Based on 305 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
102 E Main St, Lexington, SC 29072
Phone: (803) 490-0048
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sean & Kristin Parsons
My wife and I ate at Nicky’s last night, and we’re very pleasantly surprised. We were warmly greeted, and the staff made extra effort to get me seated at a table that would accommodate my knee that is just been operated on. Our server was very friendly and prompt. We ordered way too much food, especially as the serving portions are large. We got the calamari as an appetizer, slightly overdone, but seasoned well. A large pizza, which honestly is probably the best pizza we’ve ever had. We also got an order of spaghetti and meatballs . The pasta was cooked perfectly, and the marinara was tasty and meatballs were excellent. The only complaint, and it would be minor, would be that they could have drained the pasta a little more before serving as it came out slightly watery. Overall a great experience and we will be back.
… more
john whalen
This was delicious pizza! Best in Lexington and Columbia area for sure!!! Variety of things on the menu but my favorite is New York style pizza by the slice. You pick your own toppings ( tonight I had two slices. One with sausage and pepperoni. The other sausage pepperoni and mushrooms).Very generous slices at very reasonable prices. Also had a Mediterranean salad with artichoke hearts
Charles Giumarra
My wife and I stopped in just before closing, and Vica said no worries have a seat and we will take your order. Delicious pizza ny style (We ordered large pizza with pepperoni and half mushroom) and the entire staff was very nice. We will be back to enjoy more of the menu and relax with a beer.
T_ca
The food here is tasty. You have the option of indoor or outdoor dining. Also seem to do a lot of to go orders. They make a good pie but I recommend ordering a whole pie and skip “The NY Slice”. They cut their 16″ into 8 slices and for the price I would feel a lot better if they served it cut into 6. Or maybe move up to an 18″ or 20″ inch pie cut into 8. Besides that the beer is cold and the food is good…..
George Renard
We stopped by our favorite pizza place to enjoy the perfect SC weather on their patio. Cold Yuengling drafts and garlic knots to start. Instead of pizza this stop, we split a Caesar salad and a meatball sub. Definitely one of my must-have sandwiches here. The Italian sub is also excellent. Haley provided great service! Update…got another yummy meatball sub. My wife loves a slice of Hawaiian pizza. Alex gave great service on the cool fall patio.
Wendy S. Delmater Thies
Really great New York pizza in the heart of downtown Lexington. If you are still mourning the loss of Bricks and Stones NY pizza rejoice! This is the place to satisfy your craving for thin-crust pizza that hits all the right notes: semolina crust, high quality sauce and cheese, and excellent toppings. You know you’re in a REAL pizzeria from the scent of the baking pies in the correct NYC pizza oven, the garlic knots bundled and ready for the take-out orders, and the shakers of parmesan, hot pepper flakes, oregano, and granulated garlic at each table.the atmosphere is relaxed and there is outdoor dining if you’re so inclined. Friendly staff. Marvelous experience. And they serve pizza, including an authentic Sicilian one, by the slice, so drop by for lunch
… more
Paul Brown
Lunch with my daughter on Saturday afternoon. Muggy day. Wait staff awesome. Appetizers awesome. Fried Mac and cheese and other apps were good. Pizza was awesome and large. The parking was a challenge, but the food made up for it.
Katie McDowell-Ghaleb
Hands down the best pizza in SC!! After living outside NYC our whole lives this is the real deal. The true test you pick up the slice and it doesn’t flop over! Crust is crunchy and delicious the way it should be. We also had the fried ravioli, garlic knots and chicken roll which were all delicious as well. Took extra for home and will definitely be back with our kids again who had a special treat of ice cream and cannoli!!! Owners were extremely nice and welcoming and made sure we had everything we needed!
Destiny woodard
Super friendly people! Got to talk to the owner, loved hearing the history! Pizza is very good and different! A must try in Lexington!
Sarah Woodward
The food here is wonderful. The people are even better. I walked in a few weeks ago to see the manager working along with his team to fix the computer system. What stood out to me the most was that even though they couldn’t take orders, the manager still told his team to punch in, because he was going to pay them for their time, no matter what. And they called back a few hours later after the system had been fixed to see if they could take our order. These are good, salt of the earth people, and I hope their business continues on for many generations.
… View more