Based on 19 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5203 Cortez Rd W, Bradenton, FL 34210
Phone: (941) 242-2222
Website: https://new-york-style-brooklyn-pizzeria.business.site/?utm_source=gmb&utm_medium=referral
Hours
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Xander Cantrell
The online menu needs to be desperately updated because the prices were quite a bit more expensive then what was advertised. Also the place I pulled up to looked completely different, I’m assuming new owners?
… more
tj1015
We were in from out of town and on a crazy, strict schedule. Ordered our pizza ahead of time and when we got there, it was hot and ready! Not sure about some of the other negative reviews, but our pizza was great and exactly what I expected for “Brooklyn Pizza.”
… more
Ken Lindeman
What a great treat it was to get a very tasty pizza for take out, including being able to sit at the counter watching it being made, and even enjoying live music at the same time. The pizza was excellent. The dough was hand tossed/twirled by the gentleman that made it, who I believe was the owner, and the pizza constructed by hand. This would be my recommendation, hands down, for a takeout pizza in the area. It certainly will be my choice!
… more
Karen Bonanno
I ordered a margharita XL pizza the day before Thanksgiving. Now the price on their website is 20.99$ When I picked up my luke warm pizza, the price was over $30 and was the smallest XL pizza I have ever seen There was no fresh mozzerella cheese anywhere on the pizza just their normal cheese and the tomato was a whole, cold plum tomato, I will give them that the skin was off. My Italian relatives were very upset that I brought home, never mind that I paid for this as was I. I will not be back.
… more
Heather Trolio
Excellent pizza and great customer service. Order was not correct when we picked it up but the gentleman working made it right quickly and even brought it out to our car. Very impressed.
… more
Juliet Cherfils
Not worth the price. The pizza had tasted bland to me. Thought the parm and the red crushes peppers would help but it didn’t:( However, they have good costumer service!
… more
Kari Hurst
We’ve always loved the pizza here, however, I ordered one tonight for takeout, was no told that new owners took over. The pizza was very doughy. No sauce at all, if there was we didn’t see it or taste it. Toppings were scares. Plus flavorless. Basically,it was horrible. We even had to add salt! Which we never do, or have to! I think the cook was distracted with only 2 people at the bar, hence, no sauce .it too bad, cause it use to be our go to for pizza take out!. Now we will go out of our way to Danny’s on Manatee, we paid 25$ for a large tasteless pizza. I also asked what happened with the cash tip I left? For the cook and cashier, I didn’t see it in the tip jar. When I asked about it she pulled 2$ out of her pocket, I left 5$.
… more
Melissa Zemko
New owners just took over a few weeks ago and we had their pizza last night…it was amazing! It is the best pizza in Bradenton!
… more
G M
Great pizza and kind owners. Support local.
… more
Avinash Adwalpalker
We visited yesterday and dined in. Delicious pizza and friendly service.
… more
… View more