish to start your day with an energizing meal and a cup of coffee or end your night with a glass of wine and some dessert, you can enjoy it all at Otto’s Restaurant.

Based on 190 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Otto's Restaurant 53020

Address:
101 Osthoff Ave, Elkhart Lake, WI 53020

Phone: (920) 876-5857

Website: https://osthoff.com/ottos-restaurant/

Hours

Thursday 7 AM–9 PM
Friday 7 AM–9 PM
Saturday 7 AM–9 PM
Sunday 7 AM–9 PM
Monday 7 AM–9 PM
Tuesday 7 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 7 AM–9 PM

Menu

Breakfast Menu
Fresh Fruit And Granola Parfait
Fresh berries and vanilla yogurt layered with homemade granola. Granola baked with almonds, dried cherries and maple syrup		 $8.95
Fruit Smoothie
Choice of blackberry, raspberry or blueberry blended with bananas, Greek yogurt and skim milk		 $6.95
Jumbo Muffin
Made in house with your choice of raspberry or blueberry		 $4.00
Crab Cake Benedict
Two poached farm-fresh cage-free eggs atop Maryland lump crab cakes with homemade hollandaise sauce, served with Osthoff herb-roasted potatoes		 $13.95
Baked Berry Pancake
Homemade buttermilk pancake batter topped with seasonal berries and sugar, and then baked. Served with raspberry sauce and warm Drewry Farms maple syrup and choice of applewood-smoked bacon, Johnsonville Vermont maple syrup sausage links or hardwood-smoked ham (please allow 15 minutes for preparation)		 $9.95
Banana Foster French Toast
Two slices of challah bread dipped in cinnamon-vanilla bean batter, sautéed in butter and topped with caramelized bananas with brown sugar and flambéed with Myers’s Rum, dusted with powdered sugar. Choice of applewood-smoked bacon, Johnsonville Vermont maple syrup sausage links or hardwood-smoked ham		 $9.95
Steel Cut Oatmeal With Fresh Berries
Served with Wisconsin clover honey and seasonal fresh berries		 $9.95
The Farmhouse
Farm-fresh cage-free eggs prepared to your liking, with a choice of applewood smoked bacon, Johnsonville Vermont maple syrup sausage links or hardwood-smoked ham. Served with Osthoff herb-roasted potatoes and choice of Roeck’s Bakery toast: white, wheat or pumpernickel		 $8.95
Otto’s Omelet
Farm-fresh cage-free eggs prepared with a choice of onions, scallions, bell peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms, Wisconsin cheddar, spinach or ham, served with Osthoff herb-roasted potatoes and choice of Roeck’s Bakery toast: white, wheat or pumpernickel		 $9.95
Classic Eggs Benedict
Two poached farm-fresh cage-free eggs atop toasted English muffins and applewood-smoked Canadian bacon with homemade hollandaise sauce, served with Osthoff herb-roasted potatoes		 $10.95
Buttermilk Pancakes
Three homemade buttermilk pancakes served with warm Drewry Farms maple syrup and choice of applewood-smoked bacon, Johnsonville Vermont maple syrup sausage links or hardwood-smoked ham		 $7.95
German Potato Pancake
Homemade German potato pancake with a dollop of sour cream and applesauce, and choice of applewood-smoked bacon, Johnsonville Vermont maple syrup sausage links or hardwood-smoked ham		 $8.95
Cinnamon French Toast
Two slices of challah bread dipped in cinnamon-vanilla bean batter, sautéed in butter and topped with powdered sugar and served with warm Drewry Farms maple syrup. Choice of applewood-smoked bacon, Johnsonville Vermont maple syrup sausage links or hardwood smoked ham		 $8.95
Two Farm-Fresh Cage-Free Eggs $3.50
Applewood-Smoked Bacon $3.50
Johnsonville Vermont Maple Syrup Sausage Links $3.00
Hardwood-Smoked Ham $3.00
Osthoff Skillet Potatoes $3.00
Homemade Buttermilk Pancakes (Two Cakes) $4.00
French Toast (One Slice) $3.00
Seasonal Fruit Cup $3.00
Toast (White, Wheat Or Pumpernickel) $1.50
Toasted English Muffin $2.00
Bagel With Cream Cheese $2.50
Lunch & Dinner Menu
Chicken Dumpling Soup
or Soup Of The Day		 $2.95
Lakeview Nachos
Crispy nachos are topped with queso cheese sauce with smoky chipotle peppers and fresh cilantro, roasted chicken, pico de gallo, sour cream, black olives and house pickled jalapeño peppers		 $9.95
Turtle Bay Quesadillas
Garlic-herb flour tortilla filled with Monterey Jack cheese, roasted chicken, and ale-braised onions. Served with fresh pico de gallo and sour cream		 $9.95
Spicy Buttermilk Onion Rings
Thinly sliced sweet onions soaked in buttermilk then lightly floured and flash fried. Seasoned with Vulcan’s fire salt and served with homemade ranch dressing		 $7.95
Crab Cakes
Maryland lump crab cakes pan-seared, with spicy red pepper aïoli and pickled cucumber salad		 $10.95
Crispy Calamari
Flash fried, served with spicy garlic-herb dipping sauce and lemons		 $9.95
Fried Wisconsin Cheese Curds
White cheddar cheese, battered and fried, served with homemade buttermilk ranch dressing		 $8.95
Chicken Wings
Breaded chicken wings served with celery and blue cheese dressing, and choice of sweet chipotle glaze, mild, spicy, or porter barbeque sauce		 $9.95
Otto’s Sampler Platter
Buttermilk onion rings, Wisconsin cheese curds and chicken wings with choice of sweet chipotle glaze, mild, spicy, or porter barbeque sauce; served with blue cheese dressing and celery sticks, crispy nachos topped with our queso cheese sauce and pico de gallo		 $17.95
Garden Salad
Tender greens with tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, herb croutons and choice of homemade salad dressing		 $5.95
Grilled Chicken And Parmesan Salad
Crisp hearts of romaine tossed with creamy Parmesan dressing, herb croutons, grape tomatoes and slices of herb-marinated grilled chicken breast		 $9.95
Paradise Blue Spinach Salad
Baby spinach dressed with roasted apple bourbon vinaigrette, slices of Pink Lady Apple, bourbon-soaked cherries, crumbled Paradise Blue cheese and salted pecans		 $8.95
Grilled Atlantic Salmon Salad
Tender greens dressed with citrus-thyme vinaigrette, chèvre cheese, asparagus, orange supremes and toasted almonds		 $10.95
Red Chili Glazed Shrimp Salad
Glazed & grilled shrimp with crunchy romaine salad, Mexican red chili vinaigrette, black beans, pickled red onions, tomatoes, avocado and queso fresco cheese topped with crispy corn tortilla strips		 $10.95
Grilled Chicken And Sun-Dried Cherries
Tender greens tossed with yogurt poppy seed dressing, sun-dried cherries, tart apples, spiced walnuts and herb-marinated grilled chicken breast		 $8.95
Grilled Chicken Cobb
Crispy romaine lettuce with green goddess dressing, topped with smoked bacon, avocado, tomato, hard-boiled egg, Paradise Blue cheese and herb-marinated grilled chicken breast		 $10.95
1886 Burger
Half-pound char-grilled Angus beef burger topped with Wisconsin cheddar, served on locally made hard roll		 $9.95
Paradise Blue Burger
Cajun-spiced, half-pound char-grilled Angus beef burger, topped with Paradise Blue cheese		 $9.95
Steak House Burger
Half-pound char-grilled Angus beef burger, horseradish havarti cheese and ale-braised onions		 $10.95
Otto’s Burger
Half-pound char-grilled Angus beef burger topped with smoked cheddar, homemade porter barbeque sauce and spicy fried onion rings		 $10.95
Wellington Burger
Half-pound char-grilled Angus beef burger, topped with mélange of sautéed mushrooms with shallot, fresh thyme and white wine, topped with baby Swiss cheese		 $10.95
Slow-Roasted Angus Prime Rib Sandwich
Ale-braised onions, horseradish havarti, served on house-made sesame semolina roll		 $10.95
Grilled Chicken & Spinach Sandwich
Topped with garlic sautéed baby spinach, portabella mushroom and fontina cheese, with basil pesto mayonnaise, served on toasted house-made sesame semolina roll		 $9.95
Reuben Sandwich
Thin slices of slow-cooked corned beef with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing, served on a thick-cut marble rye		 $8.95
Grilled Johnsonville Double Bratwurst
Served on a Sheboygan hard roll with sauerkraut, raw onions and whole-grain mustard		 $8.95
Bavarian Beer Braised Pork Sandwich
Braised with caramelized onions, tart apples, Düsseldorf mustard and Wisconsin’s very own Sprecher Hefe Weiss Beer, served on a toasted pretzel bun		 $8.95
Grilled Salmon Club
Fresh Atlantic salmon marinated with fresh citrus and olive oil, grilled, served on toasted ciabatta bun with applewood-smoked bacon, tender lettuce, vine-ripened tomato, avocado and cilantro-lime mayonnaise		 $10.95
Elkhart Grilled Cheese
Wisconsin-made Muenster, Gouda and white cheddar with vine-ripened tomato, avocado served on locally made country-style bread		 $8.95
Smoked Turkey & Avocado Wrap
Smoked turkey breast, aged white cheddar, tomato, pickled red onion, avocado and marinated greens wrapped in garlic-herb tortilla with roasted garlic mayonnaise		 $8.95
Garlic Crusted Walleye
Seasoned with garlic-herb panko breadcrumbs and pan-seared, served with rice pilaf, broccolini and topped with lemon-herb beurre blanc		 $21.95
Pretzel Crusted Chicken
Herb-marinated chicken breast coated in crushed salted pretzels and pan seared, served with roasted garlic mashed potatoes, broccolini and Bavarian beer cheese sauce		 $18.95
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Rubbed with our own special spice rub, slow-roasted and glazed with our homemade porter barbeque sauce. Served with creamy coleslaw and your choice of baked potato or French fries		 $17.00
Grilled Angus New York Strip
Grilled Angus New York Strip served with roasted garlic mashed potatoes, broccolini and natural jus		 $25.95
Classic
Applewood-smoked bacon and crispy onions		 $14.95
Florentine
Garlic sautéed baby spinach, grilled breast of chicken finished with fresh basil pesto		 $17.95
Scampi
Garlic sautéed shrimp with grape tomatoes and finish splash of fresh lemon and herbs		 $19.95
Children’s Menu
Breaded Shrimp
with Cocktail Sauce		 $5.95
Breaded Chicken Tenders
With ranch, BBQ or honey-mustard sauce		 $5.95
Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich $4.95
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Toasted white bread with mild Wisconsin cheddar		 $4.95
Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Smoked ham, mild Wisconsin cheese on toasted white bread		 $5.95
Turkey Wrap
Smoked turkey breast, mild Wisconsin cheddar, marinated greens wrapped in a garlic-herb flour tortilla with roasted garlic mayonnaise		 $5.95
Grilled Cheeseburger
On a Sheboygan hard roll, with mild Wisconsin cheddar		 $5.95
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
On a Sheboygan hard roll, topped with mild Wisconsin cheddar and BBQ sauce		 $6.95
Mac & Cheese
A classic dish made with white cheddar cheese		 $6.95
Junior Pancakes
Two golden buttermilk pancakes with maple syrup and your choice of bacon or sausage		 $4.95
Osthoff French Toast
Bakery fresh, thick-sliced French toast dusted with sugar and your choice of bacon or sausage		 $4.95
Farm-Fresh Breakfast
Two scrambled eggs served with one slice of white toast and your choice of bacon or sausage		 $4.95
Kid’s Cereal And Fruit
Your choice of Cheerios, Raisin Bran or Lucky Charms, with a side of fresh fruit		 $4.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Kayla Zimmer
My husband and I went to dinner on a Friday night for fish frys. The beer battered cod was good. French fries were also good. Nothing special. Coleslaw was a sweet and sour – not our style. My husband had the perch. It was fairly flavorless. His potato also seemed like it was from the day before. Service and atmosphere were great though! Food could use some work.

… more

Laura “QuebbieBird”
We were very excited for our stay at the Osthoff. Unfortunately, as beautiful as the resort it, the food at Otto’s was pretty much inedible. Service was so slow and only 3 tables filled. The gentlemen next to us told us not to get the pizza but we were really in the mood for the supposed “wood fired” pizza. The pizza was not cooked, the sauce tasted exactly like plain tomato sauce, and it had a weird flavor. We had 2 pieces of a large pizza and left the rest. Our waitress was absent most of the time. The few patrons that were there were complaining. Thought I was going to be ill after the little I had. I don’t recommend this restaurant.

… more

Marianne Janssen
Italian beef sandwich is AMAZING!!! Large portion, enough that we spirit. Bloody Mary is very good! Yummy Avocado toast for breakfast. Fast service, dine in or room service.

… more

Mary Lou Mueller
Pizza was not our style. Deep dish with lots of tomato sauce with no seasonings. Also added gratuity to the bill without stating so…not cool trying to get a double tip.

… more

Ken Pannier
We had the quesadillas and a chicken wrap. Both excellent along with great service and a beautiful view while dining on the deck.

… more

GT (Terry)
The food was great. The sliders were very filling. Service could use improvement

… more

Paige Z
Please. Listen to the bad reviews. I promise, I usually don’t and wish I had! Quite possibly the WORST service I’ve ever encountered. Our waitress never checked on us, never once. Not water or a drink or how is your food (that took an insane amount of time). The bartender- equally awful. Never. Ever. Ever. Again. Never

… more

Patrick Hartel
Located inside a the Osthauf. Nice meal with friendly waitstaff. Hannah was exceptionally attentive. Varied menu to fit most tastes.

… more

Victoria Otto
Great restaurant in the resort!! Always very accommodating our whole stay!

… more

Tod Buechel
Food was great. Always have the Eggs Benedict. Service could have been better. It felt like YeOre was serving us. Will always go back as long as the quality of food is consistent.

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. P.A.M.’s Dining Room & Cocktail Bar Menu – Elkhart Lake, WI
  2. Three Guys & A Grill Restaurant Menu – Elkhart Lake, WI
  3. Tiki Bar Menu – Elkhart Lake, WI
  4. Throwback Supper Club Menu – Elkhart Lake, WI

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch