Kid-friendly, casual tavern serving American bar fare & extensive burger options. Open late. Based on 354 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
44780 Middle Rd, Southold, NY 11971
Phone: (631) 765-2111
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Will Johns
It was a nice Irish spot. Nice staff and nice decor. Really good quality food.
… more
Steve Amiaga
Nice meals, hefty portions, nice service, unfortunately the inside dining capacity is limited, so calling ahead to see how many people are waiting on a weekend might be a good idea until capacity goes back to more normal. Great seafood on this visit. Shown here, Sea Bass and Flounder specials, Lobster Roll and Greek Salad…
… more
S7
A nice eatery with a variety of burgers, pasta, fish, ribs, etc. The service was good, food was fresh and the prices are average.
… more
Robin Radich Klotz
Food was burnt awful food. The waitress had to have known the food was burnt, hamburgers well done when I ordered medium rare. Guinness was awful, lines need to be cleaned and the drinks come with a LOT of ice!
… more
Jim Gabriel
One of my favorite places for food out east. Hands down the best burgers on the north fork. (And I’ll admit there are other excellent burgers in the area). Very friendly staff. Dog-friendly outdoor seating. Superb nachos and chili as well. In short, I’ve been there lots of times with lots of folks, all of whom have been happy with whatever they’ve ordered.
… more
Eric Kisel
My family and I enjoyed a Sunday lunch at O’Mallys. The steak I had was excellent along with sides of veggies. Good value for the price. Nice atmosphere and staff. We will definitely return on a future visit to the North Fork.
… more
Vincent Ventura
Great food. Hearty servings. Friendly staff. Very reasonable prices. Stumbled across this place after coming back on the 5 pm ferry from Connecticut. Very happy with finding this place. Will now be a regular destination for me on the North Fork.
… more
Sandra Saturn
I’ve been ordering here for the last few months due to convenience and food restrictions. They were good to me until my last two encounters. That is why I gave two stars- otherwise zero. I order through the app. I went a few nights ago and was noticed by the bartender and told my food will be out in a few minutes. I continue to wait and we’re talking almost thirty minutes and I had to ask what was going on as I obviously couldn’t wait any longer. The bartender tells me they never received my ticket even though she knew I was waiting and acknowledged me. I told her I paid for it and if there is a dispute they say to contact the restaurant. She took down my information and told me that Manager will contact me and of course nobody contacted me. I thought, well this was a bad experience but I tried again tonight. This time they made my food wrong. I paid for a side it didn’t come with. As well as another request for a side that didn’t come with my food. Beyond disappointed and done with this place.
… more
Karim Bandealy
Definitely one of the best burgers I’ve had. The decor was nice and calming, a very clean establishment. The wait staff was very courteous and responsive as well. The food was great, our party ordered all burgers and one plate was more than filling so I suggest you come here on an empty stomach. Overall it was a pleasant experience.
… more
Jilian Cantwell
Though apparently understaffed, the waitress seemed uninterested in providing the type of service that we enjoyed the last few times we have been there. Our food took a LONG while – we ordered some mozzarella sticks, a while after our order, and our dinners came out a while after that. Our burgers were over cooked (we had asked for a medium cook). I ordered the Apple Knocker (suppose to have sliced apple and cheddar); the ‘cheddar’ was some kind of off flavored cheesy paste, making the burger nearly inedible.
… more
… View more