Based on 347 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
456 Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642
Phone: (201) 497-6900
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9:40 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9:40 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9:40 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9:40 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9:40 PM |
| Sunday | 11:45 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Julia C
I finally got to try this place and was not disappointed! My order was ready for pickup very quickly and everything I got was very tasty for the most part (the garlic bread was kind of disappointing).
… more
Emanuele Mannino
This place has it all Consistency, Service, and Quality. My family has been coming here for 5years now and it’s our go to place. They even have the best gluten free pizza!!! Nino and his staff make you feel like family every time you step foot in the door until you leave. We will continue to support this family owned buisness. Keep up the good work. Ps my favorite pie is the superRoni!!!
… more
Bri C
Was passing through the area on my way back to NY with a craving for pizza and found Nino’s. Truly solid pizza. I had the Grandma, Grandpa and pepperoni slices, all were very good, the Grandma slice being my favorite. The only critique I had would be I wish the sauce was just a touch more flavorful. Other than that, no complaints!
… more
Lodi New Jersey
I placed an order for delivery using the Slice app (it was recommended on Nino’s line because they were so busy). After 40 minutes of placing the order I checked the app to track my food. The ‘place your order’ page popped up and i clicked to see where my order was. I realized that I just placed the order twice and immediately called Nino’s. The girl who answered the phone told me it was too late to cancel and my order was already made. I doubted it and pressed further to see what else could be done. She got rude with me and actually hung up on me! My son and daughter in law hopped in the car (it’s literally 2 blocks away) and were greeted with rudeness and shown a plain pizza that was said to be mine. I ordered half sausage as well as several other items, so I call bull. I never received the second order but my card was charged $88 twice. Not getting any satisfaction, my daughter in law wrote a review stating what happened. The first response was that they hope to fix it. That was replaced by an admission that there was a miscommunication on their end and they hoped to make it right. I contacted Slice and began a dispute. Although they tried, they said they could not issue a refund with Nino’s authorization. I was just notified that Nino’s is willing to give me the $10 tip back from the second order. That’s $78 short of making it right.
… more
Michele Martin
Ran in the other day to grab a slice of pizza with an old friend who I hadn’t seen in a while. I have been here before and I remembered it being a friendly welcoming experience. However, this time the counter staff were not friendly and seemed more annoyed by us. I understand having a bad day, but there is a place and time to express those emotions. I will say the pizza was great which is why I gave an extra star for quality of food.
… more
Gordon Picinich
Hi,
… more
Brian Magrogan
Nino’s is always a great choice, for lunch or dinner. A great place to grab a quick slice or a meal for the whole family. The Drunken Grandma pizza is excellent and always a go to. Highly recommend Nino’s!
… more
Johnathan Amos
Extremely friendly! Greeted like a friend and a smile when I walked inside, and they explained each pizza by the slice options, including their preferences. Delicious recipe, great ingredients, very clean environment. I have nothing bad to say here!
… more
Shiraz Hussain
Ordered a grandma pie and it was objectively not good. Was over cooked seems like they forgot about it and the whole thing tasted a bit stale. Paid $30+. Hillsdale is nice though.
… more
Zachary Thomas
This pizzeria is what this town needs. The menu, extensive. The taste incredible. I find myself constantly craving various items from the menu. I generally order online and my basket becomes twice the size by the time I am ready to check out. This would be a 5 star review for me but…..every time I walk in, and I am quickly reminded how absolutely awful the young woman is inside. As I walk in each time I am beyond elated to pick up my food, then suddenly I am overwhelmingly depressed to have to deal with her just to get the food I have already prepaid for. She is holding this fine establishment back.
… more
… View more