New York Pizza Garden Menu – Fishers, IN

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Fishers, IN

Based on 313 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

New York Pizza Garden 46038

Address:
9522 E 126th St, Fishers, IN 46038

Phone: (317) 284-1163

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–8:30 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–9:30 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Thursday 10 AM–9:30 PM
Friday 11 AM–10:30 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10:30 PM

Menu

Popular Items
Super Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, olives, onion, green peppers & extra cheese.
$20.99
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef & extra cheese.
$20.99
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$13.99
Breadsticks $7.99
Wings $25.99
Catfish Nuggets
Comes with Fries.
$13.99
Philly Cheesesteak Beef Sub Meal
Comes with Fries.
$12.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub Meal
Comes with Fries.
$12.99
Greek Salad $9.99
Build Your Own Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$9.99
Pizza
Super Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mushrooms, olives, onion, green peppers & extra cheese
$20.99
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, beef & extra cheese.
$20.99
All American Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms & red onions.
$20.99
Mooney’s Alfredo Pizza
Alfredo sauce, chicken, bacon, tomatoes & cheese.
$20.99
Greek Pizza
Gyro meat, onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese, with extra cheese.
$20.99
Marama Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, olives, onions, green peppers, tomatoes & thyme.
$20.99
BBQ Special Pizza
Bbq sauce, chicken, onions & extra cheese.
$20.99
Margarita Pizza
Garlic, tomatoes, basil & extra cheese.
$20.99
Hawaiian Special Pizza
Ham, pineapple & extra cheese.
$20.99
Bacon Cheese Burger Pizza
Beef, bacon & cheese.
$20.99
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken, banana peppers & cheese.
$20.99
Chicken, Bacon, Ranch Pizza
Chicken, bacon, tomatoes & ranch sauce.
$20.99
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings $19.99
Chicken Tender $23.99
Chicken Tender With Fries $13.99
Chicken Wings With Fries $13.99
Salads
Greek Salad
Tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, olives, and feta cheese in an olive oil dressing.
$9.99
Garden Salad
Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions, cucumbers, and black olives.
$9.99
Grilled Steak Salad
Grilled steak, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella cheese.
$13.99
Grilled Chicken Salad
Lettuce, red onions, cucumbers, eggs, tomatoes, and green peppers.
$13.99
Sides
Breadsticks $7.99
Extra Sauce $1.49
Cheesy Breadsticks $9.99
Fries $4.99
Okra $7.99
Onion Rings $7.99
Mozzarella Sticks $7.80
Mushrooms $7.99
Calzones
Build Your Own Calzone $19.50
New York Meals
Philly Cheesesteak Beef Sub Meal $12.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub Meal $12.99
Double Cheeseburger Meal $18.99
Cheeseburger Meal $14.99
Gyro Meal $12.99
Falafel Meal
Comes with fries and drink.
$12.99
Philly Cheesesteak Chicken Sub Meal $12.99
Pizza Puff Meal
Comes with fries and drink.
$10.99
Chicken Wings Meal $13.99
Chicken Tenders Meal $10.99
Shawarma
Chicken Shawarma
Comes with fries.
$12.99
Beef Shawarma
Comes with fries.
$12.99
Chicken Shawarma Platter
Comes with pickles, tomato, tahini.
$16.99
Beef Shawarma Platter
Comes with pickles, tomato, tahini.
$16.99
Fish
Catfish Fillet Family Meal $34.99
Catfish Tilapia Family Meal $34.99
Catfish Nuggets
Catfish fillets cut into pieces.
$13.99
Catfish Fillet
Catfish fillet, lemon, garlic, red pepper.
$13.99
Tilapia $13.99
Perch
Fish meal.
$10.99
Perch Family Meal $26.00
Kabab
Kebab Sandwich
Fries, tomato, onion and parsley.
$11.99
Kebab Platter
Fries, tomato, onion and parsley.
$14.99
Beverages
Soda $2.50
Lunch Specials
Chicken Wings & Fries Lunch
6 pieces wings.
$10.40
Chicken Fingers & Fries Lunch $10.40
10” One Topping Pizza Lunch $10.40
Two Pizza Puff & Fries Lunch $10.40
Gyro & Fries Lunch $10.40
Chicken Parmesan & Fries Lunch $10.40
Chicken Philly & Fries Lunch $10.40
Beef Philly & Fries Lunch $10.40

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

David Shaw
Very friendly and enjoyable experience.

Karen Williams
Our 1st time here and read the good reviews! Thought, let’s give it a try! Food was terrible! Salad was yellow—mostly the core! We asked for no onions & tomatoes….and Everything came with onions & tomatoes! We also waited 25 minutes for a salad & gyro! We definitely will not be returning! Staff was friendly!!

brad russell
This place has a huge variety of menu options. I liked the fried catfish although it was borderline too salty. The wings come with the sauce on the side. The buffalo sauce is very spicy so beware. Might want to take it easy at first. I didn’t try the pizza but the kids enjoyed it.

Jimmy P
This guy is awesome. Door dash cancelled my order. He called me and gave me a much better deal once I picked up. Pizza and wings are spot on here. Give it a shot… you’ll be happy.

Hasan
This spot is great! Their wings were freshly fried to order and they were generous with the lemon pepper. The pizza and garlic bread were baked to order and you can really taste the freshness in the ingredients. Highly recommended!

Ahmed Elshoura
Super supreme pizza-M

Alex Z
My Fiancé and I just moved to the area and were looking for a good pizza place, as we cannot stand chain store pizza. We decided to pop in on a whim since it was advertised as “New York” style. Having grown up in the north east, I absolutely despise the midwest’s obsession with the abomination that is Chicago style pizza. I ordered a small pizza with green peppers, onions, and sausage while my fiancé ordered the philly cheese steak. The pizza was incredible, leagues ahead of the corporate pizza places in the area. But the philly cheese steak sandwich really stuck out. The meat was so tender and flavorful, I honestly think it was the best I’ve ever had, and my fiancé agreed. Will definitely be back and will be recommending to my friends!

… more

James Robitaille
Tonight was my first time here and the food was great!

Leana Sayyah
I used to love this place, they got new ownership and the food just doesn’t hit the same. I got an 8 piece kebob with my brother and it was so dry, pretty sure it’s frozen meat. It’s been almost 24 hours and my stomach still doesn’t feel right after eating it. It was also served with tortilla bread instead of pita. I’m not sure if the pizza is as good as it used to, don’t think I’ll try it and find out.

adam brown
We love this place. The food is fantastic- I highly recommend the wings! Also- the service is great as well- the people are so friendly.

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

×
Photo Image