NYPD Pizza Menu – Winter Garden, FL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Winter Garden, FL

Casual local chain with East Coast-style, thin-crust pizzas, calzones & local brews on tap. Based on 603 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery

NYPD Pizza 34787

Address:
16118 Marsh Rd, Winter Garden, FL 34787

Phone: (407) 877-4743

Website:

Hours

Saturday 12–9 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

FOOD
GARLIC KNOTS
Freshly baked knots with garlic, butter and herbs
$3.75
CHEESY GARLIC BREAD $7.69
MOM’S MEATBALLS
Two meatballs made with Mom’s special ingredients.
$5.99
POP’S ITALIAN SAUSAGE $6.99
NYPD FRIES $4.99
JONES BEACH FRIES
A basket of fries without the beach, just the salt!
$4.99
CONEY ISLAND FRIES
A basket of fries covered in bacon, cheese & jalapenos.
$8.99
Pepperoni Pin Wheel $5.00
RICE BALL
A traditional rice ball with mozzarella and marinara sauce.
$7.99
FRIED RAVIOLI
Raviolis lightly fried and served with our homemade marinara sauce.
$7.99
MOZZARELLA STICKS
Served with a side of our homemade marinara sauce.
$8.99
MOZZARELLA CAPRESE
Made with fresh tomatoes, garlic, basil and extra virgin olive oil.
$9.99
CHICKEN TENDERS
Battered in NYPD Pizzeria seasoning served with a side of honey mustard, BBQ sauce or Buffalo Style.
$9.99
10 CHICKEN WINGS
With your choice of wing sauce.
$14.99
20 CHICKEN WINGS
With your choice of wing sauce.
$28.99
SOUP Cup
The way Grandma used to make! Ask for selection.
$5.99
Soup By The Bow $6.99
The Siren,S $14.99
Chicken Tenders $9.99
PAULIE.S Home Made Baked Clams $13.99
CHEESE SLICE
Shredded mozzarella cheese, Italian herbs, spices and homemade tomato sauce.
$2.25
DELUXE SLICE
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers & mozzarella.
$5.95
MEATLOVER SLICE
Pepperoni, meatballs, smoked bacon & mozzarella.
$5.75
VEGGIE SLICE
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$5.75
Cheese Slice Monday Only $1.99
10″ CHEESE PIE
Shredded mozzarella cheese, Italian herbs, spices and homemade tomato sauce.
$7.99
10″ BAYSIDE BIANCA
Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, Italian spices. Add Spinach or Broccoli for an additional charge.
$10.99
10″ MARGHERITA PIE
The original pizza. Mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil, garlic & olive oil.
$8.99
10″ MARIANO PIE
Olive oil, diced tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil & mozzarella.
$9.99
10″ APB ALFREDO PIE
Creamy Alfredo sauce, Italian herbs, garlic & mozzarella.
$9.99
10″ MADISON SQUARE GARDEN PIE
A cheeseless pizza with tomato sauce, fresh spinach, mushrooms, artichoke, tomatoes, garlic & olive oil. (Add cheese for an additional charge)
$9.99
10″ HAWAIIAN PIE
Ham and pineapple on our traditional pizza pie.
$9.99
10″ VEGGIE PIE
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$10.99
10″ PESTO BIANCA PIE
Pesto sauce, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, garlic & Italian spices.
$10.99
10″ POP’S PESTO PIE
Pop’s own pesto sauce, tomato slices & mozzarella.
$10.99
10″ TRIBECA PIE
A base of mozzarella cheese with a balanced blend of imported Parmesan & Romano cheese topped with diced tomato & fresh spinach.
$9.99
10″ CHICKEN CLUB PIE
Smoked bacon, diced tomatoes, mozzarella, braised chicken, topped with ranch dressing.
$11.99
10″ MEAT LOVERS PIE
Pepperoni, meatballs, smoked bacon & mozzarella
$11.99
10″ DELUXE PIE
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers & mozzarella.
$11.99
10″ KEW GARDENS PIE
Fresh spinach, broccoli, minced garlic, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$11.99
10″ BLEU CHEESE & BUFFALO CHICKEN PIE
Braised chicken with a layer of wing sauce, mozzarella, with a swirl of bleu cheese dressing.
$11.99
10″ BBQ CHICKEN PIE
BBQ and pizza sauce topped with chicken, red onions & mozzarella.
$11.99
10″ 5 BOROUGHS PIE
Just like the 5 Boroughs, there’s a little bit of everything.
$11.99
10″ SALSICCIA PIE
Fresh mozzarella, Italian fennel sausage, caramelized onions, roasted garlic cloves, grated Parmesan, accented with crushed red pepper.
$11.99
10″ 1/2 MEATLOVER PIE $7.99
10″ 1/2 DELUXE PIE $7.99
10″ 1/2 VEGGIE PIE $7.99
14″ CHEESE PIE
Shredded mozzarella cheese, Italian herbs, spices and homemade tomato sauce.
$13.99
14″ BAYSIDE BIANCA
Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, Italian spices. Add Spinach or Broccoli for an additional charge.
$16.99
14″ MARGHERITA PIE
The original pizza. Mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil, garlic & olive oil.
$16.99
14″ MARIANO PIE
Olive oil, diced tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil & mozzarella.
$16.99
14″ APB ALFREDO PIE
Creamy Alfredo sauce, Italian herbs, garlic & mozzarella.
$16.99
14″ MADISON SQUARE GARDEN PIE
A cheeseless pizza with tomato sauce, fresh spinach, mushrooms, artichoke, tomatoes, garlic & olive oil. (Add cheese for an additional charge)
$16.99
14″ HAWAIIAN PIE
Ham and pineapple on our traditional pizza pie.
$16.99
14″ VEGGIE PIE
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$17.99
14″ PESTO BIANCA PIE
Pesto sauce, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, garlic & Italian spices.
$17.99
14″ POP’S PESTO PIE
Pop’s own pesto sauce, tomato slices & mozzarella.
$18.99
14″ TRIBECA PIE
A base of mozzarella cheese with a balanced blend of imported Parmesan & Romano cheese topped with diced tomato & fresh spinach.
$16.99
14″ CHICKEN CLUB PIE
Smoked bacon, diced tomatoes, mozzarella, braised chicken, topped with ranch dressing.
$18.99
14″ MEAT LOVERS PIE
Pepperoni, meatballs, smoked bacon & mozzarella
$19.99
14″ DELUXE PIE
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers & mozzarella.
$19.99
14″ KEW GARDENS PIE
Fresh spinach, broccoli, minced garlic, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$19.99
14″ BLEU CHEESE & BUFFALO CHICKEN PIE
Braised chicken with a layer of wing sauce, mozzarella, with a swirl of bleu cheese dressing.
$19.99
14″ BBQ CHICKEN PIE
BBQ and pizza sauce topped with chicken, red onions & mozzarella.
$19.99
14″ 5 BOROUGHS PIE
Just like the 5 Boroughs, there’s a little bit of everything.
$21.99
14″ SALSICCIA PIE
Fresh mozzarella, Italian fennel sausage, caramelized onions, roasted garlic cloves, grated Parmesan, accented with crushed red pepper.
$19.99
14″ STUFFED PIE
A double layer of dough stuffed with any two toppings, mozzarella and a side of sauce.
$18.99
14″ 1/2 MEATLOVER PIE $13.50
14″ 1/2 DELUXE PIE $13.50
14″ 1/2 VEGGIE PIE $13.50
Gigi’s 18inch Pepperoni- Pepperoni Under Cheeze $18.99
18″ CHEESE PIE
Shredded mozzarella cheese, Italian herbs, spices and homemade tomato sauce.
$15.99
18″ BAYSIDE BIANCA PIE
Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, Italian spices. Add Spinach or Broccoli for an additional charge.
$19.99
18″ THE SICILIAN
A thick seasoned crust, topped with sauce, mozzarella, Italian herbs & spices.
$20.99
18″ MARGHERITA PIE
The original pizza. Mozzarella, tomato sauce, fresh basil, garlic & olive oil.
$18.99
18″ MARIANO PIE
Olive oil, diced tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil & mozzarella.
$18.99
18″ APB ALFREDO PIE
Creamy Alfredo sauce, Italian herbs, garlic & mozzarella.
$19.99
18″ MADISON SQUARE GARDEN PIE
A cheeseless pizza with tomato sauce, fresh spinach, mushrooms, artichoke, tomatoes, garlic & olive oil. (Add cheese for an additional charge)
$19.99
18″ HAWAIIAN PIE
Ham and pineapple on our traditional pizza pie.
$20.99
18″ VEGGIE PIE
Onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$21.99
18″ PESTO BIANCA PIE
Pesto sauce, ricotta cheese, mozzarella, garlic & Italian spices.
$21.99
18″ POP’S PESTO PIE
Pop’s own pesto sauce, tomato slices & mozzarella.
$23.99
18″ TRIBECA PIE
A base of mozzarella cheese with a balanced blend of imported Parmesan & Romano cheese topped with diced tomato & fresh spinach.
$19.99
18″ CHICKEN CLUB PIE
Smoked bacon, diced tomatoes, mozzarella, braised chicken, topped with ranch dressing.
$23.99
18″ MEAT LOVERS PIE
Pepperoni, meatballs, smoked bacon & mozzarella
$24.99
18″ DELUXE PIE
Sausage, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, green peppers & mozzarella.
$24.99
18″ KEW GARDENS PIE
Fresh spinach, broccoli, minced garlic, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes & mozzarella.
$24.99
18″ BLEU CHEESE & BUFFALO CHICKEN PIE
Braised chicken with a layer of wing sauce, mozzarella, with a swirl of bleu cheese dressing.
$23.99
18″ BBQ CHICKEN PIE
BBQ and pizza sauce topped with chicken, red onions & mozzarella.
$23.99
18″ 5 BOROUGHS PIE
Just like the 5 Boroughs, there’s a little bit of everything.
$26.99
18″ SALSICCIA PIE
Fresh mozzarella, Italian fennel sausage, caramelized onions, roasted garlic cloves, grated Parmesan, accented with crushed red pepper.
$24.99
18″ STUFFED PIE
A double layer of dough stuffed with any two toppings, mozzarella and a side of sauce.
$27.99
18″ 1/2 MEATLOVER PIE $16.49
18″ 1/2 DELUXE PIE $16.49
18″ 1/2 VEGGIE PIE $16.49
PATROLMAN’S PEPPERONI ROLL
Triple pepperoni with double mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
VICE SQUAD VEGGIE ROLL
Spinach, tomato, mushroom and mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
SERGEANT’S SAUSAGE ROLL
Italian sausage, onions, green peppers and mozzarella cheese.
$11.99
BROOKLYN BUFFALO ROLL
Mozzarella cheese and chicken with your choice of mild, medium or hot sauce.
$11.99
VICE SQUAD VEGGIE CALZONE
Spinach, tomato, mushroom and mozzarella cheese.
$9.99
SERGEANT’S SAUSAGE CALZONE
Italian sausage, onions, green peppers and mozzarella cheese.
$9.99
CONVICT CHEESE CALZONE
Mozzarella and herb & ricotta cheese mix. Add any topping for an additional charge.
$10.99
SWAT TEAM STROMBOLI
Ham, salami, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese.
$11.99
MAKE YOUR OWN ROLL
Start with a cheese specialty roll and add toppings for an additional charge.
$9.99
MEATBALL PARMIGIANA HERO $10.99
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA HERO $10.99
ITALIAN HERO $10.99
SAUSAGE & PEPPERS HERO $10.99
PENN STATION CHEESE STEAK $10.99
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA HERO $10.99
VEAL PARMIGIANA HERO $10.99
SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA HERO $10.99
CHICKEN CUTLET HERO $10.99
St Patty Day Special $12.99
PASTA MARINARA
Homemade marinara sauce, with your choice of pasta.
$10.99
PASTA MEATBALLS
Homemade marinara sauce and meatballs with your choice of pasta.
$12.99
FETTUCCINE ALFREDO
Made with heavy cream and a blend of Italian cheeses.
$14.99
FETTUCCINE ALFREDO W/ CHICKEN
Made with heavy cream and a blend of Italian cheeses topped with Chicken.
$16.99
PASTA AGLIO `E OLIA
Sauteed fresh garlic, olive oil & Italian seasonings.
$10.99
PASTA AGLIO W/ CHICKEN
Sauteed fresh garlic, olive oil & Italian seasonings topped with Chicken.
$13.99
CHEESE RAVIOLI
Filled with seasoned ricotta & topped with marinara.
$12.99
BAKED ZITI
Ricotta & mozzarella cheeses, baked to perfection.
$14.99
PASTA BOLOGNESE
Our homemade meat sauce with your choice of pasta.
$14.99
HOMEMADE LASAGNA
Layers of pasta, seasoned beef, marinara, ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
$16.99
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA
Imported Romano cheese, melted mozzarella, marinara, served with your choice of pasta.
$15.99
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA
Imported Romano cheese, melted mozzarella, marinara, served with you choice of pasta.
$16.99
STUFFED SHELLS
Pasta filled with a blend of ricotta, grate3d cheese, eggs and herbs. Covered in our homemade marinara.
$11.99
PENNE ALLA VODKA
Penne pasta in a creamy vodka sauce.
$14.99
Special Dinner $14.99
Special Dinner $15.99
HOUSE SALAD $5.00
CAESAR SALAD $5.00
CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD $13.50
SPINACH SALAD $6.99
ASTORIA GREEK SALAD
Our Greek salad served with traditional kalamata olives, pepperoncinis, onion, tomato, roasted red peppers and feta cheese with Mediterranean dressing.
$6.00
TRI-STATE CHICKEN SALAD
Romaine & iceberg lettuce, mixed with diced tomatoes and celery. Topped with bleu cheese crumbles & crispy or grilled chicken, tossed in your choice of wing sauce.
$13.99
SOHO COBB SALAD
Iceberg lettuce, chicken, smoked bacon, hard boiled egg, tomato, red onions and crumbled bleu cheese.
$13.99
CENTRAL PARK CHEF SALAD
Salad with chicken, ham & American cheese strips, hard boiled egg, tomato and cucumber.
$13.99
LITTLE ITALY ANTIPASTA SALAD
Salami, ham, pepperoni and provolone cheese rolled together and sliced, on iceberg lettuce, with tomato, black & green olives, red onions and pepperoncinis.
$6.99
CAPTAIN’S VELVEETA MAC & CHEESE $6.99
CHIEF’S CHICKEN POPPERS $7.99
JR APB ALFREDO $8.99
MISDERMEANOR SPAGHETTI WITH MEAT SAUCE $7.99
CADETTE CHEESE STICKS $7.99
SIDE DINNER ROLLS $0.00
SIDE SAUCE $1.25
SIDE ALFREDO $3.50
SIDE ANCHOVIES $4.25
SIDE BOLOGNESE $4.75
SIDE BROCCOLI $5.00
SIDE DRESSING $0.55
SIDE JALAPENO $2.50
SIDE MEATBALL $2.55
SIDE PESTO $4.25
SIDE PIZZA SAUCE $1.25
SIDE RANCH / BLEU CHEESE $2.00
SIDE WING SAUCE $2.25
SIDE MOZZARELLA $3.75
SIDE BANANA PEPPERS $2.50
Slde Black Olives $2.50
Side Garlic Butter 2OZ $0.25
Side Garlic Butter 4OZ $0.50
NEW YORK CANNOLI
A large crispy pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cream and dusted with powdered sugar.
$5.99
JUNIOR’S CHEESECAKE
Known as “The Worlds Most Fabulous Cheesecake,” Junior’s Cheesecakes have been rated “Best Overall” by the Wall Street Journal. Served with fresh strawberries upon request!
$6.99
Juniors CHOCOLATE LAYER CAKE
Layers of moist chocolate cake with rich chocolate filling.
$6.99
ZEPPOLES
Just like on the streets of Little Italy! Our special dough fried, covered in your choice of powdered sugar or cinnamon sugar and served in a paper bag.
$3.99
BROOKLYN STUFFED ZEPPOLES
Just like Brooklyn! Our special dough, fried, stuffed with sweet ricotta cream filling and lightly topped with powdered sugar.
$5.99
OREO ZEPPOLES
Our special dough, fried, stuffed with an OREO.
$5.99
Luigi”S Real Italian Ice
Your choice of cherry, lemon or mango.
$0.00
Holiday Cheesecake $6.99
10″CHEESE PIE $5.99
14″CHEESE PIE $11.99
18″CHEESE PIE $13.99
TWO 14″CHEESE PIE & WINGS $37.99
14″CHEESE PIE,8 KNOTS & LARGE GATDEN SALAD $27.99
JACKIE;S FAVORITE PASTA $16.99
PENNE BROCCOLI $15.99
PASTA ARRABBITA $14.99
CILLA,S PESTO RAVIOLI $15.99
JERRY,S SAUSAGE & PEPPERS $15.99
N/A BEVERAGES
Mnt Dew $2.99
Pepsi $2.99
DIET Pepsi $2.99
SPRITE $2.99
WATER $2.29
Orange Soda $2.99
REIGN FUEL $2.99
Pepsi $3.89
Diet Pepsi $3.89
Mnt Dew $3.89
Mist $3.89
LEMONADE $3.89
ROOT BEER $3.89
Apple Juice 12.0z $2.29
Pepsi $2.99
Diet Pepsi $2.99
Starry $2.99
Lemonade $2.99
Mtn Dew $2.99
Ginger Ale $2.99
Minute Maid $2.99
Dr Pepper $2.99
Pepsi Zero $2.99
Tea $2.99
9.99 jail bird specials
MONDAY SPEG CARBONARA $9.99
TUESDAY CHICKEN PARM $9.99
WEDNESDAY EGGPLANT ROLATINI $9.99
THURSDAY TOMOATO FETA PASTA SALAD $9.99
FRIDAY BAKED RAV $9.99
SATURDAY CHICKEN MARSALA $9.99
SUNDAY SPEG ALA PUTTANESCA $9.99
CINCO DE MAYO SPECIAL
TWO TACO SLICE & HIGH NOON $7.99
TWO TACO SLICE AND CORONA $7.99
14 Inch Mexican Pizza $20.99

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Bryan Countryman
Good food! Okay service.

… more

Amanda Severance
We rented the backroom to host a small birthday party for my husband and it was a great experience. Mindy took great care of us! The food came out at appropriate times, there was always plenty of drinks and the whole thing went very smoothly. Would recommend for a small get together!

… more

Jim T
Great pizza and people. Had a double pepperoni. Yummo….

… more

Erin Creel
Dined here around 8:00pm with Mindy as our server. She was phenomenal, taking care of the entire room all by herself (about 6/7 tables). She was so nice and very attentive. The pizza was great! We’ll definitely be back!

… more

Tahny D
Delicious and fresh New York style pizza. We absolutely love the garlic knots! The food is always great, the staff however seems to change a lot. We e had great servers and not so great servers. We love the Tuesday night special of buy one pizza get one free! They have great deserts too.

… more

Brian
From the moment I walked in, Mindy greeted me with a warm smile and made me feel right at home. She was incredibly attentive throughout the entire meal, making sure my drinks were always full and checking in on me to see if I needed anything else.

… more

Danny
The restaurant is pretty good. The best vegan option is a build your own pizza with an assortment of veggies. I was happy to see that they didn’t skimp out on any veggies so it really made up for the lack of vegan cheeses. The sauce was just okay but the crust was pretty good.

… more

Gagan W
Mixed experience, not what we expected.

… more

Dan F
Ordered pizza online. Went to go pick it up and the lady said she couldn’t find it. She was very unhelpful and pushed us aside to help people behind us. 30 minutes later she found the order. It was cold. Won’t order again if this is the quality of service.

… more

Zachary Zavada
The pizza is ok… but they don’t open at the time they have posted.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions