New York Plate Menu – Gary, IN

Type : Restaurant

Location : Gary, IN

Based on 345 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

New York Plate 46403

Address:
5808 Melton Rd #2905, Gary, IN 46403

Phone: (219) 939-8800

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–5 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–9:30 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Thursday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Friday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Saturday 10 AM–9:30 PM

Menu

menu
Menu
The plates
The New York Plate
chicken and gyro over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$9.79
The Bronx Plate
steak and gyro over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$10.79
The Queens Plate
chicken over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$9.29
The Brooklyn Plate
steak and chicken over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$10.79
The Manhattan Plate
steak chicken and gyro over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$11.29
The Empire Plate
gyro over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$9.29
The Liberty Plate
steak over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$11.29
The Long Island Plate
fried shrimp over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$13.99
The Coney Island Plate
Fried catfish over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$11.99
Falafel Plate
falafel over rice with pita onions green peppers salad with our famous New York Sauce
$8.29
Gyro Plate
tomatoes lettuce onions tzatziki sauce with fries 2 pita
$9.99
the new yorkers fries (steak,gyro,chicken,beef)(your choice of meat)
Lettuce Tomatoes Nacho Cheese Hot Peppers New York Sauce $8.99
the new yorkers nacho (steak,gyro,chicken,beef)(your choice of meat
Lettuce Tomatoes Nacho Cheese Hot Peppers Sour Cream On Doritos $8.49

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Gail Thomas
The young woman working the register just needs to smile more. I don’t think she likes her Job. I tipped her $5. Didn’t crack from her sullen mood. I hope she gets happy.

… more

Kelli Couture
Food is always hot and fresh. You get more than generous portions. A must have when we’re in the area…or sometimes we make a special trip.

… more

sparkle percy
I love this place it was a good place to pick preseason food my whole family loved it I love to get their bowls so far I’ve had the New York Plate the Brooklyn plate the Flamin Hot cheese sticks or daughter had the fries and my other family members had things as well so so far everything that I have tasted has been good. I recommend this place to a lot of people if you want to try something different in this is one of the latest to try something different and get full and still have food left over.

… more

Smookumz Dashiki
For the pass year and a half all I use to order was chicken . Today that change! I tried one of signature plate, omg my inner fat bxtch was dancing. It was flavorful, filling, fresh and good portion for your money’s worth. The sauce give it a standing ovation. I’ll be ordering the “Manhattan Plate” every cheat day. The customer service was very pleasant. Much love and gratitude to the owner and staffs.

… more

Chelsea
First off, I was already HIGHLY skeptical of this place. I just moved up here from FL and haven’t seen a single good restaurant to eat at. I was really excited to find this place close to my house. I read reviews beforehand of course which made me hesitant to order from here, but I bit the bullet and did….and I regret it.

… more

Dee Mohaugany
Fast service. Gyro plate. Special sauce tastes like some type of ranch formula. Misspelled words on the menu (over 9 words).

… more

Pink Kandi
I got the New York Plate (Chicken & Gyro, rice, lettuce, tomato, green pepper, sauce, and bread) Loved it. He got the 10pc. The Fries couldve came out 1 second sooner but overall everything was good.

… more

Dave Da Drummajor
Very good. Always hot. Awesome plates and values. Foods done relatively quick. Great management. Always clean.

… more

Alice K
I went with the review that said: Yes. Eat here.

… more

Ariale Schell
We absolutely loved finding this place. It’s not shiny or flashy, it was kind of hidden but the taste of the food, the size of the portions, and the price per meal made it an amazing experience. If you go you have to make sure to try the Cheetos Menu and those Mozzarella sticks with the cheese dip makes my mouth water just thinking about it. The portions were huge and well worth the money spent on it. If we drive thru there again, we will definitely be stopping.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions