Informal pizzeria serving New York-style pies, plus a standard roster of subs, pasta & calzones. Based on 720 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1455 FL-436, Casselberry, FL 32707
Phone: (407) 657-5384
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rick B.
We were visiting family and they suggested this place and we were pleasantly surprised by the friendly staff and the excellent food.
… more
Stefanie Cespedes
Best Chicken parm around!. I get mine with ziti. Fresh and tasty every time. Didn’t expect that from a little pizza shop in a shopping center.
… more
Maria (Lagryllaa)
I have a chicken, cacciatore dinner. It includes a side salad and garlic knots. It is so flavorful and delicious! You can really taste the garlic, which they don’t skimp on! They could’ve held a little bit back on the salt, But that’s just me. First time here but won’t be the last!!!
… more
Rafael Fernandez
Walked in for some take out and I am so glad I took a chance on them! The pizza was fresh, hot and tasted incredible. I will definitely bring them my business whenever I’m in the area and in the mood for pizza. The young Lady that took my order was a joy to interact with too!!
… more
Elizabeth Marie
Just had Uber eats, and this Pizza was not a thick Sicilian at all, the cheese was hardly melted and the crust was so hard you couldn’t even bite into it. This was the thinnest Sicilian pizza I have ever had with no taste and over cooked and dry. Very unsatisfied unfortunately
… more
Robert H.
Really enjoyed my meal at Anthony’s. My garden salad and garlic rolls were okay, but the chicken marsala I had was incredible. Easily one of the best versions of that entre I’ve ever had. Wish I had room to finish it at the restaurant, but it was still quite good reheated the next day for lunch.
… more
John Flaherty
I am chef and I’ve been here since 85 and I’m out of New Jersey. This has to be the best pizza that I have had since I’ve been home. Anthony’s pizza is phenomenal, you’re really got to try it. It’s like being back on the boardwalk in New Jersey.
… more
Juliette Maron
Save yourself a headache and tummy ache, go somewhere else!!! We ordered a pizza and it came like this, so politely I called to make them aware. Immediately the lady says no refunds. Finally, she agreed to make a cheese pizza replacement. I go to pick it up and she gives me complete hell saying she shouldn’t give me the new pizza cos the pizza shown below is cooked and nothing wrong with it. Mind you, I brought it back as is not even one bite taken because the pizza clearly is not cooked. Wait it gets better. She opened the new pizza she was going to give us since they originally messed up. She proceeds to open it and pull up the crust to prove this one is cooked. No gloves, no hand washing. This lady literally rang a lady out with cash right before she took care of me. Lady, you are working the front register, people are coming in and out, you’re handling money and touching those pens that people use to sign right before I came to the counter. I get that everyone has a bad day but if you’re the manager for 36 years at this establishment like you kept screaming at me then you should stand behind your product with customer service and never cross contaminate money handling and food handling. Service is garbage, food is without a doubt cross contaminated. I saw with my own two eyes.
… more
Anonymous Anonymous
One of the best pies around! Their sauce is delicious and their dough is crunchy and bubbly. They are generous with their cheese and you get that pull apart cheesy goodness while the dough is still crispy and hot. The staff is very friendly and willing to go out their way to make their customers feel both welcome and satisfied. We had a special request and they were game for it!!! Super cool and family oriented so bring your folks down and have a great experience!
… more
pemehl
I noticed that in the past year, this place has had a difference in ownership, and ever since the new owners, I find a massive decrease in quality. While the service is okay, and atmosphere is nothing special, I find the food now genuinely repulsive. The Pizza is far too greasy and the cheese is so low quality you can barely taste it. The pasta suffers the same problem, and the chicken in the alfredo tastes like rubber. And their desserts are overpriced for what is clearly just stuff they bought from the frozen isle at Publix. My main problem is just how clearly much the food has decreased in quality, and as a real new Yorker i find the entire place no more than a joke. Can’t stand it.
… more
… View more