Based on 355 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
N12808 Northway Dr, Athelstane, WI 54104
Phone: (715) 856-5168
Website: https://m.facebook.com/pages/category/Restaurant/Nimrod-Inn-Bar-Supper-club-358647381289011/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kurt
We have tried to eat here 3 times now and all 3 times we walked out. First time waited 10 minutes for someone to even acknowledge us, no luck. Second time, same thing. Last night had a reservation at 6:30, walked in and stood there for 7 minutes while all the wait staff sat in the back working on what looked like their schedules on a white board before someone walked out and asked if we were there for dinner. Told her we had a reservation and she said 1 minute and then walked over to a table to take their order. After taking their order she disappeared and left us standing. After several minutes we walked out, again. We will never go back to this place. Service is horrible. Maybe if you’re a local it’s different. And $30 plus for a dinner at a local joint is crazy. Always feel like an outsider when we walk in so we will happily go elsewhere, like Sociables just down the road.
… more
Rebecca Bader
Had the Sunday family style chicken dinner with salad bar. The whole atmosphere was absolutely amazing. The old fashioneds are great. I got whiskey sour with mushrooms, husband got whiskey sweet with mushrooms. We want to go back to try the prime rib on Saturday. The staff was awesome. Our waitress Alex was so good and sweet. The bartender was super nice and the owners husband chatted with us for awhile. I highly recommend this place.
… more
Don Goldschmidt
The food was amazing. Prime rib Philly was big enough for 2 people and the burger was the perfect bar burger. Greasy, big and tasty!!!
… more
Quintin Serafico
Really great food. Got the nightly special, new York strip w/shrimp. Expecting a few shrimp, had about 10 on the plate. And the steak was hugh. Very nice supper club.
… more
Katie Gardipee
Perfect prime rib! We had a group of 9, everyone had great reviews from the fish fry to chicken sandwich. Salad bar had a good variety and fresh loaves of bread. A few of us had family style chicken and the portions were huge! We all took home leftovers. Service was wonderful too!
… more
Jim Suzawith
If could leave no stars I would. Bill came to $14.. Bartender took the $20 and kept the change. Hamburger was so dry you needed the chaser to wash it down. If you are not a regular, don’t bother going there. The old lady. Is a crook!!
… more
Richard Roffers
Cost have gone up substantially since I have been there last, but the quality of the meal was excellent. Prime Rib was fantastic and pizza was great ! The salad bar was great and plentiful and fresh. Hot gizzards and liver pate are not quite the same as I remember but ok.
… more
Tim Rob_______
Loved it all portions, foods, service were awesome
… more
Donna Suzawith
Don’t go and have a bite at the bar!!! Old lady bartender thinks 2 burgers for $14 deserves a $6 tip!!! Took the money and instead of giving change back, put it all in her tip jar. No wonder people stop going there!!
… more
Charlotte Wynen
The food was terribly over salted and the waitress was overly pushy to get us out of the dining area. The bar however had nice service and was well priced.
… more
… View more