Based on 141 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5 Bethpage Rd B, Hicksville, NY 11801
Phone: (516) 261-9349
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–3:15 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–3:15 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–3:15 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–3:15 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–3:15 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–3:15 PM, 5–9:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ravinder Kaur
I know this place more than 2 years now n every single time the cake i order they make it exactly the same. Not only the cake looks beautiful but the taste OMG. The cakes taste delicious as well. Going to share some of the amazing cakes on my daughters birthdays which I ordered in past 2+ years
… more
Arya Phatak
It was our first time here. We tried the chicken and egg puff, was pretty good. Next we tried chicken biryani, aloo tikki chaat, chicken 65 and chicken vindaloo. Biryani was delicious- Must try! Chicken 65 was flavorful and crispy, more like chicken pakoda. Chicken vindaloo had chicken with bone and was slightly on the sweeter side but was good. Aloo tikki chaat was okay, little dry and potato cutlet would do with more flavors. To finish, we got pineapple pastry and choco mocha pastry. The pineapple pastry was definitely not fresh and felt extremely dry. The whipped cream on top was not smooth. Choco mocha was comparatively better but still could improve.
… more
Kundan Sen
Discovered this new hole-in-the-wall place through Uber Eats, then optimized into calling in ourselves. Tiny place at the corner of Bethpage Rd right next to a laundromat. Chicken 65 is delicious. Biryani is light and fluffy yet spicy and flavorful. Kerala Parotta is basically what we know as lachchha paratha. Prepared hot and fresh, cooked with care.
… more
Elizabeth Labarbera
The custom made eggless cakes are the best cakes I’ve had in a long time! My son has an egg allergy, and I am so glad my friend who also had an excellent experience with them shared their location. I want to also add the professional customer service provided as they cared enough to make sure they were understanding of every detail. I provided the flowers but they can also work with you if you prefer full service. Many of our guest were blown away from the vanilla and butter scotch flavors. I really love their cakes will definitely use them again!
… more
Navin Mathew
We ordered a chicken fried rice and the portion was enough for two people. Their snacks and desserts are great as well especially the egg puffs. Definitely recommend this place.
… more
Christine C
We called in one night around 8:30 pm (they close at 9pm) and asked if they accept local deliveries over the phone. They checked with some one and started taking my order. I think it’s not something they do but something they were kind enough to fulfill when asked.
… more
Christina MG
I came across this bakery during an online search for a nearby bakery. I read the positive reviews this business had and figured I would try it. I was looking for two identical cakes for an event we were celebrating. My experience with NY Cakes n Bites was so wonderful. They were kind, helpful, and very responsive. I needed the cake for a specific date and they were extremely accommodating. I sent over references for both color scheme and shape of the cake. I described what I was looking for and they absolutely delivered on the final product!! I was floored by how beautiful these cakes looked. And to my delight – The cake itself was light and delicious. I will definitely be coming back and letting others know about this bakery. I highly recommend coming here for the cakes. I will be back soon! I can’t wait to try their bites as I am sure they are as equally delicious. Thank you NY Cakes N Bites for helping to make our occasion extra special!
… more
MimA
Best cake place if you want eggless cakes…
… more
Shruti Mehta
Such a lovely cake made by the baker. The whole experience from ordering to the delivery was amazing. The baker’s work is so neat. The sponge of the cake is very light. All the guests at our party loved the cake. We thought we would have so much left over because it was a small party, but the cake was finished in no time! Definitely recommend getting the cake from here.
… more
purushotham rogennagari
Awesome place Amazing Cake Shop – we ordered recently for my daughter’s birthday party a themed cake for her 5th Birthday here and designs are exceptional & Yummy taste. Staff very co-operative and always met expectations. He made exactly what we wanted – with in our budget.
… more
… View more