Based on 254 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1916 McCartney Rd, Youngstown, OH 44505
Phone: (330) 747-0381
Hours
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alana Reese
The pizza is just ‘ok’ really don’t understand the reviews saying it is the best pizza ever. I guess maybe if you grew up in the area but I wasn’t impressed. The wings were terrible , very small and over cooked.
… more
Rick Firestone
I was a first-time customer, and I will definitely be back. The pizza was great, and I couldn’t believe how nice everyone was. It was extremely hot, and they were extremely busy, but Dante, and the entire crew, make it a point to get to know you and make sure you know you are appreciated. When you can package a terrific product, with exceptional service, you have a winner!
… more
Robert Ruscoe
Good luck finding a better pizza sauce anywhere. The brier hill is the best around and Dante delivered to us and was great. I even got a hand shake. If you haven’t been, you need to be.
… more
Michellé Ruby90 (Michelle’Ruby)
Always a great experience coming to a hometown staple. Will always be the best pizza in the city! Hopefully you guys finally get the recognition that you overly deserve when the same chill atmosphere all my life I’ve been going here and it has always been a home like family vibe that’s the best part! I’d love to see y’all in a newly updated building cause y’all definitely deserve it!!!!
… more
Tom Akers Jr
What an amazing local pizza place!! Dante was phenomenal!! He knew the menu off the top of his head and recommended the special to us, which was a great deal!! He’s super nice and even walked our pizzas out to us while we waited in the car! Top notch service and excellent pizza! We’ll definitely be going back.
… more
Sam Farah
Best pizza!! I can’t stop eating here and it’s a 25 minute drive each time one way. Pizza is gone before I get home. Perfect sauce, cheese, crust. Owners are great people. You will not be disappointed. I literally try pizza places all over, this is the best!!!
… more
Paul Schumacher
Pizza came at time promised, AND it was still hot !!! That’s why we love Nickys, that and the quality. Always tasty, with some of the best sauce I’ve had in my 60 years.
… more
Nicholas Carano
16″ Sausage Pepperoni Nick’y Pizza, one of the best pizza places Youngstown, Ohio is know for! The family is “Da Best” and are friendly and know Pizza!! Oh yeah, a shout out for their wings too!!
… more
Deborah Larson
This is one of the BEST pizza places in our area!! Everything is fresh and homeade, including the sauce, dough, and sausage!! Family owned for 50 years! Highly recommend!
… more
Lauren Miller-Mazzant
Absolutely delicious pizza!! The sauce is very flavourful and I feel it is a perfect combination of everything put together.
… more
… View more