Based on 122 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4503a Monona Dr, Monona, WI 53716
Phone: (608) 467-7792
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ryan McDermott
I have been driving by this place for sometime and yearning for a meatball sub, so I finally got one. Nothing super fancy, but solid tasty food. Big meatballs, good cheese, plenty of tasty sauce, all on a nice Italian bun. This place appears to be popular with the local high school kids for lunch. Would recommend; will go back.
… more
Marshae Sanders
I’m from the south and I had a taste for some pizza! I usually go for pan pizza but a regular crust is okay as well! I try their house combo minus the anchovies. It was good and hot! The cheese was super stringy and gooey! Taste was missing something but the hotness and how fresh everything else was is why it got a 4/5 rate. I will also add they should greet there customer as soon as they walk in! I had to say something first once I got to the counter it was a bit awkward. I forgot to take a picture before I started eating but you get the point!
… more
Colleen Frey
Placed an order for pick up that took 20 minutes longer than estimated time. Kids cheeseburger was disgusting- I don’t know if the bread was old or what but there was a very offputting flavor. Kids chicken nuggets were cheap frozen nuggets. The spinach on our pizza was clearly frozen spinach and just tasted bad. The garlic that was supposed to be on it was practically nonexistent. And we ordered 12 wings, of which we were only able to eat about half because they were so over cooked. Pizza crust was good but everything else was absolutely terrible.
… more
Dave Bendit
My partner and I have been here twice now, and both times it’s been excellent. Eventually we’ll try something new, but on our most recent visit, we got the same things as we did our first time: the supreme roast beef sandwich three way for me, and the turkey sub for my partner.
… more
Debbie Rode
My daughter and i had lunch here yesterday. We are from the east coast and everything we had tasted so good! Tastes Like “home”!! Everyone here should try it. My sub was “fantastic”. Fresh meats and veggies on there and the rolls are perfect for this. We never go without having the pizza. Thee best! Such a nice, fresh lite sauce. Love the crust! We also had their wings. You’ve got to try them! We left stuffed and very satisfied. A party of about 12 came in as we were leaving. The owner greeted them like family! A must try place folks!! Best sub i have had out here!! I couldn’t wait to try it before i took a picture of it!
… more
Nina Gehan
This PIZZA! We’ve been ordering delivery since they opened and it has as only gotten better every single time….It is absolutely excellent. This completely replaced our weekly delivery order rotation from Glass Nickel, Sal’s, Ian’s (sorry guys!)…. because it’s just better. Also a fair price which we appreciate as a family! Amazing toppings and signature pizza choices that aren’t too out there but still creative and fun…. A nice super crispy crunchy crust….. Perfectly balanced tomato sauce…. It’s pizza the way we imagine it when we are dreaming of it 🙂 Keep rockin that pizza North Shore Pizza Subs – you’re giving all your competition a run for their money with your pies!
… more
Erin Murphy
Not a super inviting environment and the menu could add a little more description of what’s on the subs. The sign had me thinking this was a skater vibe and it would be really chill with lots of bright, fun art murals inside. Chill was right, but very gray and cold. Pretty pleased with the amount of food I got for $8, though! Not sure how they’re pulling it off, but if you’re hungry, bring a $10 bill down here and get a small Italian sub. Can’t imagine what the large is like! I’ll for sure come back and maybe offer to paint some graffiti murals inside to bump up the vibe a notch!
… more
Lyle Hilfiker
Stopped in for the first time and was pleasantly surprised! Great pizza and service. Old school arcade games for the kids. Would highly recommend North Shore.
… more
David Pellas
Best pizza in Madison and reasonably priced. Consistently, good. Slightly tangy sauce, excellent cheese, and great crispy crust. Wish they were on the west side, but still worth the drive.
… more
Ben Hulbert
Now, I was a big fan of Rossi’s, so suffice it to say I was disappointed to lose such a legendary spot. Nonetheless, North Shore Pizza and Subs, while NOT Rossi’s, is doing it’s own thing and doing it right.
… more
… View more