My Pi Pizza Menu – Chicago, IL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Chicago, IL

Chicago deep-dish & tavern-style thin-crust pizzas served in a straightforward eatery with a patio. Based on 262 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in

My Pi Pizza 60647

Address:
2010 N Damen Ave, Chicago, IL 60647

Phone: (773) 394-6900

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–9 PM

Holiday hours
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Little Guy’s Catering Menu
Turkey Breast
All natural turkey breast
Roast Beef
Tender, homemade & slow-roasted
Corned Beef
Cured on the premises for 7 days, slowly cooked for over 7 hours
Salami
Genoa aged salami
Ham
Kretschmer’s hickory smoked ham
Tuna Salad
Simple and superb, solid white albacore and Hellman’s mayo, the best!
Egg Salad
Gently tossed so it’s devilishly tasty
Chicken Salad
Slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, nuts & mayo
The 30-Pack
30 Li’l Guy Sandwiches*, served on one platter, Choice of 2 sides (1 quart each), 15 chocolate chip cookies
The Big 50
50 Li’l Guy Sandwiches*, served on two platters, Choice of 2 sides (2 quarts each), 25 chocolate chip cookies
Do It Yourself Platter
25 platter (Choice of 25 Li’l Guy Sandwiches*, sauces on the side, & platter)
$86.25
2 Pack Lunch Box
your choice of 2 Li’l Guys, your choice of a single serving side dish or chips chocolate chip cookie
$11.75
3 Pack Lunch Box
your choice of 3 Li’l Guys, your choice of a single serving side dish or chips, chocolate chip cookie
$14.95
Traditional Potato Salad
Our special version of the mayo / mustard classic with eggs, celery, et al
Pasta Salad
tri-color rotini, balsamic vinaigrette, feta, kalamata olives, & red onions
Pesto Penne
penne with pesto, mozzarella, & sun-dried tomatoes
Dinner Salad
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing
$32.95
Mandarin Orange Salad
Fresh greens, mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade mandarin orange vinaigrette
$37.95
Caesar Salad
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing
$32.95
Cobb Salad
tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing
$37.95
Chef’s Salad
Fresh greens, Roasted turkey, Kretschmar’s hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs with your choice of dressing
$37.95
40 Fudgy Brownie Bites $39.50
10 Chocolate Chip Cookies $22.50
20 Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies $22.50
Little Guy’s Sandwiches Menu
Dinner Salad
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing
Mandarin Orange Salad
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette
$11.25
Caesar Salad
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing
$9.50
Cobb Salad
tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing
$11.95
Chefs Salad
Roasted turkey, Kretschmar’s hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing
$11.95
Turkey $0.75
Roast Beef $0.75
Corned Beef $2.75
Ham
Salami
Tuna Salad $0.75
Egg Salad
Chicken Salad
Chicken Breast
Bacon
French
Rye
Hawaiian
Multi-Grain
Focaccia $0.50
Gluten-Free $1.50
Lettuce
Tomato
Onion
Cucumbers
Spinach
Green Peppers
Pickles
Sauerkraut
Giardiniera $0.50
Red Peppers $0.50
Hellmann’s Mayo
Pesto Mayo
1000 Island
Horseradish Mayo
Hummus
Dijon
Honey-Mustard
Brown Mustard
Yellow Mustard
Balsamic Vin
Italian
Potati Chips, Pickle And Reg Fountain Drink $2.99
American
Cheddar
Mozzarella
Muenster
Provolone
Swiss
Chuckie’s Delight
Solid white albacore tuna with Hellmann’s Mayo on multi-grain wheat with lettuce and tomato, Sorry Charlie!
Egg Salad-A-Rama
Light & fluffy egg salad on Hawaiian bread with LTO
Chicken Salad-A-Rama
Our slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, celey, walnuts, LTO and Hellmann’s mayo on Hawaiian bread
Veg-O-Rama
cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, onions, kalamata olives, feta cheese & hummus on wheat bread
$9.95
The Turkonator
turkey breast with LTO, and homemade honey-mustard sandwiched on French bread
Pesto Turkey
turkey breast, LTO, provolone, pesto-mayo served on tomato-focaccia
Damen Avenue Club
turkey breast, bacon, munster, LTO, and mayo on French bread
The Perfect Corner
home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket on rye w/ Dijon
Corned Beef-A-Liscious
home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket with LTO, 1000 Island on French
An American Ham
Kretschmar’s hickory-smoked ham, with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & Hellmann’s mayo on Hawaiian bread
The Franco-Italian
Genoa salami with provolone on French bread w/ spicy giardiniera, balsamic vinaigrette, lettuce, tomato & red onions
The Porker
Kretschmar’s ham, Genoa salami & pepperoni with provolone, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & balsamic vinaigrette on French bread
Beefaholic
homecooked roast beef with Dijon, lettuce, tomato, and red onion on French bread
Beef & Swiss
slow-roasted bottom round with horseradish sauce, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and red onions on French bread
Chicken Focaccia
Chicken breast with a pesto-mayo, mozzarella, LTO on tomato focaccia
Baked Turkonator
with Swiss cheese
Ruebenesque
our own home-cured & cooked corned beef brisket with sauerkraut, 1000 Island dressing, and Swiss cheese baked on rye
Ultimate Homemade Reuben
Only on Fridays & Saturdays. The first sandwich made with homemade-from-scratch, baked-to-order bread. That’s right! We bake the bread when you place your order with the best homemade corned beef, Bavarian sauerkraut, & Swiss cheese. 1000 Island o…
Chicken Caesar Florentine
Roasted chicken breast topped with spinach & mozzarella, baked on tomato focaccia with Caesar dressing
TKRB
Turkey & roast beef with Swiss & Cheddar baked on a French bread with LTO and thousand island
Hot Ham & Swiss
Kretschmar’s hickory-smoked ham with Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions, & Hellmann’s Mayo on French bread
Tuna Melt
Solid white albacore tuna salad-ized with Hellmann’s mayo topped with Cheddar and baked on French bread
Soup Of The Day
Shrimp & Sweet Potato Chowder
Available every Friday! A Li’l Guys original! Classic shrimp chowder with real chunks of shrimp in a creamy broth with sweet potatoes & cayenne pepper, bacon & sherry
Turkey
Tuna, RB or Turkey +$0.20 /sandwich, Corned Beef +$0.75 /sandwich
Roast Beef
Tuna, RB or Turkey +$0.20 /sandwich, Corned Beef +$0.75 /sandwich
Corned Beef
Tuna, RB or Turkey +$0.20 /sandwich, Corned Beef +$0.75 /sandwich
Salami
Ham
Tuna Salad
Chicken Salad
Egg Salad
Comes With Potato Chips
Upgrade To A Homemade Side Dish
Comes With A Regular Fountain Drink
Upgrade To A Real Fruit Smoothie
Turkey Breast
With homemade honey / dijon mustard. Grade A natural turkey breasts
$3.45
Roast Beef
With Dijon. Tender, homemade & slow-roasted choice flat bottom round
$3.45
Corned Beef
With Dijon. Cured in store for 7 days, slowly cooked for 12 hours
$4.00
Salami
With Dijon. Genoa aged salami
$3.25
Ham
With Hellmann’s mayo. Kretschmar’s smoked
$3.25
Tuna Salad
Simple and superb, made with solid white albacore, the best! Tossed with Hellmann’s Mayonnaise
$3.45
Egg Salad
Gently tossed so it’s devilishly tasty
$3.25
Chicken Salad
Slow-roasted chicken breast with Granny Smith apples, nuts & mayo
$3.25
Kids PB & J Li’l Guy $1.25
Kids Toasted Cheese Li’l Guy $1.25
Kids Pop $1.50
Milk Bottle $2.15
Traditional Potato Salad
Our special version of the classic made with Hellmann’s mayo, Dijon mustard, fresh hard-boiled eggs & crisp celery
Pasta Salad
Tri-color rotini, aged balsamic vinaigrette, feta, kalamata olives, & red onions
Pesto Penne
Our best seller! Penne pasta with fresh basil pesto, mozzarella, & sun-dried tomatoes
Potato Chips
Sea Salt, BBQ, Jalapeno, Salt & Vinegar
$1.75
Strawberry, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Strawberry, Blueberry, Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Strawberry, Raspberry, Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Blueberry, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Peach, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Mango, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Make Your Own!
Pick 2 fruits & a juice
Protein Shot $0.75
Ice Cream Or Frozen Yogurt $1.00
Coke
Diet
Sprite
Root Beer
Cream Soda
San Pellegrino: Blood OJ & Lemon
Juices: Apple
Turkey Breast $16.95
Slow-Roasted Roast Beef $16.95
Tender House-Cured Corned Beef $27.95
Kretschmer’s Hickory Smoked Ham $11.50
Genoa Salami $11.95
Tuna Salad
solid white albacore
$12.95
Egg Salad $7.95
Chicken Salad $10.95
Cookies: Chocolate Chip Or Peanut Butter $2.25
Brownies $3.95
Cheesecake
40 year old family recipe
$4.95
Main Menu
My Pi Special
Sausage or Pepperoni or Spinach with mushrooms, onions, & green peppers. No substitutions, Please!
Hawaiian Pizza
A classic combination! Kretchmar’s hickory smoked ham and pineapple with My Pi’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, & grated Romano cheese
Chicken Pesto Pizza
Slow-roasted all-natural chicken breast chunks, fresh baby spinach, My Pi’s signature tomato sauce, mozzarella, grated Romano, & fresh, homemade basil pesto drizzled on top
Stuffed Spinach Souffle
Fresh chopped baby spinach & mozzarella filling stuffed between two crusts, with twice the cheese of our deep dish pizza!
My Pi Mozzarella Garlic Bread
baked with creamy whipped butter, fresh garlic, and stuffed with mozzarella cheese
$7.95
Spicy Garlic Bread
Our open-faced cheesy garlic bread with a spice to it!
$4.50
Dinner Salad
Combination of seasonal fresh greens topped with carrots, cucumbers, tomatoes, croutons, and your choice of dressing
Mandarin Orange Salad
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette
$11.25
Caesar Salad
Fresh greens with croutons and a traditional homemade Caesar dressing
$9.50
Cobb Salad
tomatoes, chicken breast, eggs, blue cheese, & bacon on bed of fresh greens with your choice of dressing
$11.95
Chef’s Salad
Roasted turkey, Kretschmar’s hickory smoked ham, cheddar cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes & hard-boiled eggs on a bed of lettuce with your choice of dressing
$11.95
Cheese
Any Additional Ingredient
Ingredients: Sausage, Pepperoni, Canadin Bacon, Hamburger, Cheeseburger, Chicken Breast, Ham, Roast Beef, Anchovy, Mushroom, Onion, Green Peppers, Giardiniera, Jalepenos, Garlic, Black Olive, Green Olive, Artichokes, Fresh Spinach, Fresh Tomato, P…
Cheese
Any Additional Ingredient
Ingredients: Sausage, Pepperoni, Canadin Bacon, Hamburger, Cheeseburger, Chicken Breast, Ham, Roast Beef, Anchovy, Mushroom, Onion, Green Peppers, Giardiniera, Jalepenos, Garlic, Black Olive, Green Olive, Artichokes, Fresh Spinach, Fresh Tomato, P…
Four-Cheese
Mozzarella, provolone, bleu cheese, & Romano with a basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust
Modern Art Pizza
Artichokes, fresh tomato, garlic & mozzarella with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust
Sun-Dried Tomato
sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, provolone, & Romano cheese with our basil-pesto sauce brushed over our crispy thin crust
Strawberry, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Strawberry, Blueberry, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Strawberry, Raspberry, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Blueberry, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Peach, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Mango, Banana, & Juice
Your choice of orange, apple, or pineapple juice
Make Your Own!
Pick 2 fruits & a juice
Coke
Diet
Sprite
Root Beer
Cream Soda
San Pellegrino
Blood OJ & Lemon
Apple Juice
Chocolate Chip Cookies $2.25
Peanut Butter Cookies $2.25
Brownies $3.95
Cheesecake
30 year old family recipe
$4.95
Cheese $6.50
Each Additional Ingredient $1.59
1/2 Pint $4.25
Pint $7.25
Quart $12.95
Shrimp And Sweet Potato Chowder (Every Friday)
an original! Classic shrimp chowder with real chunks of shrimp in a creamy broth with sweet potatoes and cayenne pepper to give it a sweet spiciness finished with a touch of bacon and sherry
Chicken Noodle
Made from a homemade chicken stock
Tomato Basil
made from fresh tomatoes and basil
Portabella Posole
Another Li’l guys original! a vegetable chili broth with portabella mushrooms hominy corn and black beans. Such spicy flavor and healthy for you too.
New England Clam Chowder
The creamy one
French Onion
Onions are slowly simmered for hours
Baked Potato Soup
Baking the potatoes brings out their rich flavor, indulge yourself we’ll top it wit aged cheddar. (add 0.75) and or bacon (0.75).
Chili
Beefy version with beans
Cream Of Mushroom
A 40 Year old family recipe
Minestrone
Classic Italian soup
Broccoli
Fresh broccoli in a french veloute
Corn Chowder
a Light chowder with sparkling corn flavor
Vegan Menu
Vegan Spinach Special
Fresh Spinach, mushrooms, onions, & green peppers. (No substitutions, please!)
Vegan Sausage Special
Vegan Sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions, & green peppers. (No substitutions, please!)
Make Your Own
Start with a vegan cheese pizza and add any additional vegan ingredients you’d like
Additional Ingredient
Vegan Ingredients: Vegan Sausage (Charged as a premium ingredient), Fresh Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, Giardiniera, Jalapeno, Garlic, Black Olive, Green Olive, Artichoke (Charged as a premium ingredient), Fresh Spinach, Fresh Tomato, Pineapple, …
Personal Thin Crust
9″ Vegan cheese pizza and add additional vegan ingredients starting at $1.59/ingredient
$6.50
Vegan Garlic Bread
baked with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, and stuffed with vegan mozzarella cheese
$9.50
Vegan Delight Sandwich
Sriracha hummus, fresh mushrooms, cucumbers, spinach, carrots, tomato & red onion on 9-grain bread
$9.95
Daddy Pack
Add Potato Chips, Pickle & Regular Fountain Drink +$2.99
Vegan Orange Salad
Fresh greens, Mandarin oranges, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, & walnuts, served with our homemade Mandarin orange vinaigrette
Step 1: Bread
choose one: French, Rye 9-Grain, Focaccia (+$0.50)
Step 2: Veggies
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, Spinach, Green pepper, Mushroom, Sauerkraut, Carrot, Kalamata Olive, Black Olive, Pickles, Sauerkraut, Giardiniera (+$0.50), Red pepper (+$0.50), Pineapple
Step 3: Dressing
Hummus, Dijon, Italian, Brown Mustard, Yellow Mustard, Balsamic Vin, Sriracha Hummus
Optional Daddy Pack
Add Potato Chips, Pickle & Reg. Fountain Drink +$2.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Melinda Gaddy
Amazing take-out deep dish in a convenient location. The crust was crispy, toping were fresh, and it was delicious. Fast service, and there are a couple of small tables outside if you want to eat it there.

… more

Ebu Beerkens
The crust was thin and crispy, with a slight char from the wood-fired oven. It was chewy and flavorful, with a good balance of saltiness and sweetness.

… more

Guy Schwartz
Went to my pie on 8/1. Unfortunately, they were no serving single slices, so we had to order a small thin pizza for one of us. the remaining 3 of us shared a large dinner salad and a wonderful chicken pesto deep dish pizza. The salad was enough for 3 and the ingredients were fresh. The pizza was exceptionally good, and everyone enjoyed it. This is not an eat in type restaurant, they do have some bench type tables in a tent where you can eat your pizza.

… more

Charles Randazzo
My favorite pizza in the city. You can’t go wrong with the deep dish or thin crust, which is really impressive considering many pizzerias specialize in one or the other. I frequently order delivery through their app and the drivers are professional and FAST. Cannot recommend this place enough to friends, family, and neighbors.

… more

Stephen Suydam
The pizza was the lightest deep dish I have had, in a good way. It was the first time in a long time I finished eating deep dish and did not feel stuffed beyond repair. That being said, it was not indulgent enough for my liking. The staff was the friendliest crew I have ever met in a pizza joint.

… more

Metoya B
Food was great, I went for the Vegan Spinach Deep Dish Pizza and was totally satisfied. I traveled all the way from Country Club Hills to get this pizza that I had cold at Vegandale and enjoyed, only to find out they’re not dine in so it’s not a great place to take a group or a date. They have an outdoor tent set up, they bring your food out in the box with no plates or anything to eat on, no utensils, napkins, etc. The counter girl has zero personality and if im paying $25+ for a small pizza I’m gonna need you to perk up a little. Food is great, service and atmosphere could be better.

… more

Kimberly Awesome
No indoor dining. Take out & delivery only, which was not accurately reflected at their web page. Luckily, it was a nice day & they do have outdoor seating. We sought out this place, specifically for vegan deep dish. It was amazing! We order the vegan cheese pizza & a vegan spinach, which also has mushroom, onion & bell pepper. Scrumptious! The pie crust was perfect. I love that their sauce is not a puree but rather has chunk of San Marzano in it. They offer a thin crust also, that I did not try. Parking is very limited. Order ahead is recommended, because it literally took 30 minutes to get a deep dish. If you are ordering vegan, please emphasize that, because they serve omnivorous also. I had a little miscommunication with the person who took my order & ended with a pizza with dairy cheese. The server realized it when the pizza came out & made it right, but again had to wait another 30 min for the right pizza. All in all, a good experience & worth the time & effort for an exceptional vegan deep dish! Will recommend & plan to visit again.

… more

Jolene Stahn
Loveddd this vegan Chicago style deep dish pizza!! Very happy they had vegan pizza!

… more

Contessa Xo
Well pickup was not the nicest. The pickup space is so tiny. Only 3 people can fit. So waiting in the cold for longer than 15 mins isn’t fun. Even more when the cashier is lollygagging. I finally get my pizza. And to be honest it’s dry. Bare minimum sauce and it’s thin but not even crispy. I got the thin sausage pizza. For $22 a medium with this quality makes me feel cheated. I could have went to Fiesta Pizza and got a medium sausage for $10 and it’s better quality!!

… more

Stirfryable
This place is completely under the radar, and I have to say their personal tavern style pizza is one of my favorite deals in the whole city. You can pick it up and bring it along to a visit to the nearby Map Room. That’s a full Chicago experience. Amazing texture of the crust and great flavor. Really recommend!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions