Based on 70 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
910 N Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL 34145
Phone: (239) 642-5662
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8:45 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Logan M.
Save your time and money. There are better options for pizza on Marco. My pizza was delivered with all the cheese and toppings were piled into one corner of the box. The driver or someone had obviously dropped the pizza but delivered it anyway.
… more
C E
Our pizza was fantastic. It’s neapolitan style pizza. Our kids loved their XL pepperoni and we loved our XL white pizza. Came hot and fresh. Driver called and offered to bring it to the room but we met him downstairs. Highly recommend.
… more
Vee Square
The staff were helpful and attentive. They were also diligently trying to juggle keeping up with orders and maintaining the the store/kitchen clean. Caesar salad – was fresh. Wings – not bad. Eggplant parmesan & pasta – was watery. Maybe next time will try the pizza on my next visit since there were several great reviews on it!
… more
Herb Savage
I got the classic and asked for crispy. With 6 toppings, it can get soggy, and it was. Aside from being soggy, it was good.
… more
Shelby Finger
I had an issue with Napoli on the Bay in the past when using DoorDash, but it turned out to be solely the fault of the app, not the restaurant. Their pizza is by far the best pizza on the island, and they are prompt with service. They have a great lunch deal; a coke and 2 slices of pizza for under $10. Great place!
… more
Nancy Trimboli
I grew up in NYC 40 years ago… not til now have I had a calzone that measured up. And they delivered it HOT to my condo!
… more
Todd Anderbery
I sailed down taking weeks around florida. Pizza junkie. Most places make fluff pie. That weak out of a box style BS you get from hotel room service. What I expect is a Crispy crust, good char on the cheese, a smooth sauce and just the right amount of seasoning and oil. Man, these guys got it right! If your from PA, Jersey, NY then you know pizza. This place knows how to make a pie! And the prices are perfect.
… more
Jake G
Wow, excellent pizza!!! We came here to fulfill our hunger after eating out at an expensive seafood place.
… more
DMA
Pizza was fantastic. Staff friendly. Finally found the pizza in Marco that I really like. Sausage and Cheese at Napoli on the Bay – Awesome!
… more
Melissa Kosubinsky
Service was very attentive and patient with regard to my questions of ingredients as I have a food allergy. I ordered a pepperoni pizza for pickup. I, originally, tried to order online for 15% discount, but couldn’t figure out how to add toppings on cheese pizza. ( I then called in the order.). This pizza tastes very flavorful, without being overbearing. Also, the crust was done, in my opinion, perfectly. It’s thinnest in the center then GRADUALLY gets thicker towards the crust…but not too thick, so you feel like you have to down a breadstick. It’s well done…not so it’s too floppy when you pick up your slice, and not overdone (you don’t feel like you’re chewing on cardboard). The pepperoni is a nice thickness and the pizza was not greasy. It’s what I would call an enjoyable, yet hearty, pizza that leaves you feeling glad you ate it. Satisfying and delicious! In addition, there is a parking spot out front if you are picking up your order so you don’t have to worry about spending forever trying to find a spot for something that should only take minutes. The establishment seemed clean and staff was courteous and friendly. I would go back!
… more
… View more