Based on 32 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price
Address:
14391 Old Bandera Rd, Helotes, TX 78023
Phone: (210) 473-5832
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Irma Celeste
This was our first time trying Old Guy Pizza , absolutely delicious pizza made with love and such AMAZING service such beautiful and sweet human beings who I’m so blessed to know Coach Wilder and Sra. Wilder . We love supporting anytime we can make sure you follow them on Facebook @OldGuyPizza to try it anytime you can
… more
Colleen Miller
Lovingly made from scratch. These pizzas are delicious. Fresh ingredients made to order while you wait. If you get the opportunity these are a Must Try. You like so many will be a lifelong customer.
… more
Jamie Maurice
The pizza was flavorful and delicious. My kids wanted cheese only pizza and they were happy to accommodate them. Each of the 5 people who got pizza in our party loved it!! I can’t wait to get another pizza!
… more
Charity Matthews
Pizza is my all time favorite food and Old Guy Pizza consistently makes the BEST pizza I have had in my life…and I’ve traveled extensively to sample pizza everywhere! The homemade crust is the perfect balance of light and fluffy, the homemade sauce is seasoned perfectly, the pizza toppings are the highest quality and fresh. The pizzas are cooked in a pizza oven while you wait and are followed up with the sweetest service ever. The chef is a retired teacher married to a teacher and they make the best pizza team. (Who doesn’t love a team of teachers?) They have built up a list of raving fans and will sell out quickly so be sure to arrive early. Come and taste for yourself to see why they even made it on the local news. I try to never miss a pizza pop up event of his so if you see a red head with a big smile and a margherita pizza, say hello and thanks for the friendly referral!
… more
Yolanda Caldwell
The best pizza I’ve ever had, and that includes some renowned Brooklyn institutions! The made-from-scratch, fresh dough was crispy on the outside, tender inside, with an amazing aroma. The sauce, cheese and toppings were juicy and delicious, with just the right amount of fresh herbs!
… more
Julissa Abing
Old Guy Pizza is the absolute best! If you haven’t tried it yet, you are missing out. The dough is baked to perfection. Not only is the pizza delicious, but the owners are the sweetest people. Go check them out! You will not regret it.
… more
Angelica Irvin
You know it’s good when you get there right as he opens, and he sells out before you even get your pizza! Absolutely worth the wait. And both Casey and his wife are such nice and humble people.
… more
Jillian
Quite possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust, crispy and crusty on the outside, soft and chewy in the center. Topped with a generous amount of fresh tomatoes and basil, homemade sauce and real mozzarella cheese. Made with love and pride! 10/10 recommend!
… more
Laura C.
Just spent a week in Italy and I couldn’t stop thinking how old guys pizza was just as amazing or even BETTER than most places I ate at!! Incredible pizza spot. Highly recommend! The location is awesome because you’re right next to a great winery and brewery so you can grab a drink to accompany your pizza.
… more
Gina
Amazing dough! Fresh made to order ingredients. Done to perfection in a pizza oven on site. His pizzas are Devine, delicious and made right in front of you. Other pizza sauces are put to shame. His is always made fresh. And is never store bought.
… more
… View more