Based on 122 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
307 N First Ave, Evansville, IN 47710
Phone: (812) 401-1030
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8 AM–6 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–1 PM |
Reviews
Troy Major
Their “ribeye sandwhich” should be called steak and cheese because it is pre-made and wrapped in foil with cheese on it. My wife heavily dislikes cheese on sandwhiches so she wouldn’t eat hers. The steak itself was pretty rubbery and not very tender at all. My double cheeseburger was too greasy and it seems like they didnt season it whatsoever. The mashed potatoes and green beans were incredibly underwhelming and average at best. The only good thing i can say about this place is that it is cheap.
… more
Travis Sutton
Great food and customer service! Plate lunches are excellent. Make sure you get the early KR they may sell out!
… more
SM Clark
Hands down best burger in town…. and plate lunches are super affordable. If you dont come here for lunch at least once you are missing out.
… more
Me
Very fun experience and it really does feel old timey. I bought a seasoning (the chipotle one) and I use it on every dish possible
… more
Justin Sweeney
They have the best burgers in town. Very reasonable on their prices
… more
Melinda Knotts
Every lunch plate is better than the last. I really think it’s the best place for lunch in Evansville
… more
Joshua Fellows
Friendly staff, great plate lunches at a reasonable price ($6.99 at time of review). Shop is always clean and presentable. Great cookies, too!
… more
John Kuntz
Their cheeseburgers and tenderloins are nothing short of amazing. Super fast, super friendly, very affordable. Hands down the best place to get a quick lunch while at work.
… more
Tara Hall
The guys in the shop are always friendly and outgoing to make your visit memorable. The cookies are to die for whether it’s chocolate chip or peanut butter. They have down-to-earth prices, something different every day on the menu and delicious food to top it all off. You couldn’t ask for a better place to stop and get lunch. Can’t forget the wide variety of meats, cheese, and side dishes you can purchase by the pound at a reasonable price and be great quality. If you’ve been I promise you won’t be disappointed and will definitely be a repeat customer.
… more
Matthew Long (Ryan Bayless)
Old Tyme Deli & Meat Shop is a local gem for food. Every weekday this restaurant has an awesome lunch that is different everyday. Just to mention a few meals during the week, Saulsberry steak with mashed potatoes and green beans, spaghetti and lasagna with garlic bread, meatloaf with green beans. Beef and noodles don’t remember sides, All right let’s go to the best part every weekday they have hamburgers and you can get a single double triple if you want it but they are the best cheeseburgers hands-down in my opinion Evansville has a offer. The icing on top of the cake is the cookies Old Tyme deli & meat shop has the best cookies you’re missing out if you don’t get one. I come and get 3-4 cookies everyday. I work construction and everyone of my crews eat here every single day that’s how good it is nice home cooked meals. They also sell local chips drinks made right in Evansville. You can also buy your high quality meat products here they do not sell low quality meat. The staff is very friendly and courteous they will great you like your family every day. Supplies only last so long you better get here before they sell out which will happen every day because the locals know this gem. I would and do recommend this gem to friends and family also coworkers. Out of the 100 people I recommend this gem to not one person has been disappointed it’s that good. Remember come early before the food is sold out.
… more
… View more