Based on 442 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1449 US-90, Gautier, MS 39553
Phone: (228) 522-1163
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bailey Clark
Apologies for the half eaten food pics but sometimes hunger and good food gets the best of me! I’m only human I’m SORRY! So regarding the food you’ve obviously come to read about: food is yum, food is plentiful, food is hot and problems are none. I’d be very surprised if you encountered a problem there but if you do, it’s prolly your own fault and you need to address the obvious issues you have.
… more
Doug Austin
Having lived in New York for many years I wouldn’t exactly call this a New York style pizza however it’s still very tasty. Cooked exceptionally well. I had the New York specialty. Usually with that many ingredients the pizza turns out soggy but they did a great job and balanced it all very well. I placed a to go order for pick up and it was done exactly as advertised. Also had the chicken wings which were similar to an school Buffalo style chicken wing. Very good.
… more
Jason Ballard
YUM! Delicious pizza! Nicely decorated baseball themed NY pizza location. They sell slices of pizza even during dinner time. Steak salad was fantastic. Pepperoni & cheese pizza tasted awesome. Super polite employees. Everyone in our party loved their food including the fries. I would highly recommend this spot. Leave a review to help others make a decision.
… more
Paul A. Bennett
This pizza place is locally owned and operated and has been open for many years. They have 4 locations on the Mississippi Gulf Coast ready to serve anything on their menu. I recall eating at this establishment when it was in the Singing River Mall, back in the 90’s. They serve quite the variety of Italian dishes, pizza by the slice, a selection of soft drinks and beer, and are very consistent with their product. Personally, their pizza is much better than any “big name” pizza place. Support local business’ and buy local. They earned my 5 stars 2 decades ago and I am finally letting the world know.
… more
Simple Man
Great folks for sure and the pizza is on point especially if you want something different than the big name box stores. The Phillies are amazing too by the way! If you get bored of the standard pizza try the chicken and bacon one, im usually vanilla on pizza (should be red sauce and pepperoni) to be a real pizza but I’m very pleased with it
… more
M. Samp
Didn’t read any reviews before we ordered online. Ordered from an area we were staying near and purchased the supreme. Close, fast, good price, great crust, subbed the pepperoni for xtra black olives, personnel were friendly. We will be back. Thank you.
… more
Big Boi
Go to pascagoula New York pizza,,,100%better,,, wing’s are nasty here,,, plus there was fly’s on the slice to go pizza,,, definitely need better cook’s & people who care
… more
Lisa Floden
One of my favorite spots. Their antipasto salad is awesome. The staff is friendly and the place is clean.
… more
A F
We’ve gone to this place twice now and love it. The Personal size is pretty big, a large is two meals for sure. Great service! Definitely gonna keep going.
… more
Joe Rutan
Been going to New York pizza since they opened in Gautier and always been pleased with the food and service. They had the best fries I’ve ever had. Sadly today we went today and didn’t recognize anyone in there. Ordered our meals and was delivered in a timely manner. But the fries we much like the frozen you can buy at the grocery store. My meatball sandwich was barely warm. My wifes sandwich had about half the meat it should have had. Sadly it’s not the same quality as the previous owners.
… more
… View more