Based on 528 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
55 Rte 24, Chester, NJ 07930
Phone: (908) 879-9815
Website: https://www.oldmilltavernchester.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10:30 PM |
| Friday | 12–11:30 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Emi Doma
The people working here are very sweet! We came after the kitchen closed and they were close to closing overall but still allowed us to order a drink. The times of operation on Google are from pre-covid era. Their kitchen closes at about 8:45pm. The time the bar closes depends on how busy the place is but they close between 9-10pm. Very very nice place. Cannot wait to come back. They are also super dog friendly with picnic tables outside!!!
… more
bob m
First time here. I did not get that cozy welcome feeling when I first got there but I can live with that, don’t need to be pampered. After a bit it felt better. Without a doubt a locals place so I get it. Lots of great beers on tap – IPA and my red ales so I was happy. Wing sauce was great! Asked for crispy and they came out good, not overdone. Definitely a good wing. Lots of atmosphere to bring in. I know nothing about the history, etc but lots of those cop/firehouse things on the wall. Pardon my ignorance there but I think it’s extremely cool. Other orders looked good and busy for a Tuesday. I will go back because the steak looked yummy!
… more
m massey
Great local place! Absolutely loved the shrimp poppers with chipotle mayo on the Happy Hour menu. Bartender made a great classic martini. The waffle fries were unfortunately a bit over cooked.
… more
William Freeman
Food always good here.. Best burgers within at least 50 miles. The chili’s terrific and so is their sweet potato fries. The wait staff is very efficient and friendly. Always quite busy, so on busiest days at peak hours, parking may be a challenge, but normally their parking lot is adequate. Reasonable prices.
… more
Sarah P
A quaint place with very good food and great staff. It was very busy due to a birthday party but the service was still very good. The prices were decent for the amount of food we got. Definitely will be back, and recommend this place to others!
… more
Tom Frodella
I’ve been to this place twice in the past month and had great service going here. My first time here I got to meet the owner and it was a real honor to introduce myself as being part of the town. Yesterday I went in for a meal and when I entered this young girl who was the hostess didn’t even acknowledge or greet me. When I asked about seating at the bar or table she was very unprofessional about her job. There were two people that arrived after me who were greeted with open arms got better treatment than me.
… more
t abe
A friend took me here for lunch one day; I was pleasantly surprised. Great food, very affordable, nice staff. Definitely a great place to stop and grab a bite and a drink.
… more
Nikki Duvall
Food was not great. Restaurant felt old but not in a nice historic way, the vibes were not good.
… more
Patrick Ryan, DC
Debatably the best wings of my long wing eating career. Garlic Hot wings with extra blue cheese and napkins.
… more
Laura Taylor
Loved that the parking lot and entrance are wheelchair accessible, and they’d even removed a chair from the table before seating us! Little gestures like that mean a lot in a mostly inaccessible world. Solid bar food, friendly service, and fun atmosphere.
… more
… View more