Based on 978 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
11367 Big Bend Rd, Riverview, FL 33579
Phone: (813) 644-7100
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Laura Teigue
We went here for pickup and when we got home there was a bug cooked into the pizza. I also ordered an antipasto salad and it didn’t have any of the meats and cheeses on it. I tried to call back but I was put on hold for a while so I ended up just hanging up. I guess if you’re going to order from here just check for bugs and that you received the right stuff.
… more
Olivia Downing
Amazing pizza, very fresh and perfectly cooked. I got the veggie pizza and the veggies were fresh and i loved that they used orange bell peppers! I thought that was so unique and delicious!! The owners are such kind and thoughtful people, my team at Watermelon Swim tried the pizza too and they couldn’t stop talking about how amazing it was!! Thank you NYNY Pizza!!!!!
… more
LionHeart
I have no idea why they call New York Pizza, I walked in there and asked for a chicken roll and they looked at me like I had three heads. The pizza is 5 out of ten at best but it’s the only one around that’s not commercial pizza, that’s probably the only reason they have any business. The staff does not know how to handle a volume of customers at all leaving wait times to be ridiculous. I’m 2 seconds away from opening up a pizza spot myself and putting them out of business.
… more
Alejandro Rios
This is my first and last time to order a pizza from this place, take me 50 minutes to get my order and I understand is a holiday and they must be busy (was the only choice at the time) I pick up my order and I have a surprise when I realize my pizza was missing the sausage, so I call them to complain they ask me to send some pictures to make it right and promised me a credit for my next purchase, after they received the text with the pictures they come with a conclusion. The sausage is there even is not, the funny part is when they said that sausage might be melted with the cheese. At this point I don’t expect anything from them I prefer to take my business somewhere else and avoid any kind of confrontation. My best advice is to check your order before you leave to make sure you’re getting what you are paying for.
… more
Irene Eng
Salty – coming from me, who loves salt.
… more
Greg Carlile
I used to frequently order from the Carrollwood location which was always a solid choice for pizza in that area. Although it’s a bit further than I’d normally go for carryout, I finally got over to this location in Riverview recently and it was consistently good, just like their other locations. Unfortunately, there are not very many great pizza options in Apollo Beach and this place is definitely worth the occasional inconvenience of dealing with the crazy traffic in Riverview.
… more
SEAN O’NEIL
Ordered a large 1 topping. It was ready at the time they said it would be. Definitely more expensive than chain pizza except it’s worth it. Will definitely order again.
… more
Ken W
Checked it out based on a friend’s recommendation. The pizza was delicious. It’s much better than the common chain restaurants. Definitely suggest ordering online and picking up as it was done exactly when they said it would be. You can not dine inside, so pick up or delivery are your only options.
… more
M
Our family orders from here on a regular basis and it’s always a great pizza or items that are moderately priced. Paper in store menus are not available (negative) but you can look online (positive) and service could be better but is adequate. No indoor seating available so it’s best to phone ahead to pick up. Door dash delivery is expensive. Pizza and sandwiches are excellent.
… more
Daniel St.Pierre
Stopped by for a slice of cheese pizza today, and for $2.69 I expected something more authentic. I was pretty disappointed with the pizza being heavy and way too much cheese for my taste. But always pale and almost undercooked. Just average, overpriced Pizza.
… more
… View more