Local pizzeria chain serving pies, pasta, subs & salads in a relaxed atmosphere. Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
Address:
8305 Ice Crystal Dr, Laurel, MD 20723
Website: https://www.newyorkjandppizza.com/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Samuel Shiao
A really spacious but otherwise pretty standard Italian restaurant. There wasn’t any music playing and we were seated by ourselves in a big space so it had kind of an eerie quiet feel to it. However, service was friendly, helpful and quick! We had the carbonara and it was pretty good.
… more
Tugce Cemre
I love the food here. I try something new every time, and it is always delicious.
… more
Katie Morton
The food is amazing! I’ve never had a bad meal here. We order dinner here probably twice a week and have been for years. I’ve tried lots of dishes on the menu including many of the pasta dishes, many different types of pizza, chicken dishes, salads, appetizers, and everything is really delicious. The customer service is always kind, prompt, courteous, and friendly. Highly recommend!
… more
Pat Jackson
Rude folks who are dishonest. Food prep and dishonesty don’t mix. I ordered a cheese pie and something tasted very very strange. I complained and was told to come back for another one, a replacement. I went back and he the manager wants to try to bill me again and said he didn’t recall telling he would provide a replacement. Really. Who serves pizza with little to no sauce that taste spoiled or sour. Come on. I would not trust this place. I am from NY and this is a insult to say NY style pizza when it taste like a 5 year old made it. AVOID!!!
… more
C & S Fanning
Very poor customer service. We’ve eaten at the restaurant multiple times, my wife has always called for takeout. Calling for the first time, I needed a little more attention to ensure I received the best value since I was ordering multiple pizzas with coupons. After no more that a minute, the order taker became irritated and said she had other customers and go to their website, figure it out and call back, which I did.
… more
Anne Ballenger
A small glass entrance door had me fooled. To my surprise- live music, ample seating and the owner sitting at reception awaiting my order. Even though it was 9:30 pm, the atmosphere was lively. The gentleman owner is, of course, from Italy. He makes his “sauce” and lasagna daily. That evening I wanted something quick, filling, and still semi- Italian. For 11 bucks, I received a Very Good cheese steak with the works AND fries! That’s quite a deal folks! Plus free live music- I almost wished that they took longer to make it. They were quick too. I look forward to going back for the lasagna and see if it measures up to my Nonna’s.
… more
Matthew Scutaro
This review is for takeout. As a New Yorker who moved to the area pretty recently I can say that this is the closest I’ve come to a good NY slice around here. I can’t speak to service much but they said the pizza would be ready in 15 and it was. The cheese was the perfect consistency and not overloaded. The sauce had a great tomato flavor rather than the sweeter sauces you get a lot around here, and it was distributed evenly and in just the right amount. The crust was crispy and flavorful even after a 15 minute car ride. Go here. This is good pizza.
… more
Lola Brown
My rating is based on a carry-out experience and the pizza itself. I ordered a small veggie pizza. I was told it would take about 20 – 30 minutes and the pizza was ready when I arrived. No issues there. Some places will open the lid of the pizza box to allow you to inspect the pizza prior to purchase to make sure everything is ok with you. This wasn’t done, but I checked myself, so no real issue there. I do think it is a good practice for the employees to initiate that “inspection process”, but I digress. Once I got home, I can tell you I was thoroughly disappointed and underwhelmed with the flavor of the pizza. Everything about the pizza was bland. Nothing but the fact that the pizza was so bland stood out to me. The crust had no flavor. The veggie toppings tasted like chopped up nothingness, and I barely tasted any sauce as I was eating a slice. This was my first, only, and last visit to this restaurant and the restaurant’s first, only, and last $14.48 from me. If there are other good meals on that extensive menu, I’ll never know.
… more
Sk8Bit
Definitely worth the visit, multiple times!! If you’re in the mood for quality pizza, from a friendly neighborhood restaurant, this is always my choice. With a clean environment and a happy staff it always a positive experience.
… more
Andrea Thomas Real Estate
I was nearby and needed to pick up dinner for hubs and me. I ordered the heart healthy dish of Chicken and Sauteed Vegetables but wanted broccoli added. No problem ! This dish is really yummy with a flavorful broth and low carb if you skip the garlic bread. Also got side salad which was fresh and crunchy. I’ll be back for sure.
… more
… View more