New York Lunch-East Avenue Menu – Erie, PA

Type : Restaurant

Location : Erie, PA

Based on 553 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

New York Lunch-East Avenue 16503

Address:
922 East Ave, Erie, PA 16503

Phone: (814) 454-5591

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 9:30 AM–7 PM
Thursday 9:30 AM–7 PM
Friday 9:30 AM–7 PM
Saturday 9:30 AM–2 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed
Tuesday 9:30 AM–7 PM

Menu

Breakfast All Day
The Breakfast Special
2 extra large eggs, choice of 1 meat, home fries, toast and jelly		 $10.25
The Big Breakfast
3 large eggs and 2 sides of meat.		 $12.55
Greek Omelette
1 meat, cheese and Greek Sauce…It’s BIG!		 $15.05
Cheese Omelette
3 eggs, cheese		 $11.30
Western Omelette
Smith’s ham, peppers, onions, tomato and mushrooms		 $13.80
Smith’s Ham & Cheese Omelette $12.55
Spinach, Feta & Mushroom Omelette $13.80
French Toast
3 slices Texas toast powdered sugar and maple syrup		 $8.80
French Toast Breakfast
3 slices Texas toast powdered sugar and maple syrup, with 2 Egg and meat		 $10.05
Breakfast Sandwich
fried egg, cheese on Texas toast		 $6.30
Belgian Waffle
powdered sugar, whipped cream		 $7.55
Breakfast Waffle
Choice of meat, 2 large eggs		 $10.05
Tenders & Waffle
with syrup or honey		 $11.30
5 Wings & Waffle
with syrup		 $12.55
10 Wings & Waffle
with syrup		 $16.30
Fried Chicken Waffle Sandwich
Cheese, bacon, syrup, fries, onion rings or tots. Comes with fries.		 $12.55
Pancakes
Full Stack (4) Pancakes
w/ butter and syrup		 $6.30
Short Stack (2) Pancakes
2 pancakes w/ butter and syrup		 $5.05
Pancake Breakfast (2)
2XL eggs and your Choice of meat		 $10.05
Our Famous Greeks
Greek Burg $3.65
Double Greek Burg $4.30
Greek Cheese Burg $4.05
Double Greek Cheese Burg $4.90
Greek Dog $3.65
Greek Cheese Dog $4.05
Double Greek Cheese Dog $4.90
The Greek Specials
The Greek Special (3) $10.05
The Greek Special (6) $18.80
The Greek Special (12) $36.40
Lunch Special
2 Greek Dogs or Burgs, Small Greek Fries and a beverage.		 $12.55
Yeeros or Gyros…You Decide
Yeeros (Gyros)
Traditional (beef /lamb) chicken, steak or fish. Cucumber sauce, lettuce or fries, tomato and onion.		 $11.30
Yeeros (Gyros) Special
2 pcs.		 $20.10
Mega Yeeros (Gyros)
Traditional w/ shredded Steak		 $12.55
Mount Olympus Yeeros (Gyros)
All 3 Traditional, Steak and Chicken		 $15.05
Impossible (Meatless) Gyro $13.80
Falafel (Meatless) Gyro $11.30
Sandwiches
Chicken Spinach Feta In Pita
With tomato, onion and greek dressing. Also comes with fries.		 $13.80
Deluxe Chicken Sandwich
Kaiser roll cheese, bacon, LTO and mayo. Also comes with fries.		 $13.80
Philly Steak
On a kaiser or pita, grilled peppers, onions and cheese. Also comes with fries.		 $12.55
Shredded Steak & Cheese
Comes with fries.		 $12.55
Breaded Cod
Kaiser roll, tartar, cheese and lettuce. Also comes with fries.		 $12.55
BLT Sandwich
Comes with fries.		 $8.80
Smith’s Ham & Cheese
Comes with fries.		 $11.30
Grilled Cheese
Texas toast. Comes with fries.		 $8.80
Greek Grilled Cheese
Comes with fries.		 $11.30
Fried Chicken Slider (2)
Comes with fries.		 $10.05
Angry Chicken Slider (2)
Pepper rings, Pepper Jack cheese, hot sauce. Comes with fries.		 $11.30
Impossible Burger
Comes with fries.		 $13.80
Fried Chicken Waffle Sandwich
Cheese, bacon, syrup, fries, onion rings or tots. Comes with fries.		 $12.55
Smith’s Bologna Sandwich
Comes with fries.		 $9.15
1/4lb Burgs
First Quarter Burger $10.05
Second Quarter Burger $11.30
Third Quarter Burger $12.55
Fourth Quarter Burger $13.80
Over Time Burger
Stacked 5 High!		 $16.30
Texas Burger
2 stacked ¼ lbs. burgs, cheese, choice of sauce, onion ring and bacon all inside grilled Texas toast		 $13.80
More Stuff
Fish & Chips
(2) 6 oz. Battered Cod fillets, fries or tots, tartar sauce		 $13.80
Chicken Tenders
with fries or tots		 $11.30
Wings
5 Wings $11.30
10 Wings $15.05
Salads
New York Lunch Salad
Local organic lettuce and cucumbers, tomato Kalamata olives, Feta cheese, red onions and Greek dressing		 $11.30
BLT Salad
Lettuce, tomato, red onions, fried egg, bacon and Cheddar cheese		 $12.55
Kid’s Kitchen
Kids Egg Breakfast
1 egg, 2pc bacon or sausage, T&J		 $6.30
Kids French Toast
1pc French toast, 2cp bacon or sausage, T&J		 $6.30
Kids Pancake
1 Pancake, 2pc bacon or sausage, T&J Plain		 $6.30
Plain Smith’s Hot Dog
with fries and ketchup		 $6.30
Plain All Beef Hamburger
with fries and ketchup		 $6.30
Kids Grilled Cheese
with fries and ketchup		 $6.30
Kids Chicken Tenders
2 Tenders with fries and ketchup		 $6.30
Side Stuff
Butter $0.00
Corned Beef Hash $5.05
Dry $0.00
Extra Crispy $0.00
Grape Jelly $0.00
Grits $3.80
Large Battered Mushrooms $11.40
Large Cheese Sticks $11.40
Large Cheesy Fries $10.25
Large Cheesy Steak Fries $13.70
Large Cheesy Tots $10.25
Large Greek Fries $13.80
Large Greek Home Fries $12.55
Large Greek Tots $12.55
Large Home Fries $9.15
Large Just Fries $9.15
Large Onion Rings $11.40
Large Tater Tots $10.25
Rye Toast $1.60
Side French Toast (2) $3.15
Small Battered Mushrooms $6.85
Small Cheese Sticks $6.85
Small Cheesy Fries $6.85
Small Cheesy Steak Fries $8.00
Small Cheesy Tots $6.85
Small Greek Fries $8.80
Small Greek Home Fries $8.00
Small Greek Tots $8.00
Small Home Fries $5.70
Small Just Fries $5.70
Small Onion Rings $6.85
Small Tater Tots $5.70
Soft $0.00
Strawberry Jelly $0.00
Texas Toast $2.25
Wheat Toast $1.60
White Toast $1.60
To-Go
Greek Sauce To-Go | Pint
Need it Frozen? No Problem! Give us a 24hr notice and we will have it frozen to 0°F.		 $10.30
Greek Sauce To-Go | Cup
Need it Frozen? No Problem! Give us a 24hr notice and we will have it frozen to 0°F.		 $5.70
Greek Sauce To-Go | Quart
Need it Frozen? No Problem! Give us a 24hr notice and we will have it frozen to 0°F.		 $19.40
Chili Beans To-Go | Pint
Need it Frozen? No Problem! Give us a 24hr notice and we will have it frozen to 0°F.		 $8.00
Chili Beans To-Go | Cup
Need it Frozen? No Problem! Give us a 24hr notice and we will have it frozen to 0°F.		 $4.60
Chili Beans To-Go | Quart
Need it Frozen? No Problem! Give us a 24hr notice and we will have it frozen to 0°F.		 $13.70
Chili/Soup
Soup $5.05
Chili With Sauce $5.05
Chili $5.05

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Brosnan Pierce
The food here is pretty good. I got a 2 patty burger with fries and a big peanut butter milkshake. The service is also very friendly and helpful. We received refills often and had fast service. The atmosphere here is unique all the photos of the history of eerie and the older buildings around.

… more

Rob B
When I was a kid I lived on 2nd & Hess for a couple of years and would ride my bike over to East Ave to eat Greek burgers. Many a newspaper tip went to this place.

… more

Patrick John
The owner has been here 53 years! Recently renovated but the old school Greek menu is still intact. If you come to Erie you must try a Greek dog or burg especially from New York Lunch!

… more

Adam -Void-
My First visit to NY lunch E. Ave.

… more

Roots Chocolates
Great service and friendly staff! There is allot of memorabilia on the walls to give you something to look at while waiting for your food.

… more

Mark DeDionisio
It is always a treat to visit Steve and Nina. Unfortunately, I had to visit late in the day and missed seeing them. I had been yearning for my Greeks, and I wasn’t disappointed. The burgers, dogs, and Greek fries were spectacular, as always, and my server was super attentive and helpful.

… more

Jack Guritza
I was in town with my family for a mini vacation. We stopped by New York Lunch East Ave for dinner and we are so glad we did.

… more

Mary Moore
Great place all around. Owner walk around asking how you are even if you haven’t been there before and then remembers you the next time you stop. Great waiters and waitresses.

… more

Co Re
I don’t give much 5 stars. But their simple menu and great Greek sauce, plus traditional gyros, are a diamond in the ruff.

… more

uneika beason
The family owners are wonderful! Food is good and offers a welcoming atmosphere. Husband and I enjoy Saturday mornings here when we can.

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Pampered Palate Cafe & Bistro Menu – Erie, PA
  2. Country Pride Menu – Erie, PA
  3. Burger King Menu – Erie, PA
  4. La Chona Movil Menu – Erie, PA

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch