Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Menu

Firehouse-themed American BYOB joint in Madison is a family-friendly standard for pizza & pasta. Based on 356 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria 07940

Address:
15 Central Ave, Madison, NJ 07940

Phone: (973) 765-0565

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Friday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday	3–9 PM
Monday	Closed

Main Menu
Fried Calamari	$10.00
Mussels	$9.00
Clams Oreganata	$9.00
Artichokes Milanese	$8.00
Firehouse Wings buffalo or bbq	$9.00
Chicken Tenders	$8.00
Mozzarella Sticks	$7.00
Eggplant Rollantine	$8.00
Italian Antipasto (For 2) fryer peppers, provolone, prosciutto, salami, soppressata, olives, caponata, artichoke hearts, crostini and virgin olive oil	$14.00
Hot Antipasto (For 2) shrimp, baked clams, mussels, eggplant rollatini and fried calamari	$15.00
Pasta Fagioli	$5.00
Escarole & Bean	$5.00
Garden Salad mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, carrots, house vinaigrette	$8.00
Firehouse baby greens, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, red onions, roasted peppers, olives artichoke hearts, house vinaigrette	$9.00
Caesar romaine lettuce, croutons, pecorino romano, caesar dressing	$8.00
Wedge crisp iceberg, bacon, tomatoes, crumbled blue cheese, blue cheese dressing	$9.00
Greek mixed greens, olives, tomatoes, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, red wine vinaigrette	$9.00
Nicky’s mixed greens, walnuts, goat cheese, apples, dried cranberries, balsamic vinaigrette	$10.00
Baby Arugula vine ripe tomatoes, red onions, shaved parmesan, citrus vinaigrette	$9.00
Spinach crisp pancetta, mushrooms, red onions, chopped egg, balsamic fig vinaigrette	$9.00
Manicotti	$10.00
Stuffed Shells	$10.00
Baked Ziti	$10.00
Cheese Ravioli	$10.00
Meat Lasagna baked in tomato sauce	$10.00
Spaghetti & Meatballs	$10.00
Chicken Scarpariello chicken sauteed with sausage, potatoes, mushrooms and garlic in a light brown sauce	$13.00
Firehouse Chicken medallions of chicken sauteed in garlic, white wine, marinara and parmesan tossed with penne	$12.00
Veal Milanese breaded and pan fried topped with mixed greens tossed in olive oil and fresh lemon	$14.00
Eggplant Parmigiana baked in tomato sauce and mozzarella, served over penne	$12.00
Eggplant Rollatini seasoned ricotta wrapped in delicately fried eggplant baked in tomato sauce, served over penne	$12.00
Grilled Salmon perfectly grilled salmon draped with a lemon caper wine sauce, served with sauteed chef’s vegetables	$14.00
Chicken Broccoli Rabe & Potatoes grilled chicken served with sauteed broccoli rabe and roasted potatoes	$12.00
Tilapia – Oreganata Or Francaise oreganata breadcrumbs or fresh lemon sauce served with sauteed chef’s vegetable and potatoes	$13.00
Frutte Di Mare jumbo shrimp, little neck clams, mussels and tender calamari simmered in seasoned marinara sauce over linguini	$15.00
Nicky’s New Yorker n.y. strip steak grilled to your liking topped with sauteed onions and mushrooms served with onion rings	$23.00
Calamari – Marinara Or Fra Diavolo tender rings sauteed in olive oil and garlic in a seasoned marinara sauce over linguini	$13.00
Mussels – Marinara Or Fra Diavolo prince edward island mussels sauteed in olive oil and garlic then simmered in our signature marinara sauce over linguini	$12.00
Chicken marsala, parmigiana, francaise, picatta	$12.00
Veal marsala, parmigiana, francaise, picatta	$14.00
Shrimp marsala, parmigiana, francaise, picatta	$14.00
Cavatelli & Broccoli sauteed in olive oil and fresh garlic	$10.00
Penne Vodka fresh marinara sauce sauteed with shallots, butter, parmesan, cream and a splash of vodka	$10.00
Rigatoni Bolognese “our signature dish” of beef, pork and veal simmered in marinara sauce with romano cheese and a touch of cream	$11.00
Fresh Clam Sauce freshly shucked clams sauteed in olive oil, garlic, white wine and fresh parsley over linguini	$12.00
Linguini Puttanesca a light tomato broth sauteed with capers, olives, anchovies and garlic	$11.00
Orecchietta “Rabe” & Sausage “little ears” pasta tossed with sauteed broccoli rabe and italian sweet sausage in a garlic wine sauce	$11.00
Pasta Alla “Poe” (named after nicky’s mom) chicken sauteed with fresh mushrooms garlic and peas tossed in a tomato cream sauce with bowtie pasta	$11.00
Orecchietta Fagioli escarole, sundried tomatoes and white beans sauteed in olive oil and garlic tossed with “little ears” pasta and fresh grated parmesan cheese	$11.00
Three “Paisanos” jumbo shrimp, grilled chicken and spicy sausage sauteed in a roasted garlic sauce tossed with angel hair pasta	$13.00
Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe jumbo shrimp and broccoli rabe sauteed in olive oil and garlic over linguini	$12.00
Spaghetti Carbonara sauteed with peas, prosciutto, bacon, onions, cream and parmesan	$11.00
Lobster Ravioli simmered in a plum tomato cream sauce with sundried tomatoes	$12.00
Cheese tomato sauce, mozzarella	$11.00
Whole Wheat house made wheat dough, tomato sauce, mozzarella	$13.00
Pesto fresh basil sauce, romano cheese, mozzarella	$12.00
White seasoned ricotta, mozzarella	$12.00
Firehouse Special sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, peppers, onions	$13.00
Vegetable Combo broccoli florets, spinach, green peppers, onions, tomatoes	$13.00
Margherita plum tomato, fresh mozzarella, garlic, fresh basil, olive oil	$13.00
Four Cheese provolone, pecorino romano, mozzarella, seasoned ricotta	$13.00
Grandma-(One Size) square thin crust, mozzarella, grandma’s special sauce	$16.00
Sicilian-(One Size) square thick crust, tomato sauce, mozzarella	$16.00
Individual Cheese tomato sauce, mozzarella	$8.00
Individual Gluten Free tomato sauce, mozzarella	$9.00
Hawaiian baked ham, pineapple, mozzarella	$13.00
Meat Lovers pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham, bacon	$14.00
Eggplant Rollatini eggplant, ricotta, marinara, pecorino, mozzarella	$14.00
Penne Vodka vodka sauce, mozzarella, penne pasta	$13.00
Chicken Parmigiana breaded chicken, seasoned marinara, mozzarella	$14.00
Buffalo Chicken spicy chicken, blue cheese, mozzarella	$14.00
Bruschetta plum tomatoes, arugula, red onion, fresh mozzarella, olive oil	$14.00
White Clam baby clams, olive oil, garlic, fresh parsley, mozzarella	$14.00
Toppings Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham, bacon, olives, onions mushrooms, broccoli spinach, green peppers, hot cherry peppers, extra cheese, anchovy, fresh garlic	$1.00
Premium Toppings Breaded or grilled chicken, marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, goat cheese, fresh mozzarella	$2.00
Margherita plum tomato, fresh mozzarella, garlic, fresh basil, olive oil	$11.00
Mediteranean artichoke hearts, roasted peppers, olives, parmesan, fresh basil, tomato sauce	$13.00
Nicky’s Special broccoli rabe, portobello, sausage, garlic, tomato sauce, mozzarella	$13.00
Bianco seasoned ricotta, pecorino romano, mozzarella, fresh garlic, spinach	$12.00
Hamburger	$8.00
Cheese Burger	$9.00
Bacon Cheese Burger american cheese, bacon	$10.00
Mushroom Burger sauteed mushrooms, melted mozzarella	$10.00
“Four Alarm ” Burger bacon, blue cheese crumbles american cheese, hot sauce	$11.00
Pizza Burger melted mozzarella, marinara sauce	$10.00
Calzone & Stromboli	$7.00
Fillings	$1.00
Premium Fillings	$2.00
Cup Of Sauce	$1.00
Meatball	$6.00
Meatball Or Eggplant Parmigiana	$7.00
Chicken Parmigiana	$8.00
Veal Parmigiana	$9.00
Sausage, Pepers, Onions	$8.00
Sausage, Broccoli Rabe	$8.00
Cheese Steak	$7.00
Italian Sub ham, salami, provolone	$8.00
Turkey	$7.00
Homemade Tuna	$7.00
Chicken Cutlet (grilled or breaded) lettuce, tomato, mayo	$7.00
Rustic sliced steak, provolone, arugula, tomato, pesto mayo	$9.00
Tuscan grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, tomato, balsamic vinaigrette	$9.00
Chicken Or Turkey Blt crisp bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo	$9.00
Buffalo spicy chicken, blue cheese, lettuce, tomato	$8.00
Rancho grilled chicken, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing	$8.00
Chicken Caesar grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan, caesar dressing	$8.00
Tuna lettuce, tomato, mayo	$8.00
Meatbals Or Sausage	$5.00
Fries	$3.00
Side Salad	$3.00
Pasta	$5.00
Fresh Sauteed Escarole Or Spinach	$6.00
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe	$8.00
Soft Drinks	$2.50
Pellegrino	$2.50
Coffee Or Tea	$1.50
Cappuccino	$3.50
Espresso	$2.50
Bottle Water	$1.00
Can Soda	$1.25
2 Lt Soda Bottle coke, diet coke, sprite	$3.00
10″ Cheese Pizza
10″ Gulten-Free Pizza
Chicken Finger (3) with fries	$5.00
Chicken Parmigiana with penne	$6.00
Penne & Metaballs (1)	$6.00
Penne with butter	$4.00
Stuffed Shells (3)
Baked Ziti	$5.00
Mozzrela Sticks (4) with fries	$5.00
Mac-N-Cheese fries	$5.00
Grilled Cheese fries	$5.00
Apple Juice	$1.25
Milk	$1.25
Chocolate Milk	$1.25
Soft Drinks	$1.25
College Menu
Chicken Fingers	$8.00
Mozzarella Stix	$7.00
Fries	$3.00
Onion Rings	$4.00
Fried Calamari	$10.00
Meatballs	$5.00
Sausage	$5.00
Pasta	$5.00
Side Salad	$3.00
Garlic Bread	$3.00
Sautéed Spinach	$6.00
Garlic KNots	$3.00
Spaghetti & Meatballs	$10.00
Penne Vodka	$10.00
Cavatelli & Broccoli	$10.00
Baked Ziti	$10.00
Rigatoni Bolognese	$11.00
Fat Fireman Meatballs, bacon, mozzarella stix fries, marinara sauce, mozzarella	$8.00
Fat Mess Cheesesteak, chicken fingers, mozzarella stix fries, mayo, ketchup, lettuce, tomato	$8.00
Fat Hangover Buffalo chicken fingers, fries, mozzarella stix, bacon, ranch	$8.00
Fat Nicky Chicken fingers, mozzarella stix, onion rings fries, lettuce, mayo, ketchup	$8.00
Fat Waitress Bacon, egg, sausage, fries, lettuce, mayo, ketchup	$8.00
Fat Caesar Grilled chicken, bacon, romaine, parmesan, caesar dressing	$8.00
Cheese	$11.00
Buffalo Chicken	$14.00
Meat Lovers	$14.00
Hawaiian	$13.00
Penne Vodka	$13.00
Margherita	$13.00
Whole Wheat	$13.00
Toppings Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham, bacon, olives, onions mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, green peppers, hot cherry peppers extra cheese, anchovy, fresh garlic	$1.00
Premium Toppings Breaded or grilled chicken, marinated artichoke hearts roasted red peppers, goat cheese, fresh mozzarella	$2.00
Bacon Cheeseburger American cheese, bacon	$10.00
Mushroom Burger Sautéed mushrooms, melted mozzarella	$10.00
“Four Alarm” Burger Blue cheese crumbles, American cheese bacon, hot sauce	$11.00
Pizza Burger Melted mozzarella, marinara sauce	$10.00
Garden Salad Mixed greens, tomatoes cucumbers, red onion, carrots, house vinaigrette	$8.00
Firehouse Baby greens, tomatoes, carrots cucumbers, red onions, roasted peppers olives, artichoke hearts, house vinaigrette	$9.00
Caesar Romaine lettuce, croutons pecorino romano, Caesar dressing	$8.00
Wedge Crisp iceberg, bacon, tomatoes crumbled blue cheese, ranch dressing	$9.00
Greek Mixed greens, olives, tomatoes, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, red wine vinaigrette	$9.00
Nicky’s Mixed greens, walnuts, goat cheese apples, dried cranberries, balsamic vinaigrette	$10.00
Baby Arugula Vine ripe tomatoes red onions, shaved parmesan, citrus vinaigrette	$9.00
Spinach Crisp pancetta, mushrooms red onions, chopped egg, balsamic fig vinaigrette	$9.00
Buffalo Wings BBQ	$9.00
Cheese Steak	$8.00
Chicken Parmigiana	$8.00
Meatball Parmigiana	$8.00
Eggplant Parmigiana	$8.00
Sausage, Pepper, Onion	$8.00
Italian Sub	$7.00
Chicken Cutlet	$7.00
Tuna	$7.00
Term Paper large cheese pizza, mozzarella stix, garlic bread, 2 – cans of soda	$21.00
Frat Party large cheese pizza, medium cheese pizza, buffalo wings, 1 – 2 liter soda	$29.00
The Exam penne vodka, garlic knots, 1 – can of soda	$13.00
The Big Game large pepperoni pizza, medium cheese pizza, fried calamari, 10 wings (buffalo or bbq), 1 – 2 litter soda	$41.00
All Nighter medium pizza – 1 topping, side of meatballs, garden salad, 2 – cans of soda	$22.00
Animal House any fat-wich, 2 large cheese pizzas, chicken fingers, fries, 2 – 2 liter sodas	$41.00
Combo 2 medium pizzas, 1 topping each, plus 10 wings	$29.00
Nicky’S Lucky 8’S 3 medium cheese pizzas	$8.00
Large Cheese Pie, Plus 10 Wings	$18.00
Catering Menu
Fried Calamari served with marinara sauce	$40.00
Clams Oreganata seasoned breadcrumbs, olive oil, garlic, lemon	$40.00
Firehouse Wings (buffalo or bbq) served with blue cheese dip	$35.00
Chicken Tenders honey mustard	$35.00
Mozzarella Sticks served with marinara sauce	$30.00
Stuffed Mushrooms seasoned breadcrumbs, parmesan, garlic	$30.00
Tomato Bruschetta roma tomato, red onion, garlic, olive oil, shaved parmesan	$25.00
Garden Salad mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, carrots, house vinaigrette	$25.00
Firehouse baby greens, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, red onions, roasted peppers, olives, artichoke hearts, house vinaigrette	$30.00
Greek mixed greens, olives, tomatoes, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, red wine vinaigrette	$30.00
Nicky’s mixed greens, walnuts, apples, goat cheese, dried cranberries balsamic vinaigrette	$30.00
Baby Arugula vine ripe tomatoes, red onions, shaved parmesan, citrus vinaigrette	$30.00
Spinach crisp pancetta, mushrooms, chopped egg, red onions balsamic fig vinaigrette	$30.00
Caesar romaine lettuce, croutons, pecorino romano, caesar dressing	$30.00
Pasta Fagioli	$12.00
Escarole & Bean	$12.00
Penne in our classic tomato sauce	$25.00
Cavatelli & Broccoli sauteed in olive oil and fresh garlic	$30.00
Rigatoni Bolognese “our signature dish” of beef, pork and veal simmered in marinara sauce with romano cheese and a touch of cream	$35.00
Penne Vodka fresh marinara sauce sauteed with shallots, butter, parmesan cream and a splash of vodka	$30.00
Orecchietta, Rabe & Sausage “little ears” pasta tossed with sauteed broccoli rabe and italian sweet sausage in a garlic wine sauce	$35.00
Fresh Clam Sauce freshly shucked clams sauteed in olive oil, garlic, white wine and fresh parsley over linguini	$40.00
Linguini Puttanesca a light tomato broth sauteed with capers, olives, anchovies and garlic	$30.00
Pasta Alla “Poe” (named after nicky’s mom) chicken sauteed with fresh mushrooms, garlic and peas tossed in a tomato cream sauce with bowtie pasta	$35.00
Orecchietta Fagioli escarole, white beans and sundried tomatoes sauteed in olive oil and garlic tossed with “little ears” pasta and fresh grated parmesan cheese	$35.00
Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe jumbo shrimp and broccoli rabe sauteed in olive oil and garlic over linguini	$40.00
Lobster Ravioli jumbo lobster ravioli simmered in a plum tomato cream sauce with sundried tomatoes	$40.00
Baked Ziti tomato sauce, ricotta, mozzarella	$30.00
Cheese Ravioli tomato sauce	$30.00
Baked Manicotti homemade crepes, seasoned ricotta, baked in tomato sauce	$35.00
Meat Lasagna layers of pasta, meat and cheese baked in tomato sauce	$35.00
Stuffed Shells baked in tomato sauce	$35.00
Eggplant Parmigiana baked in tomato sauce and mozzarella	$35.00
Eggplant Rollantini seasoned ricotta wrapped in delicately fried eggplant baked in tomato sauce	$35.00
Meatballs Or Sausage in tomato sauce	$30.00
Sausage & Peppers	$30.00
Sausage, Peppers, Onions & Potatoes italian style, fresh herbs, garlic, olive oil	$35.00
Sausage & Broccoli Rabe	$35.00
Firehouse Chicken medallions of chicken sauteed in garlic, white wine marinara and parmesan tossed with penne	$35.00
Chicken Parmigiana baked in tomato sauce, mozzarella	$45.00
Chicken Francaise egg battered, sauteed in a lemon sauce	$45.00
Chicken Marsala sauteed with fresh mushrooms, marsala wine	$45.00
Chicken Piccata fresh lemon sauce, capers	$45.00
Chicken Scarpariello chicken sauteed with sausage, potatoes, mushrooms and garlic in a light brown sauce	$50.00
Chicken Broccoli Rabe & Potatoes grilled chicken served with sauteed broccoli rabe and roasted potatoes	$35.00
Veal Parmigiana baked in tomato sauce, mozzarella	$55.00
Veal Francaise egg battered, sauteed in a lemon sauce	$55.00
Veal Marsala fresh mushrooms, marsala wine	$55.00
Veal Saltimbocca prosciutto, sage, madeira wine, sauteed spinach	$60.00
Veal Picatta fresh lemon sauce, capers	$55.00
Shrimp marinara, fra diavolo, parmigiana	$60.00
Tilapia francaise, oreganata	$50.00
Salmon picatta, grilled	$55.00
Calamari marinara, fra diavolo	$40.00
Mussels marinara, fra diavolo	$35.00
Broccoli Rabe sauteed in olive oil and garlic	$30.00
Escarole Or Spinach sauteed in olive oil and garlic	$30.00
Roasted Red Potatoes olive oil, butter, rosemary	$20.00
Sloppy Joe’s turkey, ham or roast beef with swiss cheese, cole slaw, russian dressing, rye bread	$65.00
Assorted Sandwiches on italian rolls, focaccia and wraps, italian, roast beef, turkey, ham, grilled chicken	$60.00
Italian Antipasto an array of italian specialties	$75.00
Crudite with dip	$55.00
Fruit	$55.00
Cheese	$55.00
Shrimp Cocktail 4 pieces pp	$80.00
Turkey	$14.00
Italian	$14.00
Roast Beef	$14.00
Tuna	$14.00
Cookie Trays
Assorted Cakes & Pastries
#1 assorted sandwiches and wraps, firehouse salad, pasta salad, potato salad	$14.00
(Choose 1 Of Each) salad, pasta, chicken, vegetable	$18.00
(Choose 1 Of Each) salad, appetizer, pasta, chicken, seafood	$24.00
(Choose 1 Of Each) salad, appetizer, traditional italian, chicken, seafood, vegetable	$28.00
Cookies
Cakes
Pastries

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jeanie DeVincenzo

Great decor and super friendly staff! We had lunch here and will definitely be back for dinner…. Don’t miss out on the ZEPPOLES and this delicious broccoli rabe, chicken, and shrimp dish

… more

jeff kovatch

Very good family pizza restaraunt. Pizza is great. Excellent calamari.

… more

Daniel Grimm

We held our rehearsal dinner at Firehouse and we could not have been more impressed! All of our guests couldn’t stop raving about the food and the service was top notch. Since it’s BYOB, the staff let us bring our beer and wine earlier in the day so it was properly chilled for the dinner. If you’re looking for a place to host your next private event, Firehouse would be a great choice!

… more

Kristin Ray

I wish I could give this place more than 5 stars! From start to finish our experience at Nicky’s was amazing. The new owners, Amanda and Joe, have elevated and improved the decor, the pizza and the menu. We learned that Joe is a chef with many years of restaurant experience and he redid all the menu items. Amanda is the friendliest human on earth… we even heard her talking to the table of teenage girls next to us and making sure they had a ride home (it was after 9pm). The manager, Jeremy, stopped by several times to check on us and was attentive to all of our needs.

… more

Haley E Michienzi

Nicky’s was truly impressive. Their cauliflower crust pizza has wicked flavor, it’s crispy, and it’s gluten free! Wouldn’t have known it was a GF crust.

… more

Michele

Great experience here yesterday. We arrived as soon as it opened for lunch.

… more

Robert LoPinto

This is one of the best places in the area. Joe, Amanda, Jeremy and Amanda’s father are incredible. They truly make you feel like family. The food is outstanding. They use the highest quality ingredients, which is why we go here once to twice a week. The pizza is spot on (we love the plain and grandma) and the pasta is homemade and incredible (we get the 3 paisanos over rigatoni and shrimp francese over angel hair).

… more

Chuck Mound

I really enjoyed the decor of this Pizzeria. Had a great vibe with the workers who were very friendly and willing to serve at a high level. I went with the Margherita Slice which was average 3.5 for Morris County based on the ratings for the Pizza Hunters App. The Crust was tasty and was the highlight of the slice. They used very thin slices of mozzarella and with little to non basil. Not much olive oil or sauce was used on the slice. Could not get a good taste of the sauce, so they could have very good ingredients, but they were not presented well on the slice that I had. The people there were great, and on that alone would give them my business again. Hope next visit I get a better taste.

… more

Darlene Castellano

Pizza is the best. The two young lady’s at the front were rude and unfriendly. Very unfortunate. Customers are your most important asset.

… more

Samantha McCann

Had my daughter’s baptism celebration with a party of 45 people, and Joe and his crew did an absolutely PHENOMENAL job. They were so all so kind and helpful from start to finish. They all helped with anything they could and provided exceptional service. The food was incredible, we couldn’t get enough!

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Nicky’s Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Menu – Madison, NJ

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions