Based on 247 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
130 Old Town Rd, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 675-1313
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Grace Marie
Review update 2022 July: revisited to check out the new menu that is Oldfields Tavern. The selection is outstanding, there’s items on the menu for everyone nothing that we ordered fell short of fantastic. Burratta, spicy feta dip, birria pork tacos, fried green tomatoes, and one of my favorites the cookie butter bread pudding. Seriously amazing. Full of flavor and everything was hot, fresh and plated impeccably. Can’t wait to revisit with friends and family.
… more
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
This place was amazing. Best BBQ I’ve had but the drinks were too notch. Try the banana old fashioned. So smooth, I had two.
… more
Emma J
I’ve been to this location and the Huntington one and this location definitely takes the cake! The burnt ends with Korean BBQ sauce was the star of the show and all of our sides were delicious. The drink, which I believe was called “Over The Moon” was delicious and was a nice contrast to the food. The place looks fantastic and has a great ambiance. We’ll be back!
… more
Dave A
These pics DO NOT do the flavor justice! Was so excited to finally try and
… more
Lauren Hamilton
Me and my husband came here for the first time 8/14/22 and I wish we found this place sooner. We have been trying to find a good BBQ place and we finally did the food is amazing good real southern feel type of food. When you walk inside you truly feel like you are down south. The decor is beautiful its like an upscale rustic southern barn feel and it has a great bar with drinks that complement the food very well. As soon as we walked in we sat at the bar a felt very welcome by another customer and a great bar tender named Carl. We will definitely come back
… more
T W
Complete waste of 23 dollars. Ordered a hamburger medium, it was extremely rare, not edible. Mashed potatoes very pasty and shiny like they have been reheated many times. Mac and cheese also seems like it’s been reheated alot. Macaroni mushy and falling apart. So bad, everything went in the garbage.
… more
Cameron
Came here on the 4th of July and it was a great way to spend the night. The fried chicken sandwich was delicious and the place seemed really cool. They had a great little outdoor seating area which made it feel more like a BBQ. Definitely come if you want great BBQ food. Its worth it.
… more
Sal Verdi
I’ve had bbq all over the United States and this will beat most southern bbq.The ribs and brisket were perfect .super tender and perfect amount of smoke flavor . Kudos to let the meat shine with not adding sauce on them . True fashion . Hands down best bbq on Long Island . Can’t wait to eat here again
… more
David Tracy
Great food! Great service! Just an all around awesome place to visit for a low key delicious meal. Deanna the bartender is amazing and very attentive to her customers. I could tell she has many regulars that are repeat customers because of her service and professionalism. For a food recommendation, 100% get the Beet Salad and Fried Chicken Sandwich. The Feta Dip is also delicious. And we will never visit without getting their homemade cornbread.
… more
Gary L DiClementi
There were 4 of us for dinner. We were sat at a back corner table which was perfect for conversation. Most of us had a hamburger, it was a little over cooked for a medium rear. The restaurant was not busy at all, and it seemed like it took a little long to get our first round of drinks. The young lady that took care of our table was very friendly and had a good personality. Everyone enjoyed their meal and it was quiet enough for us to have conversations without any problems.
… more
… View more