Based on 332 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
691 Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Phone: (631) 473-3712
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jackie Puzio
Macaroni and cheese pizza was DELICIOUS, as well as all their other specialty pizza
… more
Brittany Manzolina
Normally this is my favorite place to order, I convinced my family to order Mother’s Day dinner from here. I ordered take out, was told it would be an hour wait for delivery so I decided to pick it up. When I go to pick it up the food isn’t all ready yet, ok fine no big deal, what I had an issue with was the manager on duty, first I was speaking to a brown haired girl she was nice but I did ask her if everything was in my order and she told me yes. When I got home I was missing 2 items. I called was told to come back and when I came back the manager on duty told me it’s because you were chirping with the girl at the register. What a rude way to talk to a guest who just spent $130 dollars on an order. I’m sorry that your employee was speaking to me about being busy and the food that I ordered. You on the other hand are an incompetent manager for being so rude to a guest who had to drive all the way back for their food since your delivery boy went home early. Please learn customer service. Thank you.
… more
Kevin Crean
I get deliveries and do taste-tests. Last night the Arthur Ave pizzette was exceptional. Today the Cipolla burger; wow! Very good selections.
… more
Dee Genaro
So I just visited this location and boy has it changed. The service has taken a nose dive and it seems like the ownership might have changed hands because the food just looks old, I visited at about 7pm on a Friday night and you would think the food would be at it’s freshest… Noooo it look like its been sitting there all day and the cheese started to take on a leathery look .to top it off the service was even worst. it seems like they hired a group of college kids that don’t care about the service industry and would rather talk about snap chat filters and what to do after work then make sure you’re being taken care of. to conclude this review, I’ll finish by saying this … Carnival pizza now has a life time customer.
… more
H Ginny
Called from Florida for a delivery
… more
Glen Amato
New in the area and took a chance on a Friday evening to order three dinners and was pleasantly surprised. The Sunday dinner which consisted of rigatoni with meatballs sausage and pork. With a little bit of Ricotta cheese. Excellent dish and great portion.
… more
Congo Bongos
Its good food if you go there but forget about ordering from here. Every time they mess it up. last time they forgot a salad and didnt put mozzarella on the mozzarella garlic bread. This time they gave us a disgusting pizza with oil all over the bottom of the box and under the pizza making the entire thing a soggy mess. The garlic knots we ordered because we didnt trust them to put mozzarella on the bread this time was cold… not room temp… COLD!!
… more
Mikey ponyboy2992
Absolutely slamming pizza , fast delivery on a Friday ,Really really good pizza nice balance of cheese sauce and crunch , pepperoni, and sausage very fresh . Definitely recommend getting pizza here !
… more
Joanne Cossentino
Sorry to say but…..my boyfriend and I stopped for a slice of pizza, I ordered a rice ball, and was extremely disappointed. First of all, we were first time customers who just happened to be in the area. so we stopped for a quick bite. The female behind the counter was extremely unfriendly. and acted like she was doing us favor. Then came the rice ball. The size of a .baseball, and was served cut in half. Where was the rice, the chopmeat and peas as presented on their menu? The contents tasted like a mush of potatoes and starch. The. dollop of marinara sauce on the side was cold. I couldn’t believe they charged 8.99 for the riceball alone, which really wasn’t edible. The slice of Sicilian and two small cokes, over $20.00. Ridiculous, how do they get away with. high prices. horrible food and a lousy location.
… more
Edward Crepeau
We were turned on to Old Town Pizza after they catered a sweet 16 we attended few years ago. The pizza and past are always top notch. Tonight we picked up food for take out and, unfortunately, we got home and there was an error. We were ready to settle for what we got, when they offered to go above and beyond to make it right. Thank you so much, you locked in a customer for life. PS. The Chipotle chicken pizza is freaking awesome!!!
… more
… View more