Casual local chain with East Coast-style, thin-crust pizzas, calzones & local brews on tap. Based on 578 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2743 S Market St #101, Gilbert, AZ 85295
Phone: (480) 782-6973
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
AP Wilcox
NYPD Pizza is a good choice for NY style thin crust pizza in Gilbert. We especially like the white pie, Pizza Blanca, with olive oil, crushed garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella. They also give you a choice of one extra topping to put on that pie. They recommend fresh spinach or Roma tomatoes, but we go the extra mile and add an extra topping, and do the spinach and bacon. Delicious!My wife and daughters love the Soho pizza salad. It’s a pizza with salad on top. They call the crust a pizza crisp and it’s baked with garlic, spices and mozzarella. Then they put a salad on top of it with greens, bruschetta, almonds, feta, asiago cheese and their special house and ranch dressing mix. We also like their lunch combos that we feel are fairly priced with choices like pizza slices, salad, and wings.
… more
Chad Hutchins
Great pizza, large menu, and very nice inside. We had the BBQ Chicken and the Buffalo Chicken (guess we both were in a chicken mood)… both were excellent, fresh ingredients, great crust. We’ll definitely order again. Oh and the garlic knots are legit!!
Megan Callahan
I’m from New Jersey so to me, pizza is almost as important as air I have been here probably 10 times already and it’s been amazing each time. I haven’t had anything that I haven’t liked and the staff is always welcoming and friendly. We know some by name like the waitress Brooklyn who’s always has a smile on her face or ryan who I think is the manager, goes above and beyond to make everyone feel welcome. The pizza is amazing.. don’t believe me? Try it for yourself.
Kim Gentes
NYPD is an excellent small chain. Top notch pizza sauce flavor, excellent crust and lots of cheesy goodness. Their sausage topping is one of the best available anywhere. Their cheese knots are also very good. The pricing is higher than many NY styled pizzeria joints, but the consistency of flavor and excellent results each time keep me coming back.
Witching Hour 1692
They don’t do medium pizza’s anymore so kinda forced into getting the large. The pizza dough was raw. Not cooked at all. The waitress was way too sweet to say anything to her it’s not her fault the company changes policy on sizes but yet still has it on the menu. Then who ever quality checked that pizza should have noticed it was raw. Poor management nice people. Won’t be back. This used to be one of my favorite places. One bite (2.3) that’s a score.
Sam Hittson
They lost a star because the pizza slice was underwhelming. Spinach, onion, and jalapeno. The crust was very good, but the toppings need more time to crisp up.
MattMegan Rodriguez
We’ve been here one time before we moved to San Tan. we used to live close by and didn’t notice this gem until right before we moved. Now, every time we are around or are feeling like a 5 star piece of pizza, we come to NYPD. Every time we come here, we are treated like family. My wife is from jersey, so we are always on the hunt for good new york/jersey style pizza, and we definitely found it.
Jeanette Johnston
If I could give zero stars I would. Earlier this year the Market street location in Gilbert failed to deliver our order as the person who took the order marked it as pick up. When I asked to speak to the manager, Noah the manager got on the phone and suggested I come and pick up my now cold pizza. I told him I ordered delivery for a reason and he said he would remake the pizza, I could wait for an additional hour for it to arrive and would still be charged the delivery fee.
Travis
Not bad. However, I was expecting flimsy crust, the sauce, cheese, and toppings, and even the crust was really good. I’m not complaining at all. But if there was a way I could order a good flimsy, greasy peice of pepperoni pizza….I would order that. The pizza had a perfectly crusted bottom, again, not complaining, but I like the big greasy slice… I don’t often eat pizza, but when I do, I want it count. I have other pizza reviews FROM NY on my profile that can show you what I mean.
Dennis Keegan
Have been going here for a few years and food was always excellent as well as the service. We were there on 8/22 and ordered 2 personal pizzas. It took longer than usual for our order and when it arrived one of the pizzas was dry and overdone and the other one was done ok but tasteless. Very disappointed, hesitate to go back again.
… View more