Based on 112 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
945-5 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone: (631) 669-4400
Website: http://oakneckpizzeria.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brian Huber
Oak neck pizza is quietly a real gem of a restaurant that I feel gets passed up on for whatever reason. Food is extremely delicious and I highly highly recommend them for catering. Best penne à la vodka with chicken I’ve ever had and their Rigatoni Riorentina is a unique dish and excellent. they have an excellent lunch special and Their salads are surprisingly fantastic as well. I do think they are a little behind the times compared to some other pizzerias, but they know how to make high-quality quality food! Always verify the pricing before ordering because they do need to update their prices advertised online. I’m also really enjoying their new staff. Try them out.. especially for catering. Bibi works on Sundays and she is so pleasant to deal with.
… more
Nicole Calderone
We used them for a 30 person catered party and usually go to them on a normal basis as well! However we and all of my guest were overly impressed with how well all of our 7 trays we ordered from them for our party came out and would highly recommend them for any occasion. They even catered to a few of our vegan guest which I was grateful for. Thank you oak pizza for doing an amazing job this past weekend!!!
… more
Liz English
For +/- past 10 yrs, we’ve ordered our meatball parm heroes here, once a month or so, driving past 4 closer pizza places. (They were THAT good!) Last night we were given the wrong order but, rather than refund our money for OUR trouble when we returned uneaten eggplant parm heroes to pick up correct ones, we were given barely lukewarm sandwiches (our originals from an hour earlier??) and were “tossed us a bone” in the form of a third meatball parm. To freeze?? Have you ever “enjoyed” (oxymoron!!) a defrosted meatball parm hero?? Would have been so easy for management to apologize, give us 2 correct sandwiches, hot, and refund the cost for OUR trouble. Alas, we are old and remember doing business in a different era. Bye bye Oak Neck Pizza…
… more
Christine Givens
LOVE their pizza. Friendly and fast service.
… more
Allison Castagna
Delicious Chicken Ceasars pizza.. very friendly staff
… more
Robert Voce
Decent food . Not fancy food. Pizza is.made fresh daily. Very young staff without masks. The heros are not made with fresh chicken and small portions. All fried not a breaded chicken cutlet. Other pizzerias have fresher food.
… more
Kristin Foerst
As a New Yorker I love pizza but I REFUSE to go back to this place. The employees are VERY rude and make it very clear they don’t care about their customers. I work with special needs kids and when my kid went to pay the cashier was very rude and made my special little angel feel very embarrassed and disheartened by putting him on the spot and giving a nasty attitude. My coworkers that have also brought their angels to the pizza place experienced the same treatment. We refuse to go to an establishment that doesn’t have good customer service, is extremely insentivie to children with special needs AND the pizza ISNT EVEN GOOD.
… more
Nicole Calderone
We eat here very frequently and they never disappoint us! We have also ordered catering through them and our whole party was extremely happy with all the dishes we ordered
… more
Jules R
I love this place! I’ve been going here for years and just stumbled onto it on my way to the dog park. I get their specialty slices and their Grandma slice is prob my favorite. I have them deliver now too when I don’t feel like going out. My cousin used them for catering her son’s bday party and everyone loved the food too. Chicken Verde, Eggplant Parm & Rigatoni Alla Vodka were awesome!!
… more
Chris Buetti
Absolutely love this place. Best pizzeria on Long Island in my opinion. Great food and amazing service! The owner Bahji is always there and she is so nice, sometimes I go back just because of her. Overall definitely five out of five stars.
… more
… View more