Based on 397 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
311 S Kitchell Ave, Olney, IL 62450
Phone: (618) 392-3663
Website: http://oldetymesteakhaus.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J Cone
Food was exceptional! I’m a southerner, and this food was southern. Sweet tea was sweet! The service was quick and friendly. They have room for conferences. There’s a bar area.
… more
Derek Daniels
Had the 12oz Ribeye, steak fries and Mac & cheese. Food and service were really good with a nice quiet atmosphere.
… more
Robert Crouch
Nice restaurant. Relaxed atmosphere. Clean. Erin, our server, was AWESOME!
… more
Kyle Shelton
Steak haus is pricey depending on whether u catch the lunch or dinner menus, where the values of some food items vary depending on the service. However, the quality of service from the staff was was decent the food was good, and the relatively wide selection of items ensures reasons to come back depending on what ur in the mood for eating. They r definitely responsive in the positive when I asked for extra mushrooms, and received a handsome amount covering my chopped steak; their choices in beer, wine, and spirits is large and leaves room to tailor ur drink to ur meal depending on what combinations u respond to, and plenty of room to find out by experimenting n mix-for-matching items with drinks to see for urself what works for u in the future. There was no issue receiving or paying for the check, no technical issue or slow service ur waiting forever on. The pricy nature is a cause for pause, cuz my 15 dollar meal was pretty simple for all that money, yet overall I was happy to have eaten there and will consider when I have saved a bit of cash to dine there again all in due time.
… more
Meredith Ticer
My husband and I ate here for the first time to celebrate our anniversary. Our experience was a little disappointing. We placed an order for fried mushrooms appetizer with our drinks. However our appetizer, salads and entrees all came out as t the same time. My husband’s prime rib was tender and delicious. His mashed potatoes however tasted like instant potatoes. I ordered the 8oz ribeye med. rare, & I received a grey slightly grill marked cold rare steak. The macaroni & cheese that cost extra had a chalky taste to the cheese sauce. I am extremely saddened at the lack of quality we received at the price we paid.
… more
Rose Michl
Have eaten here several times. The food is usually good. This is the second time I had ordered the charbroiled prime rib. It was cooked perfectly and was very tender (both times), baked potatoe was good. Wish they served real butter instead of 48% margarine. Side salad was small, iceberg lettuce with one cherry tomato, carrot shreds and a couple of pieces of broccoli, nothing special. Service was good. Food was a little slow coming out considering they were not extra busy.
… more
JudahTM WR
The reviews are correct!!! It was one of the best prime rib dinners I have ever had. The lady helping me was very pleasant and nice to talk to while I enjoyed my meal at the bar. When the rib came out cooked a bit over, it was so good I refused to allow it to go to waste. They discounted the meal without be asked, so I gladly gave the money I planned to spend anyway to my waitress. Fantastic food and the service is top notch. Thank you so much, hope to visit again someday.
… more
Michael Aubrey
This was my very first time eating here. I traveled from an hour away to meet up with friends.
… more
Mark Lee Shelite
Had a group of 10 for supper last Saturday evening. Most people got prime rib and said it was great, I should have had prime rib also, but got a New York strip and it was pretty tough. Everything else including the service was great!
… more
Brenda Ellis
Great service!!! The steak sandwich, baked potato, and salad (for a small up-charge) were excellent! The steak was tasty and tender, and a huge piece of meat for a sandwich. Highly recommend! Oh! Make sure you also try their delicious pies.
… more
… View more