Pizzas, steaks & Reuben sandwiches in a familiar setting, plus a kids’ menu & craft beers. Based on 810 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
225 Everett St, Bryson City, NC 28713
Phone: (828) 488-0500
Website: https://nateandnickspizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jeremy Swartz
Really disappointing. Hey, they honor the advertised happy hour prices.
… more
Kathi Kreider
This place is horrible. My husband got the Spaghetti and Meatballs dinner and I ordered the Parmesan Meatball Sub. Both of us received burnt meatballs. The “house” chips tasted burnt as well. Even if the meatballs hadn’t been burnt, the sub had three little meatballs on it. You could close the bread completely at the top and never know there were meatballs inside. I DO NOT RECOMMEND!!
… more
Barry Knauer
Order at the counter and seat yourself. Food is delivered to your table in take out containers even if you’re eating in. They do bring paper plates, plastic cutlery and napkins. We had the Mediterranean Pizza which was excellent. Avoid the Lazy Bird Brown Ale in a can. Nasty stuff.
… more
Tayah Marisa
Amazing is an understatement. This was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Also, the portion sizes for the apps were perfect and everything was so fresh and flavorful. My group of 4 people ordered 3 appetizers and a large nantahala pizza (we added bacon to it). We were all stuffed by the end of it and very very satisfied. 11/10!!!!
… more
Matthew
The pizza, cheesesticks, salad and Buffalo chicken sandwich was all good. The restaurant service was excellent, but you have to go up to a register to order and pay at the same time. The tea needed to be sweeter and if you ask for extras like a cup of ranch it is an extra charge. The air conditioner was out in the restaurant and it was 79 deg on the adjustment on wall and was set to 72 deg. Almost too hot to eat inside restaurant.
… more
Bri
Food was amazing! However, it ended there. Due to lack of staff, we had to go to the front main cash register to order and pay (upon ordering). We were expected to tip then as well, but for what I’m truly not sure. We were given napkins, plastic silverware, and plastic cups and told to seat ourselves. We got our drinks and all refills ourselves. We went out to the patio area where we were the only people, but several tables were dirty. Our food was quick, but brought to us in plastic to-go containers. Not once were we checked on, and there was PLENTY of staff loitering around, whispering in clusters, and staring at their phones. I walked past them to fill our drinks multiple times. At one point they were hugging each other and discussing hugs. We were responsible for clearing our own table too. My husband said the club was amazing, and my chicken salad was also very good. But who wants to eat fried chicken with a cheap plastic fork?!
… more
Kayla Sexton
The lady that took my order over the phone was very patient and helped me tremendously. When I went to pick the food up, both workers I encountered were very friendly and quick to get my order. The food was very good! I’m not sure if they make their own hot sauce for the wings but it was amazing. Will definitely be ordering from here again!
… more
Fox A
Great Pizza! Partner really liked their fried pickles chips. Didn’t have to wait too long for our food either which was nice! Great customer service too!
… more
Jason Melendez
Ordered take out. Pizza and wings were awesome. The blazing sauce for the wings wasn’t as spicy as I was hoping, but the flavor was amazing, even on the pizza. The house made sauces are delicious. Definitely recommend.
… more
J Farrant
Absolutely garbage pizza. Never had a worse pizza in place that called themselves a restaurant. Greasy, nasty cheese that falls off the pizza if you try to pick a piece up. You have to walk back up to the front to order your food, then carry your paper plates and cups back to the table. Get your own drinks. They bring all your food out in to go containers. Save yourself time and money and go to Domino’s before eating this trash food.
… more
… View more