Nancy’s Pizza, inventors of the Stuffed Pizza, is now in Columbus, GA.
Nancy’s Original Stuffed Pizza was invented in 1971 by Nancy’s founders Rocco and Nancy Palese. A perfect balance of the rebellious spirit of 1970s America and centuries-old Italian traditions, the Stuffed Pizza is 2 1/2 inches high and features two layers of crust stuffed with cheese and toppings, and covered with our perfectly spiced sauce.
Chicago-style stuffed pizza is the draw at this restaurant also offering thin-crust pies & pastas. Based on 71 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5295 Whittlesey Blvd, Columbus, GA 31909
Phone: (762) 524-7525
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 1–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Monica Franklin
I stopped in for a quick dinner and I was glad I did. I got a medium thin crust. It was delicious. The cheese pull was amazing, it wasn’t over sauced. It was perfect. The guy who took my order was super friendly. I can’t to visit again.
… more
Asiel Gonzalez
I came here because of the hype online but, didn’t live up to it for me. This “pizza” is simply…okay. first time having deep dish like this. It’s almost like eating a mediocre lasagna. It’s piled with tomato sauce which completely overwhelms any other flavor. I hope you like tomatoes. Nancy’s was a one time deal for me..
… more
Payton
I absolutely LOVED Nancy’s pizza!!! Perfect sauce to cheese ratio with an awesome taste and super cheesy mozzarella reasonably priced and definitely the best bang for your buck in Columbus! The manager is a super sweet guy and very friendly with customers. Not to mention the Groovy vibe… my parents go the rustic crust and we’re very pleased with the taste, I myself got the thin crust and unlike most cardboard crunchy thin crusts, this was very light and fluffy! We also loved that they slice in squares making for easy to share and perfect for kiddos tiny bite sized pull apart pieces! Great place for pie and we will ABSOLUTELY be back!
… more
Cathryn Willmschen
My boyfriend and I shared a small stuffed cheese and pepperoni. The outer layer of crust was perfectly crispy, providing a delightful contrast to the gooey, melted cheese within. The tomato sauce was rich, tangy, and generously spread throughout the filling. It was expensive for a small pizza, but one slice is a perfect portion for my lunch.
… more
Wilbert Martinez
Ordered a large a lot of meat and it didn’t disappoint. The sauce to cheese ratio was just right and they were very generous with their meats. I’m from IL and I’ve had my share of Gino’s East, Giordano’s, and Lou Malnati’s and Nancy’s is up there. The only downside is the wait. They only do carry out or delivery. For carry out, they give you an estimate of approximately 35 minutes. My wait was more like 50 minutes. Granted, their website does say it’s just an estimate.
… more
Rene Casas
Pizza Rate: 7.2. Not bad at all. Fresh produce and friendly customer service.
… more
Office Ttee
SOOOO Good!!!! I used to order frozen pies like this from Giordanos. HANDS DOWN Nancy’s is the better choice, especially since it’s fresh and gives us an opportunity to support local. The pictures don’t do it justice. It’s a party in my mouth. Well worth the price. One slice is a meal. Glad to have this available in Columbus!
… more
Jim Jordan
True deep dish Chicago pizza with layers of cheese and toppings, ( the uncle Tony ) not just a thick crust wannabe. If this Is what you’re looking for it’s really good. We’re two old people( can’t eat like I use to ) so we’ll be able to eat on this thing for a couple of days. We’ll probably go back to our regular pizza source, but this will not disappoint, and a great experience.
… more
Joseph Bannon
First time there, ordered Chicago Beef and Hawaiian . There was no beef at all on the Chicago Beef and the quality of the ingredients was just okay. Big disappointment. $56 for 2 medium pizza, no one said thank you.
… more
Valeria Robinson
We were staying in Columbus for 4 days and decided to try Nancy’s. We ordered a large deep dish pizza with pepperoni and bacon, and was huge but very good! The large pizza was too much for 4 people, we left about 4 slices. Great service and the wait was about 35 mins, well worth the price!
… more
… View more